He’s about to speak, after an introductory video. I’ll update this post as often as possible with my thoughts, but comment away. This will become the Obama speech thread.
8:05 Mountain Time: This biographical video is slow-paced, calming after all the pump-you-up music, full of pictures of Obama through the years, and all about Durbin’s message that “after this long campaign, so many of us know this man.” Or, if you don’t, you will now. The point: That Obama should come out of this convention no longer an unknown quantity to anyone who cares to pay attention.
8:10 Obama enters, dark suit and red tie, U2’s “City of Blinding Lights” playing. This has been his campaign theme song for a long time—it’s taking me back to Iowa.
8:14 The crowd won’t be quited. The thunderous foot-stamping is back.
8:16 The usual nod to Hillary and Bill Clinton—but no foot-stamping thunder from the crowd for those two.
8:18 Keeping it subdued and grounded in economic concerns. But he’s just getting going.
8:20 “Enough!” The Democratic message this year boiled down to one word.
8:23 The stadium is almost completely full. I can’t give you any more pictures like the ones below, because it’s too dark, but I see only a smattering of empty seats and those are mainly the ones with no clear sight-line to the podium.
8:25 The paean to McCain’s military service out of the way, Obama is really taking him down—in a calm, smooth, but very tough way. “Now, I don’t believe that Senator McCain doesn’t care what’s going on in the lives of Americans. I just think he doesn’t know. Why else would he define middle class as someone making under five-million dollars a year?”
8:28 A recapitulation of the “Enough!” theme. Obama now says of the Republicans, “It’s time for them to own their own failure.”
8:30 Obama, by filling a huge stadium, set himself up for more “celebrity” attacks. He just put up a shield, wrapping the story of struggling Americans into his own story, talking about being raised by a single mother, and then saying: “I don’t know what kind of lives John McCain thinks that celebrities lead, but this has been mine. These are my heroes. Theirs are the stories that shaped me. And it is on their behalf that I intend to win this election and keep our promise alive as President of the United States.” Take that, Paris and Britney.
8:35 This is a wonderfully-constructed speech. Watch how finely it is woven, paced, built to deliver all the necessary bits in fine rhythm. We are now in a State-of-the-Union-style section of promises about what Obama will do as president. He is doing here what Bill Clinton often did so well: Making the sell, pulling out the contract and going over the points like a traveling salesman, letting the audience see how great things will be if… only…
8:37 In some ways I wish I hadn’t been following this campaign for so long, because then I would know how most of the people tuning in are processing this speech. Stories like the one, just now, of his mother having to haggle with insurance companies while she was dying of cancer—I’ve had that one fed to me so often over the last year that it now tastes like nothing. Or like old cardboard. But I am not the intended audience.
8:41 And now, with his family and background introduced, and his promises laid out, we are into foreign policy. “If John McCain wants to have a debate about who has the temperament, and judgment, to serve as the next Commander in Chief, that’s a debate I’m ready to have.” What we are seeing here is Obama kicking McCain’s national security cred out from under him by calling him old, confused, hot-headed, dishonest, and just plain wrong—all in much subtler language of course.
8:45 “John McCain likes to say that he’ll follow bin Laden to the Gates of Hell—but he won’t even follow him to the cave where he lives.”
8:47 This is a tremendously strong promise of redemption to Democrats. He is promising to cast off the sense the Democrats can’t own national security and patriotism. “We are the party of Roosevelt. We are the party of Kennedy. So don’t tell me that Democrats won’t defend this country. Don’t tell me that Democrats won’t keep us safe.”
8:50 Throwing the lack-of-patriotism charge right back in McCain’s face. “I love this country, and so do you, John McCain. The men and women who serve in our battlefields may be Democrats and Republicans and Independents, but they have fought together and bled together and some died together under the same proud flag. They have not served a red America or a blue America—they have served the United States of America. So I’ve got news for you, John McCain: We all put our country first.”
That is a very hard slam against McCain’s “Country First” slogan, a jingoistic rallying cry that may be somewhat effective, and that the Obama campaign hasn’t taken on directly until now.
8:54 We are moving toward the close. His political case made (even mentioning the gays by their gay name!), Obama will now make his emotional case. “All across America something is stirring…”
8:56 Get your hankies, people. Here’s the reference to King: “‘We cannot walk alone,’ the preacher cried. ‘And as we walk, we must make the pledge that we shall always march ahead. We cannot turn back.’”
8:58 And it ends, and the crowd explodes, and the fireworks and confetti shoot off, and now we see the genius of the backdrop. It is for this shot at the end, when the potential new first family, a first family like America has never seen before, hugs, kisses, and walks arm-in-arm toward us on our screens from something that looks very much like the White House. If it can be imagined, maybe it can be made real.
9:02 And again, as with Wednesday night at the Pepsi Center, the entire, huge Biden family, in all its whiteness, comes out and warmly envelops the Obama family, absorbs the four black figures into a mass of welcoming white figures. Again: If it can be imagined, maybe it can be made real.
9:05 They all walk together into the White House—I mean, the backdrop.
9:07 The closing prayer. I’ve sat through a lot of these opening and closing prayers this week. I’ve been blessed by Jews and Muslims and Native Americans and Latinos and African American baptists. But now, with the whole country watching, I am, naturally, being blessed by the whitest of Jesus-thanking pastors.
9:10 Pelosi comes out to close the convention. I have to say I really like this idea of Robert’s Rules roving around a city. She asks for a motion to adjourn. She gets it, along with an asked-for promise that the audience will work for victory. And then she closes the convention with a rather wilting, thrice-repeated “Yes we can.”
9:13 Here’s what I think: I think Obama was, as usual, near flawless in his delivery. I think the whole staging and pacing of it was a tremendous bit of political theater. I think that he avoided all the right things: soaring too high; overtly suggesting a comparison between himself to MLK on this anniversary of the “Dream” speech; coming off as too light-weight or without a taste for blood. I think the idea of opening the convention, by way of inviting the public to a giant stadium on the last night, was very smart, especially in a swing state such as this one. And I think Obama has set himself up very well for the next big moment: the debates. He’ll be respectful of McCain’s service and accomplishments, but he won’t shrink from pointing out McCain’s failures and the feebleness of McCain’s ideas.
Perhaps—or, quite probably—Obama could have delivered a more soaring, more intricate, more detailed speech. But he didn’t need to. He needed to prove he could speak to, and relate to, the average American. And he did.