The “real” Donnie Davies singing “It’s Not Okay to be Gay.”
Courtesy of a Josef, who sent this observation along with the clip: “Davies is too exaggerated, too much a caricature to be legit.” Agreed, Josef. But who is Davies spoofing? The still-gays? Or the ex-gays?
That reminds me of the bullshit pastor "Brother Matt" who used to come to my university campus (Southern OR) twice a year to yell at the students that we're heathens, sodomites, going to hell, etc. I hear that Matt goes up and down I-5 all year and he goes up to Washington too.
This Donnie guy is just strange.
Dan, When is this video supposed to have been taken? (and what's with the beard)
That video clip was taken at Central Washington University. 90 minutes from Seattle, in Ellensburg.
I think Davies is spoofing the ex-gays. But here's something a satirist should think about: does my satire hit its intended target? What's the collatoral damage?
Because Davies' work - even though I know he's a spoof, and even though I know he's aimed at the asshole ex-gay movement - still hurts a little and it's really scary. Because the satire is so dead on, because I know that a lot of people think that god hates fags. Being reminded of that by Davies, who lacks the, er, well, compassion, I guess, of a Colbert, wasn't funny. Even while it was funny.
Know what I mean? And I think that's why Dan and others (like me) have been kind of obsessive.
No, cancel that. It's not compassion that Davies lacks - though he doesn't seem to have much. It's precision. He's not precicely targeting his satire. It comes off so broadly that it offends many of the people I think Davies is trying to speak for.
When Colbert attacks a fundie, often by agreeing with his target's statements on gays and the poor, gays and poor people never question what side Colbert is on. We know he's our guy. With Davies, we're not so sure.
josef, yeah I know what you mean, why do you think I keep refreshing the SLOG today for updates about this Donnie character. He freaks me out, and I just don't know if he's spoofing or not. This whole thing just smacks of the crap I grew up with being the dyke atheist in Puyallup.
Just trying to keep my friends close and my enemies closer.
Do you know what year was this video taken?
I don't think Dan is the only one obsessing! Anyway, yeah, that guy looks way too old to be Donnie Davies. Maybe it's a fake beard?
We used to have a guy like this on our campus at Oklahoma State...he would stand in the middle of the quad, shouting about sodomites and feminists going to hell...but also Baptists. Which actually, is pretty funny--the Baptists weren't used to being grouped with homosexuals and feminists!
Comments
Someone should exorcize Mister Savage of his obsession.
Yo, it's seriously getting OUT of CONTROL.
Sorry, Rupert, but I cleared it with the editor. He said I could keep right on obsessing.
That reminds me of the bullshit pastor "Brother Matt" who used to come to my university campus (Southern OR) twice a year to yell at the students that we're heathens, sodomites, going to hell, etc. I hear that Matt goes up and down I-5 all year and he goes up to Washington too.
This Donnie guy is just strange.
Dan, When is this video supposed to have been taken? (and what's with the beard)
That video clip was taken at Central Washington University. 90 minutes from Seattle, in Ellensburg.
I think Davies is spoofing the ex-gays. But here's something a satirist should think about: does my satire hit its intended target? What's the collatoral damage?
Because Davies' work - even though I know he's a spoof, and even though I know he's aimed at the asshole ex-gay movement - still hurts a little and it's really scary. Because the satire is so dead on, because I know that a lot of people think that god hates fags. Being reminded of that by Davies, who lacks the, er, well, compassion, I guess, of a Colbert, wasn't funny. Even while it was funny.
Know what I mean? And I think that's why Dan and others (like me) have been kind of obsessive.
No, cancel that. It's not compassion that Davies lacks - though he doesn't seem to have much. It's precision. He's not precicely targeting his satire. It comes off so broadly that it offends many of the people I think Davies is trying to speak for.
When Colbert attacks a fundie, often by agreeing with his target's statements on gays and the poor, gays and poor people never question what side Colbert is on. We know he's our guy. With Davies, we're not so sure.
josef, yeah I know what you mean, why do you think I keep refreshing the SLOG today for updates about this Donnie character. He freaks me out, and I just don't know if he's spoofing or not. This whole thing just smacks of the crap I grew up with being the dyke atheist in Puyallup.
Just trying to keep my friends close and my enemies closer.
Do you know what year was this video taken?
I thought you were the editor?
I don't know when it was taken. It was posted to YouTube on 10/19/2006.
This one isn't a satire, of course, but it's easier for me to shrug off than Davies' number.
I am now officially glossing over these posts. Josh's abstinence education rifes are better written and less annoying.
Thanks for scouring the web and posting your findings. It makes it easy for me to be lazy and yet still up to date!
Okay, Boomer. Keep us updated, k?
That dude looks about 60. Isn't Donnie 27?
I don't think Dan is the only one obsessing! Anyway, yeah, that guy looks way too old to be Donnie Davies. Maybe it's a fake beard?
We used to have a guy like this on our campus at Oklahoma State...he would stand in the middle of the quad, shouting about sodomites and feminists going to hell...but also Baptists. Which actually, is pretty funny--the Baptists weren't used to being grouped with homosexuals and feminists!
Maybe the reason it's hard to tell if it's satire is because it's real. Just because it's so exaggerated doesn't mean it isn't sincere.
On the contrary, it's ok to be gay.
Comments Closed
In order to combat spam, we are no longer accepting comments on this post (or any post more than 14 days old).