Slog

News & Arts

The Stranger Suggests

Critics' Best Bets
Music Arts & Food


Line Out

Music & the City
at Night

Thursday, March 14, 2013

Bradley Manning in His Own Words

Posted by on Thu, Mar 14, 2013 at 10:04 AM

The nonprofit Freedom of the Press Foundation has released hour-long audio and a transcript of Pfc. Bradley Manning, in his own words, to the world—about his time in the military, his dismay at the kill-and-capture attitude towards entire nations of people the US was ostensibly trying to "liberate," and why he decided to work with Wikileaks.

From Guardian reporter Glenn Greenwald:

The court-martial proceeding of Bradley Manning has, rather ironically, been shrouded in extreme secrecy, often exceeding even that which prevails at Guantanamo military commissions. This secrecy prompted the Center for Constitutional Rights to commence formal legal action on behalf of several journalists and activists, including myself, to compel greater transparency. One particularly oppressive rule governing the Manning trial has barred not only all video or audio recordings of the proceedings, but also any photographs being taken of Manning or even transcripts made of what is said in court. Combined with the prohibition on all press interviews with him, this extraordinary secrecy regime has meant that, in the two-and-a-half years since his arrest, the world has been prevented, literally, from hearing Manning's voice.

Huh. Sounds similar to a certain legal situation in this week's news section.

Manning seems to disclose pretty much everything, including his rocky relationship with his boyfriend in the states ("he did not seem very excited about my return from Iraq"). Manning is human. And the government informant who turned him in claimed to be a journalist and a pastor who'd promised him confidentiality.

Talk about a chilling effect.

But more to the point, Manning talks about why he did what he did—after seeing videos of soldiers merrily shooting civilians and journalists, a lack of critical thinking about why certain people were on "target lists" (which might have had more to do with domestic beefs than terrorism), and how the American people were being kept in the dark about what the US was doing in these highly publicized wars.

Manning's tone is clinical but what he describes is damning—the US military working against democracy, against the exercise of speech and political dissent, against the purported reasons our military invaded in the first place.

One excerpt:

Over the course of my research I found that none of the individuals had previous ties to anti-Iraqi actions or suspected terrorist militia groups. A few hours later, I received several reports from the scene – from this subordinate battalion. They were accidentally sent to an officer on a different team on the S2 section and she forwarded them to me...

The top OIC and the overhearing battle captain informed me that they didn't need or want to know this information anymore. They told me to quote 'drop it' unquote and to just assist them and the Federal Police in finding out, where more of these print shops creating quote "anti-Iraqi literature" unquote.

I couldn't believe what I heard and I returned to the T-SCIF and complained to the other analysts and my section NCOIC about what happened. Some were sympathetic, but no one wanted to do anything about it...

I knew that if I continued to assist the Baghdad Federal Police in identifying the political opponents of Prime Minister al-Maliki, those people would be arrested and in the custody of the Special Unit of the Baghdad Federal Police and very likely tortured and not seen again for a very long time – if ever.

Instead of assisting the Special Unit of the Baghdad Federal Police, I decided to take the information and expose it to the [WikiLeaks organization], in the hope that before the upcoming 7 March 2010 election, they could generate some immediate press on the issue and prevent this unit of the Federal Police from continuing to crack down in political opponents of al-Maliki.

Find the rest here.

 

Comments (17) RSS

Oldest First Unregistered On Registered On Add a comment
venomlash 1
Well if he wanted to stamp out injustice in the dealings of the American military, he should have only brought to light the relevant information, instead of giving everything to Wikileaks.
It's like weeding a garden with napalm.
Posted by venomlash on March 14, 2013 at 10:45 AM
Pol Pot 2
Manning should get a congressional Medal of Honor.
Posted by Pol Pot http://bottlefuelrag.blogspot.com on March 14, 2013 at 11:06 AM
GeneStoner 3
The dude is no hero, despite what he thinks.

He went in with malice aforethought and pre-conceived notions, took a position of trust in military intel, and then stood behind his homosexuality as a victim to conduct illegal activities that caused grave harm to the US.

He should have joined the Peace Corps.
Posted by GeneStoner on March 14, 2013 at 11:07 AM
inGage 4
Bradley Manning is a TRUE patriot. He stood up for the morals he believed in, specifically that people shouldn't be dehumanized and murdered by a US Military filled with immature bullies that are the same asshats they were in high school. The primary change being they have more bravado and less empathy. The men in the helicopter responsible for gunning down innocent civilian reporters and children without remorse, have been trained on the mechanics of death. Yet they still don't comprehend it's true cost and are most likely in desperate need of psychiatric assistance. (side note: This isn't headline news in the USA.. To get this news, we have to go to the UK. Wonder why.. .)
Posted by inGage on March 14, 2013 at 11:09 AM
5
@1 illustrates the typical sociopathic, fully indoctrinated mindset so prevalent today, although extending across the age spectrum, it is exceedingly abundant among those forty years of age and younger.

Obviously, many stories demonstrate that papers such as the NY Times have sat on, or rolled over on, stories at the request of the gov't and Wall Street elites.

Judy Miller and her planted stories in the NY Times (for her buddy Dick Cheney) strongly suggesting the existence of weapons-of-mass-destruction in Iraq (and Miller goes on to a highly lucrative position at the neocon Manhattan Institute), and many others, indicate their disposition to anything as inflamatory as "Collateral Murder" and the colossal and damning information gleaned from the Cablegate release (we all know that venomlash has yet to finish a single book, assuming she/he/it has ever even cracked one?).

Bradley Manning is a true American hero, as was the misguided (too much TV, perhaps) former ballplayer, Tillman, who died from "friendly fire" in Afghanistan. Tillman --- and probably once Mr. Manning --- believe in the American propaganda spewed forth from Wall Street's cinema, proclaiming the exceptionalism of Amerika, and the evils of everyone else.

Is Hillary Clinton, former chair of the MCC, which funded the overthrow of the democratically-elected, and populist president of Honduras, Zelaya, a great American, or an enemy of democracy?

Obviously, an enemy of democracy, as are Obama, Biden, Holder, Cheney, Rumsfeld, the Bush family et al.
Posted by sgt_doom on March 14, 2013 at 11:15 AM
GeneStoner 6
Why do I feel like the posters here who are calling PFC Manning a "TRUE American hero" really have no clue as to what a hero is...

Posted by GeneStoner on March 14, 2013 at 11:33 AM
Fnarf 7
I think the real answer to the Manning story is somewhere in between the two extremes here. While a number of things he exposed were necessary to see, it is insane to think that he was ever in a million years going to get away with it.

The outrage in his treatment is the secrecy and lack of due process attached to it. But he has at last been exposed to light, and will in fact get a trial. He's going to spend the rest of his life in jail, guaranteed. But I don't think his case has done anywhere near the damage to habeas corpus that Jose Padilla's did, or to the US's open embrace of torture.

And we have the stuff. The torture documents are the important ones, and we're going to be hearing about them for a long time to come. I'd really like to see Cheney in the cell next to him, of course, but the damage to his reputation, and Bush's, will probably be enough. Bush would be able to paint all he wants in a cell.
Posted by Fnarf http://www.facebook.com/fnarf on March 14, 2013 at 11:38 AM
Cato the Younger Younger 8
@6, I assume for you the real heros are the soldiers who joyously shot up a bunch of innocent people? Actually I have read some of your other comments and that probably answers my question.

But if you actually value doing the right thing and moral thing the US Corporate Military isn't the job for you. Manning should have been born 300 years later, he's Star Fleet material...not US Army material
Posted by Cato the Younger Younger on March 14, 2013 at 11:39 AM
Posted by anon1256 on March 14, 2013 at 11:44 AM
Pope Peabrain 10
What was happening was unjust. If he had reported to the chain of command, he would have done his duty. He chose instead, despite what he knew was a serious offense that could never be tolerated for many reasons, to go the route he went. I know heroes sometimes fall on grenades and sacrifice their life for the lives of others. That's what he did. His life is over.
Posted by Pope Peabrain on March 14, 2013 at 11:59 AM
Sir Vic 11
@7 The other very important element that is forgotten: nearly 1 million people have security clearances in the War on Terror! A leak like this was going to happen eventually with that large of a group. The size of the military intelligence apparatus is the real threat to civil liberties.
Posted by Sir Vic on March 14, 2013 at 12:24 PM
venomlash 12
Ew, the only one here agreeing with me is GeneStoner. I need to take a shower.
Well no, I'm on the same page as Fnarf mostly. (I think his trial should be in the public eye.)
Actually do need to go shower though, so see yas.
Posted by venomlash on March 14, 2013 at 12:53 PM
treacle 13
@1,12 - I think that there was absolutely no way to "stamp out injustice" in the way you describe. I think that is remarkably naïve. Merely exposing a few crimes would have resulted in no net change of course -- like so many examples before. (e.g. Guantanamo, Abu Ghraib, Blackwater, etc. etc.)

The Wikileaks cache exposes the clearer picture of the corruption and Machiavellian diplomacy at the core of US foreign policy. And it allows journalists & foreign gov'ts to gain a clearer picture of the dragon they are dealing with, --now and whenever they need to do keyword searches in those documents-- thereby balancing the tables just a little bit more.

Manning took his morals to the universal level, after he saw that the one side he pledged his allegiance to was actively betraying him and it's own stated code of conduct.
Posted by treacle on March 14, 2013 at 1:36 PM
gloomy gus 14
I agree with you too, @12, FWIW. Napalm to mow the lawn is very apt.
Posted by gloomy gus on March 14, 2013 at 1:38 PM
Fenrox 15
It's strange, It's like you guys are watching a video where Manning is bitching about not getting room service and pouting that he got caught at all.

He accepted responsibility and is awaiting punishment. He knew that he would be railroaded and denied normal justice. He did it anyway. OTHERS are calling him a hero.

What is the definition of a hero? SOMEONE WHO DISPLAYS COURAGE OR IS A DAMN COMIC CHARACTER. Hero is a meaningless term, you can't misuse it.
Posted by Fenrox on March 14, 2013 at 1:45 PM
16
"Napalm to mow the lawn is very apt"

Garden/lawn is revealing of the way you think of the empire.
Posted by anon1256 on March 14, 2013 at 2:52 PM
17
Uh, Brendan? Greenwald is an opinion columnist for the Guardian, not a reporter.

(Unless you feel like classing Rush Limbaugh as a reporter for the EIB Network - gag!)
Posted by DonServo on March 14, 2013 at 4:19 PM

Add a comment

Advertisement
 

Want great deals and a chance to win tickets to the best shows in Seattle? Join The Stranger Presents email list!


All contents © Index Newspapers, LLC
1535 11th Ave (Third Floor), Seattle, WA 98122
Contact Info | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Takedown Policy