Slog

News & Arts

The Stranger Suggests

Critics' Best Bets
Music Arts & Food


Line Out

Music & the City
at Night

Tuesday, November 27, 2012

Cardinal Dolan Appropriates Famous Catholic Leftist Dorothy Day... As a Symbol of the Fight Against National Healthcare?

Posted by on Tue, Nov 27, 2012 at 10:25 AM

The conservative Cardinal Timothy Dolan has seized on a new cause—the canonization of Catholic anarchist, pacifist, pro-labor, and pro-immigrant radical Dorothy Day.

The move is political, of course, as Day was a powerful woman who appealed to both the pro-life side of the church (she had an abortion herself, which she later regretted) and the radical leftist side of the church (she co-founded the Catholic Worker movement, was a self-described anarchist, and accepted Abbie Hoffman's declaration that she was "the first hippie").

Now that the church is splintering between its pro-Vatican right (which Dolan represents to the hilt) and its pro-nun, pro-helping-the-poor left (not to mention the spanking the religious right received in the November elections), it makes sense for a politically ambitious American cardinal to find a bridge cause. But the weirdest thing about Dolan's embrace of Day is his attempt to leverage her anarchist legacy to oppose national health care.

NYT:

But bishops now say Day’s life resonates with the struggles that they are most engaged in today: the fight against abortion and their concern about government intrusion in their affairs. In her radical rejection of government — Day believed all states were inherently totalitarian — the bishops see echoes of their fight with the Obama administration over health care.

So Dolan supports Day's anti-statism not when it comes to capital punishment or war—when talking about his thoughts regarding President Bush on those two issues, Dolan said "I would have to give him the benefit of the doubt to say that those two issues are open to some discussion and are not intrinsically evil"—but when it comes to health care?

How craven can you get?

Of course, it shouldn't surprise us. This is the same Cardinal Dolan of the infamous $20,000 incentives for sexually abusive priests to leave the vocation (payoffs, not prisons!) and the threats to cut charitable services because of contraception provisions in the national health-care bill.

Day supposedly once said: "Don’t trivialize me by trying to make me a saint." She saw through the machinations of religious leaders like Cardinal Dolan who would canonize someone for their own political gain.

 

Comments (7) RSS

Oldest First Unregistered On Registered On Add a comment
Pope Peabrain 1
If we made the church carry the cost of unwanted pregnancy, they'd change their tune, fast. And isn't the church totalitarian? Clearly they still think they're above the law. We've moved on. They lost, unless they can get the papists on SCOTUS to side with them.
Posted by Pope Peabrain on November 27, 2012 at 11:58 AM
Knat 2
Since when has the Catholic Church met a totalitarian state that it didn't like?

I guess it's when that "totalitarian" state is lawfully elected by the people and it dares to attempt widening its citizens' access to affordable healthcare. What a weird distinction.
Posted by Knat on November 27, 2012 at 2:02 PM
3
There's no state more totalitarian than the Vatican.
Posted by sarah70 on November 27, 2012 at 3:48 PM
4
dolan y
Posted by letired on November 27, 2012 at 5:00 PM
5
For what it's worth, Day was a vigorous protester against the Franco regime, and often angered the church leadership with her staunch radicalism. Dolan hasn't been touting her arrests during protest actions (including ones in support of Cesar Chavez) in his campaign for her canonization.

There have been Catholic heroes (Day, St. Francis) who vigorously shook their fists against the Vatican. It's a sad state of affairs that we live in a time when most non-Catholics consider every Catholic a mule for the Vatican's yoke. But the radical Catholics have either been driven away from the church or have been too quiet—to declare oneself a radical Catholic won't win you friends from either side of the fence. (Though I'd like to think that if Day were alive today, she'd be working with other anarchists and religious groups to sabotage the border fences between the US and Mexico and leave caches of supplies for undocumenteds trying to cross the desert.)

There are some who still hold to the spirit of Day, holding to their Catholicism while rejecting the church's statism and refusing to be driven out. See Pat Thenell, who was profiled in our recent feature titled "Seattle's Best Christians":

"Catholic is what I am and I am proud to be that. I love the Catholic view of the world as good and graced by God. The message of Jesus tells me that we are called by our baptism to practice love, respect, kindness, justice, and hope every day. This message helps me to understand that the marginalized have a special claim to our care. I am angry that the leadership of the church seems to want to move the church back. Some of my friends say to just leave and join a different Christian community, but the Catholic Church is my church and I will not be driven out."

May the radical/anarchist Catholics out there (and, once upon a time, in some circles, they were not considered a non sequitur) keep up the good work and let Cardinal Dolan know what they think.
More...
Posted by Brendan Kiley on November 27, 2012 at 5:31 PM
6
First things first. So first there should be the canonization of Doris Day, a great singer and actress who never even got an Oscar.
Posted by Juan Alfredo on November 28, 2012 at 12:28 AM
Cynic Romantic 7
Maybe the GOP should start throwing a few sainthoods around?
Posted by Cynic Romantic on November 28, 2012 at 12:42 AM

Add a comment

Advertisement
 

Want great deals and a chance to win tickets to the best shows in Seattle? Join The Stranger Presents email list!


All contents © Index Newspapers, LLC
1535 11th Ave (Third Floor), Seattle, WA 98122
Contact Info | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Takedown Policy