Because every time Tony Perkins open that mouth on teevee he goes and breaks the Ninth Commandment. Take his appearance on MSNBC's Hardball last night with Barney Frank. Here's the interview:
Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy
Everyone is praising Barney Frank for tearing into Perkins. And Frank did an amazing jobâI lurv me some Barneyâand you can sense that Chris Matthews is growing increasingly uncomfortable with hosting Perkins, a frequent guest on Hardball and the head of an SPLW-designated anti-gay hate group. But both Matthews and Frank allowed Perkins to assert, again and again, that there are "studies" out there that prove children do better in homes with "a mom and a dad." That's a lieâit's false fucking witnessâand Perkins damn well knows it.
The study Perkins alludes to is a 2010 Department of Health and Human Services study. And It didn't compare children raised by opposite-sex couples to children raised by same-sex couples. It compared children with two parents in the home to children with single parents. One of Perkin's fellow hell-bound sinnersâanother habitual breaker of the Ninth Commandmentâhad his lying ass handed to him when he made the mistake of making this argument in front of Al Franken:
U.S. Sen. Al Franken of Minnesota caught Thomas Minnery, vice president of government and public policy for Focus on the Family, blatantly mischaracterizing a government study on the benefits to children of being raised by two married parents as referring to opposite-sex parents, when the report itself drew no such distinction.... Testifying at a Senate hearing on a bill that would repeal the federal Defense of Marriage Act, Franken said, âMr. Minnery, on page eight of your written testimony, you write, quote, âChildren living ⌠with their own married biological or adoptive mothers and fathers were generally healthier and happier, had better access to health care, less likely to suffer mild or severe emotional problems, did better in school, were protected from physical, emotional and sexual abuse, and almost never live in poverty compared with children in any other family form.â You cite a Department of Health and Human Services study that I have right here from December 2010 to support this conclusion.
âI checked the study out,â Franken said, pausing to let a ripple of laughter from the gallery dissipate, âand I would like to enter into the record, if I may, that it actually doesnât say what you said it says. It says, ânuclear families,â not opposite-sex married families, are associated with those positive outcomes. Isnât it true, Mr. Minnery, that a married same-sex couple that has had or adopted kids would fall under the definition of a nuclear family in the study that you cite?"
Minnery replied, âI would think that the study when it cites nuclear families would mean a family headed by a husband and wife.â
âIt doesnât,â Franken said, again spurring laughter from onlookers. But as with the earlier audience reaction, Franken, a former comedian, remained deadpan serious. âThe study defines a nuclear family as one or more children living with two parents who are married to one another and are each biological or adoptive parents to all the children in the family. And I frankly donât really know how we can trust the rest of your testimony if you are reading studies these ways.â
The video is here.
Studies have shownâagain and again and againâthat children with same-sex parents do just as well or better than children with opposite-sex parents.
Chris Matthews? Let's play hardball: the next time you have Perkins on Hardballâif there's a next timeâask him how he squares his faith with his willingness to bear false witness against his gay and lesbian neighbors.