Slog

News & Arts

The Stranger Suggests

Critics' Best Bets
Music Arts & Food


Line Out

Music & the City
at Night

Friday, March 2, 2012

Occupy Seattle to Protest Breast Cancer Fundraiser Tomorrow

Posted by on Fri, Mar 2, 2012 at 12:47 PM

Updated after the jump with comments from Occupy Seattle organizer Lara Salomon Schuchat.

Encapsulating the continued public fallout between breast-cancer awareness giant Komen for the Cure and its supporters, tomorrow evening, women from Occupy Seattle are joining forces with other pro-lady organizations to protest a swanky downtown fundraiser to benefit the breast cancer organization's local Puget Sound affiliate.

"With all the various attacks on Women's Choices and debate over control of our bodies raging on (with renewed spirit, especially in the South) we feel it is important to let a foundation as big as Komen know we will not fall prey to their propaganda machine," writes women of Occupy Seattle spokeswoman Lara Salomon Schuchat. "There is no pretty pink spin you can put on unnecessary cancer deaths due to lack of free/low-cost screenings."

The $300-a-plate gala is scheduled to begin tomorrow night at 6:00 pm at the Fairmont Olympic Hotel in downtown Seattle. Women of Occupy Seattle are urging the public to join them.

Here's the problem: Protesting the event won't take money away from the GOP-humping slimeballs at Komen national; what it does is hurt low-income women in the Puget Sound area—the very women these protesters are hoping to support.

"There's this confusion between what we do and Komen national," says Jim Cline, a spokesman for Komen Puget Sound. "All of the money we raise stays in the community. We don't give a penny to Komen national and we were against their decision [to defund Planned Parenthood] from the start."

Cline explains that there are currently over 600 low-income women in the Puget Sound area who qualify for free mammograms—and need them ASAP—but who are relegated to a long waiting list because there aren’t enough public funds available to pay for them.

The gala is expected to take in $400,000 for local breast cancer screenings. Last year, Komen PS provided 13,000 free screenings and mammograms in the Puget Sound area with its funds. "Cutting our ability to raise these funds hurts poor, local women," he adds. "It doesn’t hurt [Komen CEO] Nancy Brinker."

"I think these protesters are well-intentioned, but they’re confused," Cline says.

I have calls and emails out to Occupy Seattle's protest organizers to find out what the group hopes to accomplish with a protest, why now, and what message they're hoping to send to Komen Puget Sound and the public. Seattle Clinic Defense, a group that counter-protests anti-choice groups who picket abortion-providing medical clinics, is also expected to protest. I'll update when I hear back from them. UPDATE: SCD writes, "SCD was initially planning an action surrounding this fundraiser before Komen reversed their decision regarding funding of Planned Parenthood Clinics. Following this reversal, we decided to focus our efforts on the national Forty Days for Life anti-choice campaign that began in mid-February."

I believe I understand their surface motivations. A month ago, when news broke that Komen national had cut ties with Planned Parenthood to provide low-income breast cancer screenings for women (and Komen for Puget Sound's entire staff refused to return my calls and emails asking them to clarify their position on the national decision) I suggested this protest might be appropriate. But since then, a lot has changed—Komen national reversed its decision thanks to strong public backlash, and Komen's Puget Sound organizers finally returned my calls and explained themselves. I understand why people would still be leery of donating to Komen (I've talked to dozens of women who are) but I'm curious to know what outcome protesters hope to achieve with a picket, and why.

UPDATE: Here's the full response that Occupy Seattle organizer Lara Salomon Schuchat just emailed to me (emphasis mine):

We are deeply concerned with the future of any additional funding for PP, since it has not been fully promised that this situation will not repeat again, and soon. With all the various attacks on Women's Choices and debate over control of our bodies raging on (with renewed spirit, especially in the South) we feel it is important to let a foundation as big as Komen know we will not fall prey to their propaganda machine. There is no pretty pink spin you can put on unnecessary cancer deaths due to lack of free/low-cost screenings. Especially if they have been cut-off from such a resource over personal politics centered on Abortion & a Woman Right to Choose, which has nothing to do with Breast Cancer.

While we know the portion of the Komen budget that is earmarked for PParenthood is not that tremendous, by their own fundraising standards, that also begs a deeper question that concerns us...where are all those donation dollars really going? Why isn't more going to Researching the CURE they talk so much about (especially when we find out they waste a lot of funds to wage legal battles with any one who dares to use the trademarked term "the Cure")? And why is so much more spent on "education" or "overhead" than on actual research that could save lives.

Frankly, we feel that the Komen Foundation has lost it's way and is toying with the lives of some of the most marginalized women in our society. The very ones who need them most. Low-income and the homeless. We should all have equal access to preventive care, especially during economic times like these.

Final note, we will have secure donation bins (including a live, on-line wifi hotspot set up at a table nearby) to give guests the chance to donate directly, safely, & securely to Planned Parenthood our another charity of their choice. We are also encouraging people (of all genders) who supported them in the past to return the Pink-washed Swag to their fundraising HQ, in a show of solidarity. A way to say "put that money where your mouth is" and put more back into research!

Ultimately, we want SGK Foundation to know "we are still watching" and expect equality for all women.

 

Comments (24) RSS

Oldest First Unregistered On Registered On Add a comment
1
Tits are the new 1%!
Posted by Occupy some pussy too on March 2, 2012 at 12:54 PM
Fnarf 2
Komen's national didn't really reverse anything; they said they'd look at it. The damage to Komen is permanent; they are exposed as a right-wing front group that has nothing to do with breast-cancer research or helping women in any way.

The local Komen organization needs to find a way to deal with that new reality. Maybe they should change their name?

On the other hand, Occupy don't know anything about anything, and can be counted on to pick up the shitty end of the stick no matter how carefully you explain things to them. The sensible thing to do is stay the hell away from the whole clusterfuck.
Posted by Fnarf http://www.facebook.com/fnarf on March 2, 2012 at 12:56 PM
Will in Seattle 3
Komen is as dead to us as the NBA is.
Posted by Will in Seattle http://www.facebook.com/WillSeattle on March 2, 2012 at 12:58 PM
Kinison 4
Just dont donate money to their cause and thats all you need to do. Harassing a bunch of (misguided) women raising money for breast cancer, wow. Real brave of them, they going to follow it up by kicking some K9 dogs?

Yesterday they marched to protest the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation because they give Monsanto GM seeds to poor villages in Africa. Some well spoken rep walks out, speaks to the crowd and pacifies them all, naturally the leaders of the march were all pissed off because of that, because they had angry demands to issue and they didnt get a chance because once again, Occupy was out smarted again.

They really have lost it, nobody is going to pay attention to them if they keep protesting everything under the sun. The whole purpose of the movement was to expose the tax inequalities, the corporate personhood, the money in politics, you know the things that almost everyone agrees is a problem in America. But the original message of OWS is gone, all thats left is a bunch of attention seekers.
Posted by Kinison http://www.holgatehawks.com on March 2, 2012 at 1:20 PM
5
Occupy has become our version of Westboro Baptist Church.

A bunch of dumbass zealots.
Posted by giffy on March 2, 2012 at 1:21 PM
pinksoda 6
Everything Fnarf said, and also this:

Because of the recent choices made by Komen National, I can totally understand why this was/continues to be a galvanizing subject.

This protest could be used as a way to harness that momentum and educate people about the SGK organization, Planned Parenthood, etc. I guess more in the spirit of a rally for reproductive rights, as it were, than a protest against a (horrible) decision that SGK backed down from.

Not that I think that's what will happen here, but I think that would be a positive way to use this scheduled event, as well as all that pent up energy and anger from the SGK grant mishap!
Posted by pinksoda on March 2, 2012 at 1:31 PM
7
What I've heard is that the plan is to encourage people arriving for the Komen event to make a donation on-the-spot to Planned Parenthood or to the Breast Cancer Research Foundation.
Posted by Phil M http://twitter.com/pmocek on March 2, 2012 at 1:32 PM
Vince 8
I would suggest a candle light vigil for women still suffering the ravages of this disease and in support of Planned Parenthood instead of anything negative or antagonistic. Sigh.
Posted by Vince on March 2, 2012 at 1:33 PM
9
As long as Komen national is a functional arm of the right wing and is running cover for the chemical and pharmaceutical industries, then no matter how benign the local Komen is, it is still helping the national organization to achieve its far more influential overall goals.
Posted by cracked on March 2, 2012 at 1:34 PM
10
Yeh, being all positive and non-confrontational ALWAYS gets better results...
Posted by cracked on March 2, 2012 at 1:36 PM
Vince 11
@10 At least not worse...
Posted by Vince on March 2, 2012 at 1:39 PM
Will in Seattle 12
Now, remember, this does not mean you shouldn't donate money to good groups that are positive, as @7 suggested.
Posted by Will in Seattle http://www.facebook.com/WillSeattle on March 2, 2012 at 1:55 PM
13
What does the Transphobia Cisgendered People of color caucus have to say? Is saving tits patriarchy at its worst?
Posted by If tits are the 99%, are cocks the 1%? on March 2, 2012 at 2:42 PM
OuterCow 14
@9 Yup.
Posted by OuterCow on March 2, 2012 at 2:58 PM
15
If you live in Puget Sound and want to help with cancer research, and also want to help with women's health too, just donate directly to Seattle Cancer Care Alliance, Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center, and Planned Parenthood, screw the middlemen. Similarly, I'll never donate to the United Way, rather to the individual organizations directly.
Posted by pragmatic on March 2, 2012 at 3:12 PM
16
The truth of the matter is this will be a peaceful protest, simply asking guests to redirect their donations and think about what this giant foundation is really doing with all those millions!
Posted by RubyredRider13 on March 2, 2012 at 4:17 PM
17
As previous commenters have already noted, there are better places to donate locally if Gala attendees want to support Seattle women and better organizations to support in funding cancer research.

As a co-organizer of this event, I was glad that Cienna had finally decided make a comment on this action despite having the information several weeks. She certainly didn't make any attempts to contact OS or organizers until today. My confusion turned quickly to dismay when I see she is extolling the virtues of SGK local. Her lack of research on Komen affiliates is clear, however, as it states clearly that local affiliates donate 10-15% back to SGK national.

If SGK local wanted to make a statement that would set them apart from the national decision, they missed that boat. She must have recently gotten the green light from national to make this kind of statement which shows their lack of autonomy. But I suspect this local SGK spokesperson is merely using the same fuzzy math that is pervasive in the organization to hide the truth of their mission.

This demonstration is moving forward specifically because of recent attacks on women's health with the focus on supporting LOCAL organizations. Please add more additional comments about your favorite local organizations that support women, low cost healthcare and cancer research!

Thanks!
Posted by Karahp on March 2, 2012 at 4:28 PM
18
I think that those bashing Occupy for not being "on point" to what Occupy (anything) is all about have been severly misguided in their research on the subject. It's not just about Money in Politics or Inequity in taxes. It's about the privatization and profiteering off of miserable conditions of the people. Yesterday's action at the Gates Foundation was a day of action in support of education. That Monsanto's questionable practices also came to light is not suprising considering the Gates Foundation is a supporter of the company. On that note, how many of you know how many countries have outright BANNED the seeds due to health risks and threats to the bio-diversity of their countries. The Komen Foundation has a very questionable history above and beyond the recent PP debacle. I support these women in their desire to be vocal about the transgressions of a supposedly altruistic charity. No doubt, they will also be asking that people donate elsewhere. For many of us, it is realized that just because a charity (which are defined as corporations btw) says that they are concerned for the people, doesn't make them any less corrupt.
Posted by Synisrefusal on March 2, 2012 at 4:57 PM
Free Lunch 19
@18 - It's too bad all that won't fit on a sign, because maybe then the protest would make sense to passers by.

Maybe you should carry signs that say, "We're protesting because..." and then list a URL so they can go home and read a 500-word treatise on how this protest relates to OS's ever-shifting mission statement.
Posted by Free Lunch on March 2, 2012 at 6:06 PM
20
@15 thank you pragmatic for posting those great places to donate to. For instance, here is the link for Seattle Cancer Care Alliance. http://www.seattlecca.org/
They also focus on helping the patient and families get through the hardship, in addition to research and treatment. They aren't just funneling money to research to make a buck for big corporations while fighting to get people to ignore environmental effects.
Posted by cracked on March 3, 2012 at 1:50 AM
Rebekah 21
As someone whose mother has been through two bouts with breast cancer (the second metastatic), SCCA has been a tremendously helpful organization for both her and for our family. I donate to them whenever I have the extra $$.
Posted by Rebekah on March 3, 2012 at 5:05 PM
BurienRon 22
You people are lame. SGK local does not contribute to the national organization. Y'all are paranoid that they fuel big business. Well excuse me... but big business finds cures for diseases and keeps America's middle class employed. Provides jobs to the lower class too. Like you.
You had less than 12 ppl show up for the protest.... y'all chanted for a while... and got your adrenaline rush. Night over.
Posted by BurienRon on March 3, 2012 at 9:32 PM
23
The goal certainly wasn't to overwhelm the guests at Saturday's Gala with a bunch of angry protesters. We smiled and waved, did a few MicChecks, offered attendees pink flowers and handed out nearly 200 flyers with the information about alternative places to donate and facts on the Komen Foundation with URL's to research for themselves. Many guests were supportive and passerby's honked and waved in support as well. Goal accomplished.

@22 While it may have been true at some point in the past that big businesses were the major employers of America, large corporations have shipped so many of their jobs overseas that more people in this country work for the public sector and small businesses these days. Welcome to 2012, Ron!
Posted by Karahp on March 5, 2012 at 12:05 PM
24
A relatively small number of demonstrators were able to ensure that almost everyone who attended that event (i.e., those who arrived via automobile between about 5:15 and about 7:15) were thinking about the controversy surrounding the Komen Foundation when they walked in the front door. Those who could read fast enough also had on their minds a list of alternative organizations that support breast cancer research. Good job.
Posted by Phil M http://twitter.com/pmocek on March 5, 2012 at 1:41 PM

Add a comment

Advertisement
 

Want great deals and a chance to win tickets to the best shows in Seattle? Join The Stranger Presents email list!


All contents © Index Newspapers, LLC
1535 11th Ave (Third Floor), Seattle, WA 98122
Contact Info | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Takedown Policy