Folks were crawling into their tents at about 2:30 a.m. last night and attempting to enjoy their first restful night at Occupy Seattle's new digs on Seattle Central Community College campus. But a few minutes later, three men walked into the camp and began to Sieg Heil salute. I didn't see this part because I was in the back of the encampment, but when I got up front, dozens of witnesses said they had kicked out the Nazis, including one man who had the words "Sieg Heil" tattooed on his chin. These weren't just people dressed up as Nazis for the Halloweekend, they said, but real-deal white supremacists. Not only did Occupiers push them out, several said that other protesters were attempting to hit the Nazis with sticks.

Occupy Seattle: Nazi-free since this morning at about three
  • Occupy Seattle: Nazi-free since this morning at about three

By 2:45 a.m., the Nazis were long gone, but the protesters were angry and fighting among themselves. In a two-hour meeting marked by screaming and additional physical confrontations between Occupiers, many argued that the Occupiers needed to keep out Nazis "by any means necessary" while others seemed reluctant to embrace physically aggressive tactics. And this exposed a certain weakness—at least an unresolved disagreement—that polarized the group. When is force necessary for a nonviolent movement?

The argument for using force, raised by several people, is that many people of color and low-income populations come from communities where the police cannot be trusted to impose order (police officers can make a bad situations worse) so protesters need to take matters into their own hands. Others wanted to avoid physical confrontation. As heat grew, one man in a top hat was being physically pushed out of the campus because some people believed he was a Nazi sympathizer (he'd gotten between the Nazis and protesters with sticks earlier to break up the fight, he said). They were pushing him to the sidewalk and screaming at him while he provoked them back. Police began to watch nervously from the sidelines. One woman then sidetracked the meeting—more of a screaming match at this point—when she asked to see a show of hands of everyone who heard one guy call her a "bitch" earlier. This went on for at least two hours. Some said they needed to send a message that Nazis aren't welcome and others feared the Nazis were trying to infiltrate their movement.

But as a blogger, I have to say that I don't think this was an attempt at infiltration but rather one of the most epic acts of trolling I've ever seen. In a few minutes, three guys—whether they were actually Nazis or not—who had come to Capitol Hill (the land of faggotry and liberalism) last night to fuck with people's heads got what they wanted. They managed to send the Occupy Seattle encampment into a tizzy that continues even this afternoon.

This was a growing pain, sure. Occupy Seattle is an experiment in anarchy and self governance, and without set rules about which sort of speech is allowed and which isn't, they run the risk of getting trolled by any asshole who enters their midst and says something hateful or stupid. But the first time an Occupier defends their "free speech" zone against someone whose free speech is repugnant (like a Nazi) by punching them or whacking them with a stick, then cops are going to get involved and they may get kicked off campus. Not only does that distract them from the issue—Occupy Wall Street is less about the internal politics of a few campers and more about the economy of the 99 Percent—it could force police to end their experiment in self-reliance.