Slog

News & Arts

The Stranger Suggests

Critics' Best Bets
Music Arts & Food


Line Out

Music & the City
at Night

Friday, May 21, 2010

Neoliberalism, Ideology, and Pop Life at the Hidmo

Posted by on Fri, May 21, 2010 at 4:20 PM

Sarah Blaffer Hrdy's book Mothers and Others: The evolutionary origins of mutual understanding opens by describing a commercial plane that's packed with humans.

3476661172_02f5bb3d09.jpg
  • Davitydave

Each year 1.6 billion passengers fly to destinations around the world. Patiently we line up to be checked and patted down by someone we've never seen before. We file on board an aluminum cylinder and cram our bodies into narrow seats, elbow to elbow, accommodating one another for as long as the flight takes. With nods and resigned smiles, passengers make eye contact and then yield to latecomers pushing past. When a young man wearing a backpack hits me with it as he reaches up to cram his excess paraphernalia into an overhead compartment, instead of grimacing or bearing my teeth, I smile weakly, disguising my irritation. Most people on board ignore the crying baby or pretend to.


What all of this makes apparent is the essence of humans: we are "hypersocial apes." We are able to easily tolerate and cooperate with strangers—indeed, this is our defining feature, this is what comes so naturally to us: we are not only great at cooperating but we also enjoy it.


A little later in the book, Hrdy imagines if the plane were filled with chimpanzees:

Given the oddity of my sociobiological musings, I cannot help but wonder what would happen if my fellow human passengers suddenly morphed into another species of ape. What if I were traveling with a planeload of chimpanzees? Any of one of us would be lucky to disembark with all 10 fingers and toes still attached, with the babies still breathing and unmaimed. Bloody earlobes and other appendages would litter the aisles. Compressing so many highly impulsive strangers into a tight space would be a recipe for mayhem.
My next discussion at Pop Life will contrast Hrdy's theories on human cooperation with the theories that are pushed and pushed (even if they are dead—which is the case today) by neoliberal economists: the ground of all economic activity being human individualism, self-interest, and competition of all humans against all humans. For this set of thinkers, whose influence on American politics has been nearly total, local action is far more rational, and therefore human, than group action.


Hrdy sees things differently. From her essay, "How Humans Became Such Other-Regarding Apes":

"Nature red in tooth and claw”, “selfish genes”, and “rational actors” notwithstanding, humans are a peculiarly other-regarding, “pro-social” species. We routinely share and behave in ways that benefit others and find it pleasurable to do so. Our closest relatives among the other apes, chimpanzees and bonobos, with whom we last shared common ancestors some seven million years ago, and still share nearly 99% of DNA sequences, also descend from highly social, manipulative ancestors and possess similar cognitive capacities, yet they are far more single-mindedly self-serving. In this respect, other apes are far more nearly “rational actors” than humans are.

Why is individualism the dominant ideology of our day? Who maintains it? Who benefits the most from this way of thinking, which, if Hrdy's way of thinking is closer to the truth (and I certainly think it is), is for the most part an illusion of the human condition? As obvious as the answer seems, you only need to read (or even listen) about the very recent Greek crisis to plainly see it is not so obvious for many on the street, many policymakers, and far too many members of the press.


Along with Hrdy, I will also discuss the work and theories of the South Korean economist Ha-Joon Chang.

 

Comments (7) RSS

Oldest First Unregistered On Registered On Add a comment
biffp 1
Go to the Africa savannah. You'll see what 8 chimps can do to a jeep. It's chaos alright, hilarious chaos.
Posted by biffp on May 21, 2010 at 4:42 PM
Vince 2
Oh, by the way. The cooperative ape human with the back pack intends to blow up the plane and litter the countryside below with fingers and toes.
Posted by Vince on May 21, 2010 at 4:46 PM
3
Yes the true nature of humanity is clandestiney ,charles! smile in your face know all the time we want to take your place!-backstabberz-Rugged individualism is a heads up lifestyle!
Posted by Goldenschwartze on May 21, 2010 at 5:26 PM
Sandiai 4
Chimps are assholes. If it was a plane full of bonobos it may have gone better.They would just sit there with their bag of pretzles and their junk hanging out.

Someone mentioned mirror neurons before in another SLOG post. Humans have empathy for each other because we have the most mirror neurons of any animal. Men have a few less than women, and those with autism have a few less, but it's all good. With them we "mirror" other peoples' experiences in our own head, essentially feeling them ourselves. You can't be mean to someone unless you can separate yourself from them emotionally, since you would experience their pain yourself (like in Clockwork Orange).
Posted by Sandiai on May 21, 2010 at 6:49 PM
5
It's disappointing to see Hrdy misrepresent the "selfish gene" theory as being at odds with altruistic behavior. Given the ambiguity of the phrase, I can understand why people might misinterpret Dawkin's intent, but it's really unfortunate that they do so, because his idea is so useful.

Most people seem to immediately assume that the term "selfish gene" means simply "a gene that make one selfish," which could not be further from the truth. In fact, the "selfish gene" refers to a gene which, in a sense, is itself selfish. I know it sounds foolishly anthropomorphic to put it this way, but it's difficult to give a proper explanation in a brief blog comment. At any rate, when you begin to view genes as the target of survival pressures, rather than individual organisms, the so-called "paradox" of altruism disappears entirely.
Posted by Furcifer on May 21, 2010 at 11:51 PM
Supreme Ruler Of The Universe 6
The process of Individualization is a universal constant.

Species spit.

New elements form.

Diversity increases.

The Commu-crap you spew about our natural proclivity rollup into sardine cans is horrifying, and yet revealing, as the underlying substrate of the current b.s. administration.

We have always spread out. Left Europe. Homesteaded...just to get enough room for each of us.

Posted by Supreme Ruler Of The Universe http://yrihf.com on May 22, 2010 at 4:37 AM
thatsnotright 7
When i sart to feel irritated at the tedium and discomfort of flying I make myself remember that my grandfather came to the U.S. from Greece in 1910 in an ocean liner in steerage class. I imagine having to interact with, hear and smell 100's of people in cramped, squalid quarters for two weeks and a 4 or 12 hour plane ride in coach becomes luxurious.
Posted by thatsnotright on May 22, 2010 at 3:51 PM

Add a comment

Advertisement
 

All contents © Index Newspapers, LLC
1535 11th Ave (Third Floor), Seattle, WA 98122
Contact Info | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Takedown Policy