Slog

News & Arts

The Stranger Suggests

Critics' Best Bets
Music Arts & Food


Line Out

Music & the City
at Night

Wednesday, March 10, 2010

Down and Out in the Magic Kingdom eBook Club, Day Two

Posted by on Wed, Mar 10, 2010 at 2:00 PM

downandoutinthemagickingdom.jpg
As part of "Read an eBook Week," I'm reading Cory Doctorow's Down and Out in the Magic Kingdom on my Android phone, two chapters a night, and writing about it every day. Here's Day One.

Yesterday, commenter Free Lunch asked:

Paul - are you reading this on an Android phone? How would you rate that experience?

You know, I really like reading on Aldiko. I keep the font a dark brown instead of black (for some reason, that makes a huge difference with the contrast; black feels too sharp to me on a screen) and I make the background a grey-ish off-white. I put the brightness control at the top of the screen so I can dim it as I read—about 25% brightness seems to be where I'm most comfortable. I enjoy the experience of turning the page just by tapping the screen, too, and the response time is good. My main problem has to do with the number of words that can reasonably fit on each page (and that's a problem with my phone's size and not the app) and the seconds-long black screen lag time between chapters. I don't know if I'd want to read poetry or philosophy or a really dense, difficult work of fiction on the Aldiko, but for some light, entertaining genre fiction, it's a really pleasurable experience.

Anyway: About Chapters 3 and 4. Wow, this book shifted gears motherfucking quickly (I guess killing and resurrecting your narrator will do that.) The most surprising part to me was how much Jules asserted himself as a person, and how little I like the person he's become in just two chapters. He's already tried to sabotage another person's work (even if that person was the one who had him killed, it still seemed low) and he coerced his friend Dan into endangering his Whuffie by helping him do it.

And Dan seems to have changed, too. Just yesterday in the comments, Soupytwist said "I love Dan. What a mess!" She was dead-right; Dan was the best part of the first two chapters for me. But in these first four chapters, he's gone from the daring, charismatic Keep-a-Movin' Dan to a dramatic failure to a mostly silent sidekick who clearly has something going on in the background.

I'm hoping to see a lot more more from Dan and from Lil, who's starting to show a personality (the flashback of how Jules and Lil met was well-played, I think. Doctorow isn't afraid to make their relationship kind of creepy, which is admirable and believable in a world where people who can live to be thousands of years old also interact with people in their early twenties who are, technically, adults.) I like the touch of men appearing older and women appearing younger; it's a clever reminder that everything might be different but some things, like gender perception, are still complex. Debra and Tim are great characters. I like how friendly Tim seems, and how driven Debra is. I also like that even Jules has to admit that their new technology is frankly awesome.

Given the changes between chapters 1 and 2 and chapters 3 and 4, I honestly don't know what to expect next. I hope that Jules will be a little more likable, or that Dan will be a little more sympathetic. And I'm still waiting for a little more explanation about how the society functions; gfish in the comments yesterday explained the ad-hocracy a little clearer than Doctorow has. I don't feel in the dark about things, but I'd like to see the world fleshed out a little bit more.

Re-reading these last three paragraphs, I think I sound overly negative. I'm enjoying the book quite a bit; the tech writing is both believable and full of wonder, which is a hard thing to do, and the characters are interesting if weirdly uneven. I'm just really curious to see if Doctorow can smoosh the whole thing together into one cohesive whole. I'm hopeful. I'll be back to talk about Chapters 5 and 6 here at 2 tomorrow. If you'd like to catch up—the book's not very long, you can download it for free over here in a bunch of different formats—you could probably read all the way from the beginning to Chapter 6 at the Sorrento tonight.

 

Comments (6) RSS

Oldest First Unregistered On Registered On Add a comment
1
Are you reading Doctorow specifically because he's going to be in town in a couple weeks for NorWesCon?
Posted by supergp on March 10, 2010 at 2:18 PM
Paul Constant 2
@1: Nope, that's just a bonus. I'm reading this one because it's intentionally available for free in just about every format of ebook, in the hopes that more people will play along at home.
Posted by Paul Constant http://paulconstant.tumblr.com/ on March 10, 2010 at 2:25 PM
3
Too bad these are Doctorow's strongest characters. In the next few books they're reduced to ciphers spouting off his BoingBoingesque rhetoric.
Posted by Chris B http://eccentric-orbit.org on March 10, 2010 at 2:51 PM
4
@2: Fair enough. I cheated and read the whole book the first night, which makes it a little wierd to comment on the early chapters.
Posted by supergp on March 10, 2010 at 3:00 PM
Greg 5
The thing I was left wondering about was, how do concepts like justice and revenge translate in a moneyless, deathless society? Presumably there is an ad-hoc court somewhere to hand out punishments, of a sort, and killing somebody will crater your Whuffie, but what exactly would Jules do if he caught the person who killed him?
Posted by Greg on March 10, 2010 at 10:31 PM
6
Another TERRIFIC Docotorow book - 'Someone Comes to Town, Someone Leaves Town' - the ultimate page turner - koo koo bonkers crazy
Posted by darchu on March 11, 2010 at 7:44 AM

Add a comment

Advertisement
 

All contents © Index Newspapers, LLC
1535 11th Ave (Third Floor), Seattle, WA 98122
Contact Info | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Takedown Policy