Reading about the cooked-up-in-Fox-News-HQ brouhaha about how President Barack "The Wimp" Obama's national address to schoolchildren is an attempt to indoctrinate America's vulnerable yout' (or at least those who bother to show up for school) with his evil political ideas, I'm transported back to the past. Specifically, the middle six years of the eight years of George W. Bush driving this nation off a cliff.
During those halcyon post-9/11/pre-economic meltdown days, any sensible critique of Bush's proposals, plans, or personality was met from the Right with a baying insistence that, Damnit, He's the President of these United States, and therefore WE (that is, YOU, you lefty scum who are criticizing unnecessary wars, torture, privatizing Social Security, whatever) Owe Him Our Respect. You can disagree with the Man, but you Must Respect the Office he holds.
They used this rhetorical fallacy (formally speaking, a false dilemma: one can respect an office and despise the office-holder and/or disagree with his politics) time and time again, and it had some effect on the middle-ground morons who don't follow actual political events in the reality-based world and so voted for him in 2004 in Ohio.
Now that a Democrat is President, though, all of that Respect for the Office goes out the window, and a boilerplate speech about working hard and staying in school is treated as though it were a compulsory quiz the specifics of class warfare per Das Kapital, with anyone failing to be sent before the Death Panels.
Lefties need to recall the rhetorical excesses of the Right and use them right back at 'em. Anyone who takes their child out of school to avoid hearing THE PRESIDENT OF THESE UNITED STATES speak is clearly disrespecting the office we all must respect, and is no patriot.
Of course, I am not the first person to point this out, but it hasn't gotten a lot of play on Slog, so here you go. Hope it comes in handy in any Labor Day arguments with right-wing relatives.
2
5
Lefties need to recall the rhetorical excesses of the Right and use them right back at 'em.
7
8
10
11
12
14
15
16
...it is my expectation that any child in any class where the President’s speech is incorporated into instruction will be a part of that instructional activity. Being a part of an instructional activity means that the child can participate fully or elect not to participate fully while remaining in the classroom, as would be the case with virtually any instructional activity.
19
23
Comments (25) RSS