Last night's King County Executive candidate forum was exactly the sort of opportunity that Larry Phillips, a King County Council Member, was waiting for to drive his biodegradable stake through the heart of Republican Susan Hutchisonâs campaign. Town Hall was more than half fullâhundreds of peopleâready to watch all the candidates running for county executive shred each otherâs environmental agenda at a forum sponsored by a coalition of environmental groups. Just last week, Phillips rolled out his âGreenprint,â a set of environmental objectives that he vows to implement as the executive, and he planned to use this platform to challenge Hutchison. One problem, though: Hutchison skipped the forum. Last week, Phillips said that if Hutchison didnât face off on these issuesâaddressing his Greenprintâthe âsilence would be deafening.â But the deafening silence wasnât the absence of Hutchinson; nobody ever expected her to make an appearance, considering she has skipped almost every forum and dodged the microphone at those she did attend. No, the deafening silence came from the four Democrats on stage (Phillips, County Council Member Dow Constantine, State Senator Fred Jarrett (D-41), and State Representative Ross Hunter (D-48)) when asked to explain how they differ.
In lieu of Hutchison, this was their chance to show us, at least, that they could distinguish themselves from one another. After all, with a closet Republican in the race, whoever gets past the primary will need to eviscerate Hutchison by contrasting issues and calling out her allegiance to the GOP.
The moderator, environmental lobbyist Cliff Traisman, asked Phillips, Constantine, Jarrett, and Hunter to focus on their âvisions for the futureâ and not to âlook backward,â but the four men were determined not to address each other. They remained tethered to banal campaign talking points. And even after Taisman asked a final question, âWhat have you heard tonight that you specifically disagree with?â the menârefusing to sparâtold nostalgic tales of growing up as an Eagle Scout, visiting fishing spots, and cavorting at swimming holes.
More after the jump.
They took a few stands, albeit indirectly. For example, Constantine would immediately convert an old rail corridor on the Eastside to make a bike path (instead of using it for a light rail, which he believed should be placed in other areas), whereas Hunter said we should buy the land but study our options. But mostly, they fell back on rehashed rhetoric. Hereâs my take their underlying messages:
Hunter: Once we miraculously make government a financially efficient animal, there will be money for all the other stuff.
Constantine: Have I mentioned my work to stop a gravel mine on Maury Island? Yes? Well then let me tell you about the time I worked to stop a gravel mine on Maury IslandâŚ
Phillips: I have a Greenprint! My plan has a name!
Jarrett: We canât do anything until we can prove we can do it; if you elect me, Iâll prove we can do it.
Really, bold leaders? Hutchison is killing all of you with a nearly three-fold lead in the polls. It would be nice to think that our candidates have the conviction, fortitude and wherewithal to articulate just how their policies differ from their competitorsâespecially when asked what they disagree with. Of course, they want to be polite and indirect, but polite and indirect will not this race win.
While Phillipsâs Greenprint is a step in the right direction, itâs of little value if he canât use it to call out opponents who donât have a fucking plan. And Constantine needs to show that he can do more than call Hutchinson a Republican; he needs to show us he can explain the differences of his platform from hersâand, in her absenceâhe needs to distinguish his platform his Democratic rivals.