Slog

News & Arts

The Stranger Suggests

Critics' Best Bets
Music Arts & Food


Line Out

Music & the City
at Night

Thursday, June 11, 2009

Becoming a Man

Posted by on Thu, Jun 11, 2009 at 1:23 PM

TMZ:

Chastity Bono, civil rights advocate, journalist, author and musician, is in the early stages of changing his gender—transitioning from female to male, TMZ has learned. Bono, the child of legendary entertainers Sonny and Cher, began the process earlier this year, shortly after his 40th birthday.

"Yes, it's true—Chaz, after many years of consideration, has made the courageous decision to honor his true identity," confirmed Bono's publicist, Howard Bragman.

Congratulations to Chaz Bono. I have no beef whatsoever with his decision. I've known lots of lesbian-identified women who transitioned from female to male. Lots. I don't have issue with it. But...

This just doesn't happen to my gay male friends. This has never happened to a gay man that I've know personally. And I can only think of a single gay man in the public eye—one of the Arquettes—who has ever announced that, after years of consideration, he realized he wasn't honoring his true identity—e.g. he'd really been a woman all along—and was transitioning from male to female. Female sexuality is very different than male sexuality—which is not to say that female sexuality is lesser than or inferior to. If we don't view male sexuality as the standard, if we don't use male sexuality as the baseline, pointing out that female sexuality is lived and experienced very differently is no slam. The fluidity of female sexual identity, as I've said in "Savage Love," should be viewed as a superpower, not as a flaw.

And, again, congrats to Chaz.

 

Comments (54) RSS

Oldest First Unregistered On Registered On Add a comment
Jocelyn 1
How the hell am I ever going to remember to refer to Chastity Bono as 'he'?
Posted by Jocelyn http://wtfwouldjesusdo.com on June 11, 2009 at 1:31 PM
Rotten666 2
Blurg.
Posted by Rotten666 on June 11, 2009 at 1:37 PM
3
Female sexuality isn't lesser than or inferior to male sexuality, but it's a superpower.

Really? It's "more than" male sexuality?

So there are differences and da chix is better than da guys.

OK, noted.

(Wow. Invent fire, impose 40,000 years of patriarchy and war, and man o man, da payback's a sumbitch).
Posted by PC on June 11, 2009 at 1:39 PM
4
Ewwww. But she/he's got a point. Penises are waaaaaaaay better than vaginas. Thanks be to god that the majority of men in this world don't agree with me.
Posted by Straight girl who loves the wang on June 11, 2009 at 1:40 PM
Georgia Guy 5
Add one of the Wachowski brothers ("The Matrix") to your list. I think Larry became Linda.
Posted by Georgia Guy on June 11, 2009 at 1:43 PM
6
Dan, I know at least one gay-identified man that transitioned from a man to a woman. Perhaps that your statement that female sexuality is more fluid informs your observations. A male sexed person with gender identity disorder IS a woman. Your premise that she would have a more fluid sexuality suggests that she would be more likely to be open to having satisfying sexual/dating relationships with someone of the opposite gender than a gay man. In an interview I recently watched with a male-to-female transsexual, she viewed her high school relationships with women as lesbian relationships, and her relationships with men as hetero. From what you've written in Savage Love, this fits well into your interpretation of female sexuality, if you view a male sexed female gender transsexual as female.
Posted by huckster on June 11, 2009 at 1:45 PM
7
@4:

This Chinese character :



is pronounced "wang" and means king. Just thought you might like to know.
Posted by facet on June 11, 2009 at 1:46 PM
8
Dan, I know you tried very hard to be PC in this post, but I'm afraid you are guilty of the cardinal feminist sin of essentialism. In future, please consult with ECB before writing anything. You are hearby sentenced to 3 women's studies courses and 3 hours of sensitivity training.
Posted by David Wright on June 11, 2009 at 1:46 PM
9
@7

Thanks for the info!
Posted by Straight girl who loves the dong on June 11, 2009 at 1:50 PM
10
Random thought: most intersexed infants have a gender picked for them early on, and it's usually female, isn't it? Since it's so much easier to remove bits than to try and construct a penis. If a lot of those intersexed babies would have grown up to identify as male, it wouldn't necessarily be surprising that you have more FtMs than MtFs.
Posted by JBB on June 11, 2009 at 2:01 PM
lizzie 11
The fluidity of female sexual identity, as I've said in "Savage Love," should be viewed as a superpower, not as a flaw.


You know there are quite a few more MTF's than FTM's, right?

http://differenceblog.livejournal.com/ta…

Are you saying MTF's have the superpower of a fluid female sexual identity, but FTM's don't? Or both of them do, just gay men don't? Why are there so many more drag queens than drag kings? That doesn't count as a fluid sexual identity, you have to take hormones to make it count?

Whenever you stereotype genders, you make no sense. You realize the biological difference between female and male sexual response is exclusively in the hormones, right? The junk down there is the exact same tissue between men and women, just rearranged a little.
Posted by lizzie on June 11, 2009 at 2:04 PM
12
I wonder when Chaz will fuck Violet Blue.
Posted by Mr. Poe on June 11, 2009 at 2:06 PM
Fifty-Two-Eighty 13
@1: I'd be real curious to know how often you refer to Chastity Bono as anything. And why.
Posted by Fifty-Two-Eighty http://www.nra.org on June 11, 2009 at 2:06 PM
lizzie 14
Random thought: most intersexed infants have a gender picked for them early on, and it's usually female, isn't it?


No, the most common intersexed condition is an XXY trisomy (Klinefelter's), and almost all of those infants are assigned to male, because of enlarged genitals at birth.

Most XXY people don't even know they have the condition because few people question whether they were born female or male after their assignment. The condition does affect gender identity, behavior, body shape, secondary sexual characteristics, and internal genitals, however.
Posted by lizzie on June 11, 2009 at 2:09 PM
Jocelyn 15
13 - I used to watch Celebrity Fit Club.
Posted by Jocelyn http://wtfwouldjesusdo.com on June 11, 2009 at 2:10 PM
bucket 16
Chaz gets the best of both parent's worlds: Cher's plastic surgery and Sonny's moustache!
Posted by bucket on June 11, 2009 at 2:11 PM
17
@14: Ah, shows how much I remember. I was secretly hoping for a nice neat explanation, but I guess you don't always get those. Thanks for the info!
Posted by JBB on June 11, 2009 at 2:12 PM
Doctor Memory 18
Bucket@16 wins the thread and possibly the entire internet for the day.
Posted by Doctor Memory http://blahg.blank.org on June 11, 2009 at 2:13 PM
josh 19
This just doesn't happen to my gay male friends. This has never happened to a gay man that I've know personally.


Aside from the fact that gender reassignment is an incredibly rare event, what's missing here for comparison is the rate of gender reassignment among your acquaintances who aren't gay men.
Posted by josh http://www.sciencevsromance.net on June 11, 2009 at 2:14 PM
Eva Hopkins 20
Lizzie: I don't know a lot about inter-sexed or transgender people (aside from knowing a few!) but: the junk down there is pretty complicated stuff. I don't think it's rearranged just a little between genders. Although you do go on the mention internal sex organs, etc.

So, Dan: are you saying that because Chaz will now be a male, but was born female, that "fluidity" is what led him to that choice? Or will Chaz enjoy more sexual fluidity than most men, having been born a woman? I think "women's sexual fluidity" is Danspeak for "girls who are straight will sometimes make out w/ other girls but usually straight boys won't make out w/ other males."

On reflection, I know one gay man who went MTF, two women (1 straight, 1 gay) who went FTM & one straight man who went MTF. I know less gay men than Dan does (presumably). Hmmmm.
Posted by Eva Hopkins http://www.lunamusestudios.com on June 11, 2009 at 2:20 PM
21
I have also known at least one gay man who transitioned to female. I knew her during her transition, and she was very sad when she could no longer go to bathhouses. Apparently, the straight men she met weren't quite as exciting (or good-looking) as the gay men she had known. Nevertheless, I agree that lesbians transitioning to male seems much more common, as I can easily think of half a dozen lesbians I've known who have transtitioned to male.
Posted by Gargoyle on June 11, 2009 at 2:22 PM
hartiepie 22
The fact that you can think of only one gay-to-gal in your whole life sure shows who you hang with. Where the hell have you been????

Please go watch "Paris Is Burning" and report back what you think of how the other half lives......
Posted by hartiepie on June 11, 2009 at 2:23 PM
23
as someone who's known, fucked, and befriended numerous gay men over the course of his life, i think we can all defer to dan savage's judgment in these cases. as he pointed out in his column, ADULT gay men rarely make the decision to change their gender. and, as someone who knows MANY MtF transsexuals, i can agree with his observations. men who decide their gender aren't "who THEY ARE" often consider and say as such early in puberty. i think it's because, despite people's incessant idea that men and women should be and are treated EXACTLY THE SAME, they are treated differently. children grow up seeing how they're treated compared to how they feel, and often understand something's amiss. the difference between MtF and FtM transsexuals in childhood is that early development has evolved so that we try to treat our girls the same as the boys, but not quite so much the boys as much as the girls. to wit, the girls who wear dresses are normal, and the girls who wear pants are normal. but the boys who wear pants are normal, and the boys who wear dresses are considered ABNORMAL.
Posted by franky on June 11, 2009 at 2:27 PM
Gitai 24
I've got one tranny friend who was a big out fag til she was 20. Now she's got big tits and the military boys just love her.
Posted by Gitai on June 11, 2009 at 2:49 PM
COMTE 25
@3:

Considering that even the tiniest whiff of female sexuality can turn the average het male into a drooling, goggle-eyed nincompoop, I'd have to say, "yeah, it's definitely a superpower".
Posted by COMTE http://www.chriscomte.com on June 11, 2009 at 2:54 PM
26
The outlet for female-bodied people to play with gender, and possibly eventually decide to physically transition, is the butch-femme culture within the lesbian community (which is SUPER accessible). The outlet for male-bodied people is drag, which can be a little scarier. That said, there's more than a few drag queens who eventually decide to transition; I'd question which sort of gay men you hang out with if you've NEVER seen it.
Posted by DragCub on June 11, 2009 at 3:04 PM
27
Congratulations to Chaz!
And maybe his courage will help his mom to come out as a drag queen.
Posted by ms. placed logic on June 11, 2009 at 3:20 PM
Fnarf 28
I can't believe there's ANY area of human sexuality that I have more experience in or knowledge of than you, Dan, but apparently there is. I have a friend who is a fag-turned-woman (in a long-term relationship with another fag-turned-woman, which is even more unusual, I guess).
Posted by Fnarf http://www.facebook.com/fnarf on June 11, 2009 at 3:20 PM
29
@23 I think you've nailed at least a big part of it. Everybody is attacking Dan, but he has a point - there have been articles in the New York Times addressing the way the lesbian community handles the phenomenon of adult lesbian-identified people announcing themselves FTM. Not so for the (grown up) gay male community. There does seem to be a bit of an imbalance, and I think that comes from the way straight and lesbian female-sexed folks have more socially acceptable leeway with gender expression than male-sexed (even - or especially - gay-identified) folks do.
Posted by yourleastfavorite on June 11, 2009 at 3:21 PM
30
It's also a method of gaining privilege. Granted, transitioning FtM is not as privileged a position as being born male-sexed and identifying as a man, but it can result in gaining the privilege that comes with being male-identified.

Transitioning MtF is a loss of that privilege and may therefore be more rare - who wants to lose what little privilege he has?
Posted by thoughts on June 11, 2009 at 4:09 PM
Vince 31
If Cher were my mom I'd want to wear all her clothes and go for manicures together and fuck with the help until we both wet our pants.
Posted by Vince on June 11, 2009 at 4:17 PM
32
facet @7: That character is "spelled" "wang", at least in some romanizations, but if you pronounce it as if it were spelled "wong", you'll be more likely to make yourself understood. And, speaking of "understood", Straight Girl @9, that what "dong" means.
Glad to clear all this up.
Posted by Eric from Boulder on June 11, 2009 at 4:23 PM
memorex 33
I definitely agree with 23 and 29. I've long been frustrated by the narrow limits imposed on men in our culture. Not to the point where I'd consider reassignment surgery. But it would be nice to be able to wear a skirt without raising a ruckus.
Posted by memorex on June 11, 2009 at 4:26 PM
Fifty-Two-Eighty 34
@33, I totally agree. Skirts are much more comfortable. I've never understood why so many women prefer pants. But, as you say, a guy in a skirt would most definitely "cause a ruckus."
Posted by Fifty-Two-Eighty http://www.nra.org on June 11, 2009 at 4:32 PM
memorex 35
Anatomically speaking, skirts also make a lot of sense for men.
Posted by memorex on June 11, 2009 at 4:39 PM
36
Sexuality /= Gender. You can't interchange the two.
Posted by Pahana on June 11, 2009 at 4:39 PM
37
Well Dan, for what it's worth, I'm a lesbarbarino and I personally know four former lesbos who've made the big mustache of change.

I love them. It's still bewildering to me.
Posted by sheiler http://sheilerama.com on June 11, 2009 at 4:58 PM
38
@21: I've known a lot of non-transsexual women who had the same complaint about all the best guys being gay. ;)

@26: That's a very good point.

@34: A guy in a kilt, on the other hand, is just fine as long as you have the legs to pull it off. ;)
Posted by Orv on June 11, 2009 at 5:00 PM
Violet_DaGrinder 39
A couple of thoughts.

- A FTM transition is a transition into greater social power, which might be more appealing than the reverse.
- Gay men are less likely to demonize females/femininity than lesbians are to demonize males/masculinity. There's more community support for existing in the middle among gay men. Not UNIVERSAL support. Just more.

I'm not as convinced as Dan is that female sexuality is sooo much more fluid than male sexuality, having known (and dated) plenty of bi/shades-of-gray guys. I think men are subject to more severe socialization against sexual fluidity. Not that the socialization isn't just as real as the biology, blah blah blah (Paul, I miss you!). . . I just think we're gonna see a shift over time towards men being more like women in this regard.
Posted by Violet_DaGrinder http://www.imeem.com/jukeboxmusic51/music/y1malqpG/prince-the-new-power-generation-featuring-eric-leeds-on-f/ on June 11, 2009 at 5:12 PM
40
@39: I also note that Dan's post was about someone who was publicly transitioning FtM. I think, culturally, there's a much stronger negative reaction to MtF transsexuals than to FtMs. Men in our society are very protective of their masculinity and MtFs are perceived as undermining that in a way that seems to threaten a lot of people. For that reason, I suspect MtFs are more likely to stay out of the public eye.
Posted by Orv on June 11, 2009 at 5:18 PM
Y.F. Redux 41
Fifty-Two-Eighty,

Allegedly pants/trousers were invented by a Chaldean princess named Semiramis 2,800 years ago for women/eunuchs to wear while galloping across the steppe on horseback conquering things. Most men wore robes, kilts, skirts, and dresses for thousands and thousands of years because of the wang comfort issue. Only in the past few hundred years did the trouser take off as "male" apparel.
Posted by Y.F. Redux on June 11, 2009 at 5:23 PM
Violet_DaGrinder 42
@40

Yep, absolutely. I think there's a perception of FTMs as being kinda tough/badass (who wouldn't want to be a dude, right?), and a perception of MTFs being pansy-assed faggots (what kind of freak would want to be a giiiiirl, right?) who need to have their skulls crushed. As you say, not surprising if a FTM is more willing to be seen as such.
Posted by Violet_DaGrinder http://www.imeem.com/jukeboxmusic51/music/y1malqpG/prince-the-new-power-generation-featuring-eric-leeds-on-f/ on June 11, 2009 at 5:27 PM
Carollani 43
I just saw this shiz on Twitter, that's crazy! Man, I'm glad I'm not famous and have to announce such personal shiz like this through my publicist. Heh.
Posted by Carollani http://twitter.com/carollani on June 11, 2009 at 5:40 PM
pissy mcslogbot 44
Only in the past few hundred years did the trouser take off as "male" apparel.

so then the trouser trout as such is a relatively new species?
Posted by pissy mcslogbot on June 11, 2009 at 5:52 PM
45
I've always wondered about the lesbian infatuation with looking male compared to the relatively mild femininity of some gay men. Why the short haircuts? Why the baggy/men's clothes? Some gay men I know like to wear girl-ish jeans but that's about it. It's very odd.
Posted by The CHZA on June 11, 2009 at 6:16 PM
46
@14 Actually, most babies that are born XXY are not detected at all until they are adults. They appear completely normal, and typically don't develop any problems until puberty when they don't produce enough testosterone to increase muscle mass, lower voice, etc. The lower rates of testosterone's largest effect is usually depression. Many men who are XXY do not find out until they try to have children and discover they are infertile. Transgender/transexual issues do not occur in XXY individuals at a increased rate over the general population, and neither does being gay. Older studies of XXY tend to show the most severe cases, and it is highly variable. It is only since the use of amniocentesis that we realized how often (1 in 500) XXY occurs. Recent studies of prenatally diagnosed XXY babies have very positive outlooks. Most XXY boys start taking testosterone supplements at some point during puberty and live completely typical lives as compared statistically to the general population, with the exception that it is almost impossible for them to produce children without the use of IVF.
Posted by XXY mom on June 11, 2009 at 6:46 PM
Cory 47
I'm confused... You have an issue with the fact that women are different from men? And then you go on to acknowledge that women are, in fact, different from men, and that females aren't 'lesser than' men?

....Okay... Thanks for the tip. Didn't realize that one. Thanks for making me feel like both an outsider and, on some strange subconscious level, inferior.
Posted by Cory on June 11, 2009 at 10:35 PM
Rob in Baltimore 48
My pet parrot, whom I've always referred to in the masculine, suddenly started laying eggs this past Monday, after 12 years.

I don't get the whole sex change thing, but a lot of people don't get the whole gay thing. I hope Chaz is very happy. Live and let live.
Posted by Rob in Baltimore http://www.wishbookweb.com/ on June 12, 2009 at 5:10 AM
Womyn2me 49
Hi, Dan... lesbian here...

I am not thrilled with the continuing movement to push lesbian butches into this idea that they have to become men... that if a woman does not feel like what our culture thinks of as a traditional female, they must be a man...

Butches are an important part of our lesbian community and butches are constantly asked when they are going to transition to male...

Lesbian Butch identity is NOT just a step on the way to becoming a man.

and women who transition to men are NOT lesbians. they are heterosexual men... and they lose their lesbian card, in my book... I will not date a F2M genderqueer transman... I am a lesbian, I do not date men, no matter what their genitals look like...
Posted by Womyn2me http://http:\\www.shelleyandlaura.com on June 12, 2009 at 8:43 AM
Geni 50
I used to sing with the Seattle Lesbian and Gay Chorus. The chorus was comprised of gay, bi, straight-but-flexible, trans, intersexed, and queer/questioning folks. There were at least three of the men in the chorus that I was actually surprised to discover were F2M. There were none of the M2F who surprised me. (There were a lot more transfolk than those, I'm just saying that three of the F2M guys were so very masculine - and hot! - that no one would have guessed they were transgender.) For whatever reason, F2M often seems to work "better" - at least, more seamlessly, and I do think a lot of it has to do with acculturation. As Franky and others have pointed out, a girl who behaves "mannishly" will get some shit, but NOTHING like a boy who behaves and dresses like a woman.

Most of the F2M transfolk I knew had identified as lesbians before their transition. I only know of two of the M2F transfolk who identified as gay beforehand; most had simply been more or less sexless/celibate until they could get their reassignment - maybe because society is harder on women in general. People are much more baffled by a man becoming a woman, and largely I think that is because of the loss of status and power.
Posted by Geni on June 12, 2009 at 12:29 PM
51
#49--Another lesbo here. I agree that lesbian butch identity is not just a step on the way to becoming a man. I know lots of butch women. I also know a few F2M genderqueer folks. As a somewhat butch woman, I've never felt pressure to transition. Maybe it's just me, but I can't imagine that it would be easier to decide to transition than to just stay being a badass butch, so I figure for many F2M transitioners there is a compelling personal feeling that requires them to transition, that they feel more comfortable with themselves identifying as a male than as a female. Whereas I'm totally happy being a butch woman and screwing with gender expectations of women.

I do think it's interesting that for F2M folks, they almost always start out identifying as lesbians and then transition into heterosexual men, whereas for most of the M2F folks I know they started out as straight men and then identify now as lesbians. From my experience, it seems like for trans folks who are born female but become male, there is a tie in with being attracted to (what started out as) the same sex, whereas for trans folks who are born male but become female they are attracted to (what started out as) the opposite sex. I would be interested to read some research into this to see if there is any correlation between sexual identity and gender identity for trans men vs trans women.

AndI also agree that I would not date an F2M transman as I am not interested in dating men. I've known a few M2F transwomen that I might've dated had I not been in a relationship when I knew them.
Posted by doogie1818 on June 12, 2009 at 1:17 PM
52
I think this has less to do with sexuality and more to do with power in our society. Lots of people LOTS would like to make more money, be taken more seriously in all areas of life and be considered a hero for spending a day with their kids. ((Males)) Very few people would sign on to a gender that is considered (lovingly of course!) irrationally emotional, designed for child rearing and rendered a non-sexual object after 40. What person with a working brain stem would sign on to be a traditional woman? If I weren't born with it I know I wouldn't. Face it, as long as it sucks societally to be a woman, more people are going to want to be men if they can stand the change.
Posted by Courtnay on June 12, 2009 at 5:59 PM
a.james 53
49: Go /away/.
I'm all for female-equality, Women's Rights, yah yah yah! But as a transguy who's lived it, I find people like you, wanting to rush to empower your "sisters" so they don't "feel the need to become men and weaken our community!" EXTREMELY damaging to the psyche's of young transmen. Everywhere. We're not allowed to question our own gender, in part because society makes it so easy to "cross" dress for women, but also a large dose comes from supposed anti-sexism types who demand we feel empowered as /women/ for behaving more androgynously/masculinely than "typical women".
In my experience, there's a lot of guilt and power put into being "women" by feminists, a lot like there's power in being "man" from society. When you guilt "butches" for coming out as trans, you just lay on the decades of bullshit we get bogged down in. That attitude acts like we don't have to sit on our hands for years living as women because we don't want to upset our female peers– the assumption that we have it easy.
Many of us are raised with feminist leanings, and I know I'm still working out my issues with sexism and gender; how to assert being a man without giving into the dumb oppressive shit "men" are supposed to do. I can't help but feel a sense of loathing when people with the attitude that I'm just giving into social pressure of how men and women are supposed to act. Don't forget that society also assumes that straight transmen, living as "empowered, gender-subverting women" /should/ be lesbians, and that the lesbian community has internalized gender roles. You don't want straight/bi transmen entering your communities and filling out the "masculine women" roles? Then become an advocate for trans-folk {youth especially}, and start unthinking gender in the lesbian community.

This bit is more to Dan: It's mostly because of the wedge-driving society and the medical community did between gay men and transwomen. What I know of Trans History, gay communities used to be a lot more fluid, especially with queens. Doctors encouraged transwomen to separate themselves from "gays", and media types fluttered with of-course-they're-not-homosexuals lines. Being gay was to be social deviant to the nth degree. It's the same reason why cross-dresser groups ousted gay men in that time. "Yeah we're weird but actually we're much more morally wholesome than those /gays/!" Transmen were largely unheard of, mostly because the medical community ignored them {Freud was still relevant}..again it's easier to move into the lesbian community because a lot of transguys don't know the TS street is two-way, and there's a lot of social pressure to be "awesome women" than "evil men", regardless of the dominate culture.
More...
Posted by a.james on June 13, 2009 at 2:06 AM
54
@23 FTW, #29 too!
Posted by Oh Suzanna on June 14, 2009 at 10:24 PM

Add a comment

Advertisement
 

Want great deals and a chance to win tickets to the best shows in Seattle? Join The Stranger Presents email list!


All contents © Index Newspapers, LLC
1535 11th Ave (Third Floor), Seattle, WA 98122
Contact Info | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Takedown Policy