Slog

News & Arts

The Stranger Suggests

Critics' Best Bets
Music Arts & Food


Line Out

Music & the City
at Night

Thursday, June 4, 2009

The Tiananmen Massacre, Twenty Years Later

Posted by on Thu, Jun 4, 2009 at 11:18 AM

d379/1244139984-goddess.jpg

Twenty years ago today, on June 4th 1989, the People's Liberation Army violently ended a student-led pro-democracy protest in Beijing's Tiananmen Square. The protest grew out of the funeral celebrations of Hu Yaobang—an anti-corruption and reformist party member—with crowds collecting around April 15th, 1989.

A few excellent sources exist on the events, and background that lead up to this peaceful protest and it's eventually violent end at the hands of the PLA. The Wikipedia article on the Tiananmen Square massacre, and particularly its references, are a decent place to start.

Even to this day, all the details and even the number who were killed or imprisoned is unknown. When I was a student at Johns Hopkins, I stumbled upon a collection of first-hand accounts and images from the clearing of the streets of Beijing, that I transcribed and scanned: (Some of these images are quite graphic.)

1e4f/1244139236-troops.jpg


They stood there hand in hand, unarmed - the student pickets... The tanks moved forward, then paused and solders immediately dashed out, and apparently with their guns aimed at us. Many of the students swore not to give way and shouted slogans like 'Down with fascists!' 'Down with autocrats!' At this instant, the machine guns on top of the tanks were tilted down and started strafing the crowd.

All the people in the first row were instantly killed. Then followed the assault troops who raked the crowd with their assault rifles. The tanks then savagely rolled over the first row of the crowd, leaving a paste of human flesh behind its trail....

0cca/1244139265-rollover.jpg


The armored vehicle approached quickly from the west. As the people were very closely packed, the vehicle simply rammed into the crowd. Immediately, I saw 8 people crushed under its wheels - their bodies were no longer identifiable... The armored vehicle moved to and fro, intending to clear the way for the troops to pass. As it had killed so many people, and as the crowd was determined to protect the unarmed students, the people used concrete stands to set up new barricades. The vehicle broke through the first line of stands, but not the second. Then the people used some iron bars to stop its wheels. Somebody lit a bottle filled with petrol, dropped it into the vehicle through its door and covered it up with huge blankets. After about 10 minutes, a soldier emerged, waving white underwear which he used as a white flag. There were four of them altogether, two of whom were old soldiers with white hair, their rank being at least above that of a lieutenant colonel. Everybody was very furious when they came out and was prepared to tear them into pieces. The soldiers said, 'We understand. We do not want to do this. But we have no choice. Please forgive us.' The people asked, 'Who will forgive you? You are murderers, you have killed so many people, you are so brutal, you must pay for it!' However, the students dissuaded the crowd from killing the soldiers, saying, 'Protect them, for if you hurt them they will have the excuse for further suppression.' ——

0267/1244139403-burningtc.jpg

More images after the jump.

8e76/1244139117-bodies.jpg

e828/1244139160-patient.jpg

89f9/1244139041-researcher.jpg

 

Comments (20) RSS

Oldest First Unregistered On Registered On Add a comment
blip 1
the frontline documentary "the tank man" is amazing. it's remarkable how well the chinese government has hidden this event from it's own people.

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/…
Posted by blip on June 4, 2009 at 11:34 AM
2
Thanks for bringing this up Jonathon. I remember being in University in the midwest when this happened, and CNN pretty much being the only video news outlet in town who was able to transmit and watching this all in the student union with many other Chinese students who were desp trying to get through on the phones to their relatives...the young Chinese here now seem to have little knowledge on the event and care mostly not of it--I often think I care more than they do--my folks said it reminded them of the violent and murderous crackdown in Mexico city in the late 60s.

I often think that if a large multi-day peaceful demonstration like this happening in multiple places across the country (as it was then) at the same time when a foreign dignitary (in this case Gorbachev) visited our own government would not hesitate to use similar tactics against us. We got snippets of the whole story in FRONTLINE's "Tank Man" story a few years ago but there is still much we do not know about...but it did reveal US companies such as Boeing and GE selling more hi-tech surv gear to China than anywhere else in the world.
Posted by natural growth=Lebensraum on June 4, 2009 at 11:42 AM
Loveschild 3
Horrendous, it seems so distant though. Thankfully the things that those people were fighting, for have been achieved now that the Chinese society is a relatively wealthy one and that's why the new generation of Chinese feel almost apathetic to what happened so many years ago.
Posted by Loveschild http://www.samaritanspurse.org/index.php/articles/responding_to_haiti_earthquake/ on June 4, 2009 at 11:47 AM
4
Don't kid yourself Loveschild. They got a taste and that made em even more blind than a lot of the people here are. They wanted Democractic rule and they did not get it--they got death and destruction and a mostly intensified police state. They cannot go out on the street, say what they want, go where/when they want, do what they want. The Chinese Communist Party is one of the most corrupt, scary, and rough operations in the far East. I lived there for 1 year in the middle 90s on exchange and I never want to go back, never buy products made there and feel pity for the generation who has had historical amnesia imposed on it. And anger at those of us who should know better than to belittle the aftermath as you just did.
Posted by Loveschild is uneducated STFU on June 4, 2009 at 12:00 PM
5
"Now been achived"???!!! @3, are you out of your fucking mind? There is no democracy in China! They're not apathetic - they're prevented from learning about what's really going on! China has blocked Twitter, Facebook, Flickr, lots of other sites, on this anniversary.

Who the hell are you, really? The depth of your ignorance about so many issues is just astounding.
Posted by Patti on June 4, 2009 at 12:01 PM
Rotten666 6
# Loveschild would you please wake up and smell the fucking coffee you retard? They weren't fighting for material wealth they were fighting for freedom and basic fucking human dignity. The right to speak their mind without their head getting bashed in.

Way to miss the point entirely, Mrs. Potatohead.

I'm telling you, Loveschild has to be a stranger staffer fucking with us. A person this stupid couldn't possibly be real.
Posted by Rotten666 on June 4, 2009 at 12:04 PM
Julie in Eugene 7
Thanks for the post and pics... I was 10 when this happened, and remember very clearly seeing the famous picture on the cover of Time (and reading the article). It was probably the first time I was really faced with comprehending why a government would kill it's own people, and why someone would sacrifice their life for a principle.
Posted by Julie in Eugene on June 4, 2009 at 12:10 PM
8
#3 Maybe there's some hidden sarcasm in your comment? I just can't imagine that any rational human could believe that wealth = freedom. Or that this wealth is some how magically shared amongst all of the people. Or that the perceived apathy is born out of contentment and not misinformation.
Posted by Velveteen Robot on June 4, 2009 at 12:16 PM
Loveschild 9
6 I'm not saying that all is rosy now but to deny that there has been progress and that one of the undermining causes that brought about the The Tienanmen Massacre (discontent with the anti-capitalist atmosphere) has now not been achieved is false. The Chinese society is now one that engages heavily on the market and is has become more affluent because of it, regardless of some human rights abuses that still go on, people in China today (specially the youth) enjoy now greater freedoms than those in 1989.
Posted by Loveschild http://www.samaritanspurse.org/index.php/articles/responding_to_haiti_earthquake/ on June 4, 2009 at 12:20 PM
10
#3, ha ha ha, hilarious troll once again, "Loveschild"
Posted by troll detector on June 4, 2009 at 12:21 PM
Rotten666 11
@9 Man, I just can't figure if your are just tragically misinformed or one of the greatest trolls to ever haunt the Internets.

Posted by Rotten666 on June 4, 2009 at 12:25 PM
12
#9 Ah! I get it..you are a Chinese "historian".
Posted by Velveteen Robot on June 4, 2009 at 12:34 PM
Jonathan Golob 13
At the risk of feeding a troll... @ Loveschild:

You're missing one the key points of the Tiananmen protests. The protesters weren't seeking democracy as an ends or a goal. The protesters were seeking democracy as a means--as a way of ferreting out corruption and nepotism, of ensuring that the fruits of the imminent economic boom of China were going to be fairly shared.

It was, at the core, an anti-corruption movement. Democracy was just a way of getting there. The protesters lost. The same corrupt party officials, who ordered the assault in 1989, became the business tycoons of today, the monsters swimming upon the frothing pile of ill-gotten wealth.

The last twenty years of economic growth in China is one of the more remarkable accomplishments in human history. It's also a social, environmental and economic disaster unraveling before out eyes. It didn't have to play out this way. Without the cleansing mechanisms of democracy, it did.
Posted by Jonathan Golob http://dearscience.org on June 4, 2009 at 12:46 PM
14
China has not "blocked Twitter, Facebook, etc" - a friend of mine in China just posted opinions about Tiananmen on all these sites in exasperation at (what he alleges is) misinformation about the state of play out there.

Honestly, I'm not pro-Chinese-government, but it'd be nice to weigh up the pros and cons of the actual facts rather than just getting constant hysterical, anti-Commie hype. Tiananmen was a pretty black stain on China's copybook. On the other hand, I think as Americans we'd have a right to be pissed off if a foreigner refused to listen to anything we had to say, merely shouting "MY LAI! MY LAI!" in our faces by way of justification.
Posted by Osirun on June 4, 2009 at 1:06 PM
Will in Seattle 15
I'm just going to say one thing - Who Cares.

Because the reality is the Chinese people don't appear to, and if they want to destroy their country with pollution that impacts even Seattle, then ain't nothing gonna change over there.
Posted by Will in Seattle http://www.facebook.com/WillSeattle on June 4, 2009 at 1:18 PM
16
the student protesters didn't even understand the concept of democracy which they were asking for. i agree with Golob that it was more of a response as an anti-corruption movement.
Posted by datajunkie on June 4, 2009 at 1:20 PM
Matt from Denver 17
Loveschild, you stupid piece of shit, China is a one-party state where all political discourse is brutally controlled. They have prisons full of dissenters. They routinely block access to web sites around the world, including respected news sites, when bad news about China is being broadcast.

You think this was about economics? China's boom was already well underway in 1989. People don't revolt over economics when times are IMPROVING.

You obviously know nothing about China except what they showed during the Olympics. You have read no books, no articles, seen no documentaries about it. Christ on a bike! You have NOTHING to inform your opinion.

Jesus fucking christ...
Posted by Matt from Denver on June 4, 2009 at 1:45 PM
Andy 18
@9, that is it. Is it not possible you are real. NOT POSSIBLE. If someone was as actually as stupid and misinformed as you pretend to be, they would not have the mental capacity to learn how to use a computer.
Posted by Andy on June 4, 2009 at 2:28 PM
Rotten666 19
@18 I'm telling you, Loveschild is a Stranger staffer. I'm leaning towards David Schmader.
Posted by Rotten666 on June 4, 2009 at 4:17 PM
Josh Bomb 20
those olympic opening ceremonies last summer were SWEET, huh?
Posted by Josh Bomb http://www.satanosphere.com on June 4, 2009 at 4:33 PM

Add a comment

Advertisement
 

All contents © Index Newspapers, LLC
1535 11th Ave (Third Floor), Seattle, WA 98122
Contact Info | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Takedown Policy