Slog

News & Arts

The Stranger Suggests

Critics' Best Bets
Music Arts & Food


Line Out

Music & the City
at Night

Friday, February 27, 2009

Notes from the Unemployment Line

Posted by on Fri, Feb 27, 2009 at 1:00 PM

Last week Sophia Ferrel, 32, e-mailed me late at night asking that I delete a certain paragraph from her note. She thought it was ill-considered. Today, after responding to some of her comment critics, she reconsiders last week's deleted paragraph and its class implications.

9ef1/1234545801-sophia2.jpgBeing unemployed is like being pregnant, in that everyone wants to give his or her advice/opinion about what I should do with this new and very noticeable situation. The trouble with advice like this is it only reflects the idealized version of what these people imagine they would do were they in my situation—not my actual life with all its variables.

Another analogy: Looking for a job makes me feel like I am dating again. I know I am a great catch so why has no one snapped me up? And where is the one that I will have great chemistry with?

“Thank you for applying for the position of …This email is to inform you that we will not be using the applicant pool to fill this position. As you may have read, the City [of Seattle] is anticipating budget shortfalls, and we will need to use this position to place an employee who would otherwise be laid off... The economic outlook will not always be this challenging…”

In other words: I think we would be better off as friends.

I wondered if the Employment Security Department was hiring since they are so obviously overwhelmed. And they are! They're hiring 70 intake agents to work in their telecenter, part-time, with this caveat: Expected Duration: March 1, 2009 - February 28, 2010.

Apparently our state government has an end date forthis madness. It’s right there: February 28th, 2010. Just like the quick little wars that we get ourselves into; didn’t they have an end date too?

I don’t know why but this doesn’t actually sound so bad, sitting on the phone all day long with frustrated unemployed people. Maybe my standards are getting lowered after looking at thousands of soul-sucking job postings. Maybe I just care about my new co-unemployees—these collected masses of wonderful people without jobs—and want them to hear my sweet voice of concern and empathy.

Sometimes my optimism can get me into some trouble. For last week's post, I had written a small paragraph about driving right by 7-11’s with "Now Hiring" signs. My boyfriend read the piece and not so subtly pointed out how flip and insensitive that was. At one point in his life, he had to live in his car and took jobs at places like McDonald's to make ends meet. I felt like such an asshole and so insensitive. Who am I to not just take any job that comes along?

I e-mailed Eli Sanders late at night and asked him to take out that paragraph. My boyfriend made me realize that part of the unexplored reality is that it really is part of a broader class struggle to be holding onto the notion that because one has a college degree and has had white-collar jobs, one will be owed that kind of work by the world. Sometimes it is easy to forget this, though even unemployed people are rewarded according to class. Two years ago, I worked at a coffee shop and earned $8.75 an hour. My current unemployment benefits reflect none of that, but reflect 60% of what I was paid at my last job (that I was lucky to get and lucky to be well-compensated for). My friend who was laid off from The Seattle Times makes quite a bit less on unemployment than I do, and she is no less talented, hard working or intelligent than I am. I know we pay into these benefits, and that is why they differ (and they do cap out at around $530 a week). But having these benefits differ based on what you were paid only in the last two years can’t help but seem slightly unfair.

So I have spent most of this week thinking a lot about what other kinds of jobs I would take, since apparently it is near impossible to get an interview for jobs you are incredibly qualified for.

The real truth of the matter is that the very last places I will go will be places like Labor Ready, 7-11 or Fred Meyer. Is that classist? Do I sound flip and insensitive? It doesn’t really matter, does it? I have trouble selling my soul to earn a pittance. I grew up poor, but I grew up educated, free, playing in streams, building forts and riding my bike around the loop road on Guemes Island. My mom is and was a super liberal naked-gardening hippie. I am not well suited to work under florescent lights and suck up corporate bullshit to earn what is not even a livable wage.

I AM willing to paint your house, or make your coffee, or serve your drink, or mow your lawn, or any other multitude of low paying jobs. And probably soon you will see me out there, doing just that. But until those $3,610 dollars I have left in unemployment benefits run out, I am going to keep looking for a job that utilizes my professional experience, builds on my college degree and stimulates my mind. I am going to use the cultural advantage I have and try to do something that benefits me.

A commenter put it well last week, writing: “If you get laid off, you can file for unemployment. You can also cut your expenditures if you must, but you do not have to do so. Not only do you not have to, but also you are not obligated to. Get over it.... Even the unemployment offices do not expect you to take the first job possible. The time they allow is so you can find a job that you are suited for.”

And I have nothing but time; my very favorite thing about being unemployed is that I get to structure my time. I don’t have to give the same amount of time at the same time each week, over and over. I can look for jobs at one a.m. I can hang out with my boyfriend, who works a late shift, during the middle of the day. I can spend hours and hours helping create Flash Volunteer for free. And in the middle of all that I pay my bills, check my overdrawn checking account, and apply and apply and apply for jobs. If this sounds like a luxury, well it is. And I love it.

Things are going to work out or they are not, but why waste my short time I have on this planet worrying about it? And I do believe it is as simple as that.

Have an unemployment story to share? Write to jobless@thestranger.com.

 

Comments (34) RSS

Oldest First Unregistered On Registered On Add a comment
1
wait.. i keep seeing the same 4 unemployed people. where are the rest of them? the recession is a lie admit it
Posted by Go away! 'Batin'! on February 27, 2009 at 1:09 PM
2
sophia's my favorite by the way, grrrrow! i'm glad she lost her job and sent a pic. although some new snaps are probably not to much for a fan to ask for you know what im sayin
Posted by Go away! 'Batin'! on February 27, 2009 at 1:13 PM
3
I commented last week how the max unemployment benefit ($530/wk) is greater than my take-home pay ($2000/mo). I too have a degree, but work for the school district. It's well known that society doesn't give a rat's ass for public education, as reflected in the literal value we pay educators. I, too, wouldn't work at McDonald's, 7-11, etc. A friend of my dropped out of school at 16 and immediately went to work in fishing in Alaska make $50k a year. She now works at an spiffy private athletic club that charges members twice my yearly pay to join, and she makes makes twice what I do working 30 hours a week. Perhaps this crisis will finally bring people to realize the classism of our soceity, and truly understand what's important and "valuable"
Posted by Lose-Lose on February 27, 2009 at 1:15 PM
4
Ahem. HELLO Marie Antoinette.
Posted by yahreally on February 27, 2009 at 1:16 PM
5
there are many more who just don't want the media attention @1.
Posted by Will in Seattle on February 27, 2009 at 1:24 PM
6
yes i'd say it's classist - but you're not likely to get a job at 7-11 even if you applied for one. i moved to seattle in october of 2002. the economy was in the shitter due to post 9/11 fallout. i had lost my job in new york working in marketing for a music company and moved to seattle with the severance pay and cash out of my paltry 401(k). i applied for every single job i could possibly find because i needed a job. video stores. record stores. grocery stores. book stores. for a little while i assembled backpacks. i got hired as "holiday help" at barnes and noble for the christmas shopping season. i was asked by the owners of sonic boom "why would you want to work at our record store after working for {huge music corporation}?" it took me almost 5 months to find a job and the job i got was eliminated 7 months after i got it. then i was unemployed for 8 months. that job was done after 6 months. i became underemployed - working project based work for a year and half - with unemployment filling in the gaps - and watched my health benefits come and go depending on how many hours i had worked. finally got a job right in the neighborhood where i worked was so psyched! 5 months later they told everyone they were relocating out of seattle and we would be working through the end of the year (training our replacements).

job hunting was hard for overeducated, privileged white people before this economic disaster. i'm sure it's worse now. the thing is - what about all the people who are NOT overeducated, privileged, white or not - what's happening to them? what about people who don't just have themselves and their cable bill to support - but actually have families they can't feed or clothe or possibly even house now?

i am out of the race now. i have a rare, progressive, neuromuscular disease that is slowly stealing my ability to walk - and has already stolen my independence (living at home with mom) and my ability to work. so you have one less overeducated, privileged white woman competing with you for a job.

things most likely will work out for you. and i'm sure if things don't work out as you hoped when you planned - that you have a support system that will help you out.

there are hundreds of thousands of people whose situations won't work out, who don't have that support system. what about their stories?
More...
Posted by xina on February 27, 2009 at 1:24 PM
7
@3 The public is actually wild for our new prez and his plan for teacher incentive pay.
Posted by It's the free riders we don't want to pay much for. on February 27, 2009 at 1:28 PM
8
Good for you. I made exactly the same choices about which jobs to apply for when I was unemployed about eight years ago. I ended up with a very poorly paid job which covered the rent and some nutritious and filling foods which weren't necessarily very tasty, but it was in my field, and since then my career's flown. Sure, the global circumstances weren't like they are now - but everything you've written makes you sound thoughtful, intelligent, hard-working, committed and generally the sort of person an employer would like to hire; there are plenty of people without jobs at the moment, but most of them won't have those qualities. I remain convinced you'll end up OK.

Losing a job, and all of its associated self-worth, means that you lose so much of your dignity. Dropping your standards like certain dicks would like you to will just make you feel even lower. Don't do it unless you absolutely have to.
Posted by Liz on February 27, 2009 at 1:32 PM
9
"I am not well suited to work under florescent lights and suck up corporate bullshit to earn what is not even a livable wage." Who IS well-suited for shit like that? People who didn't have access to the education you had, or the opportunities you had? NOBODY is "well-suited" to work like that, but they do it because they don't have the luxury of waiting to get a better job. Did you know some people have trouble even getting unemployment benefits? Wow. You're a lucky one.
Posted by precipice on February 27, 2009 at 1:35 PM
10
Unemployment is a state insurance benefit you earned with your past jobs. Society has an interest in the stability that comes from you staying in a white collar job. Take the 7-11 job if you want or need it, but if thousands of overqualified workers took minimum wage jobs they would be dislocating or locking out unemployed people with less choices or skills.
Posted by Green Peas on February 27, 2009 at 1:38 PM
11
When she gets tired of being unemployed and decides to soil her hands doing jobs that are beneath her and her naked mom, she may be in for a shock. Those kind of jobs aren't as plentiful as they used to be and they're being snapped up by people who value paying their rent over nursing their egos.

She was obviously expendable in her previous position, so why should she gain a position that's comparable? That's probably not fair, though. Sorry. This particular writer really gets my hair up.

Your cashiers built forts and played in streams and were reared for a world that is better than the one we have. I'm sorry for you and your rude awakening.
Posted by tabletop_joe on February 27, 2009 at 1:44 PM
12
good luck Sophia
Posted by not a troll on February 27, 2009 at 1:46 PM
13
happy to take your flourescent-bathed corporate suck-up job, which affords me more than a living wage, and plenty of free-time to go visit the cute little trinket-shop you'll be working at, on Friday nite.
Posted by troll on February 27, 2009 at 1:53 PM
14
oh my...
Posted by ho' know on February 27, 2009 at 2:03 PM
15
No matter how many opportunities a person is presented with, it still takes hard work to make an opportunity into success. You have spent years developing marketable skills, there is no reason to feel guilty about wanting to cash in on that effort. The unemployment insurance system is set up just for people like you. A cushion so that you can find a position best suited to your skills. That is the best possible outcome for both you and the rest of us. The society at large benefits when each of us is working to our greatest potential.

Of course there are class implications to prefer working in a coffee shop rather than a 7-11, but that doesn't make your choice invalid. If 7-11 is going to make you miserable, no matter what the reason, than don't feel obligated to perform penance for the unfortunate fact that you lost your job. 7-11, Fred Meyer, Walmart, and countless others of that sort have capitalized on a self defeating cycle of creating no-skill jobs that neither pay well in money or experience for the workers. They strip away any personal initiative or expression, by design, to provide a uniformly nonthreatening experience for their customers. Its a dead-end job, providing you with little other than a shockingly small pay check. It seems to me that the problem is less that you wouldn't work in such a place, but more that that so many do.

Thank you for your well thought out post. Its refreshing to see a little time and care taken in your writing rather than most of the gut reactions that prevade the blogosphere. It has been interesting to take a glance into your little piece of the recession, and I look forward to more in the future.
Posted by Pablito on February 27, 2009 at 2:14 PM
16
Omfg, Sophia...shout your hole, I've known you for what? 15yrs? You're cute, smart and god i love kid but pls stfu and stop embarrassing yourself.
Posted by Peter on February 27, 2009 at 3:04 PM
17
Stuff White People Like : Endless Introspection
Posted by laterite on February 27, 2009 at 3:09 PM
18
The Stranger needs to start handling this topic with the respect it deserves.

Which reminds me--when's the "Seattle's Sexiest Unemployed" Flickr contest starting?
Posted by tiktok on February 27, 2009 at 3:13 PM
19
I'm currently looking for work, but certainly not anything at McDonald or 7-11. I have the luxury of waiting to find the exact kind of job I want. I feel bad for those that lack such things, but I am sure as hell not going to go work some minimum wage job just because other people have to.

If you have to get a job right now in order to live, then that's that, but if its not as pressing then that there's no reason to not be selective.
Posted by sgiffy on February 27, 2009 at 3:22 PM
20
uh, what makes y'all think that Labor Ready, 7-11 or McDonald's would hire any of you? Employers with low skilled jobs to fill usually aren't interested in hiring some slumming or desperately unemployed, white, middle class, well-educated office worker...they tend to cause problems and might be prone to going after the jobs of the managers of such places. Low skill employers are looking for the very young, or the very old, or the very poor, or the very foreign...they're used to being treated poorly and tend not to resist authority...
Posted by michael strangeways on February 27, 2009 at 3:49 PM
21
How you gonna make your way in this world
when you aint cut out for working?
Posted by Warren Zevon on February 27, 2009 at 3:58 PM
22
Cut out that dead boyfriend of yours and I'll make it where you don't have work anymore.
Posted by Sugar Daddy Option Still Available on February 27, 2009 at 4:02 PM
23
Yeah, I was all selective and shit when I started looking for work after I was laid off LAST YEAR. Since then, I've had several temp jobs - some I loved, some I HATED but I worked them all for their entirety. I took one of those "corporate bullshit" jobs you're so unsuited for. Guess what? I was unsuited for it, too, but needed the money more. That job ended on New Year's Eve (budget cuts), and none of my temp agencies have been able to line any more work up for me since then. I'll be taking a job in environmental activism next week, and it's something I've always thought about doing. It pays less than I'd like, but it pays more than unemployment, which is running out. And I'm not going to pass it by because it's not my "ideal" job.

You're lucky you still have the luxury of sitting back, waiting for the perfect job to land in your lap, and living in your delusions. Enjoy it while it lasts.
Posted by Sylvie on February 27, 2009 at 4:06 PM
24
I talked to a contract agency today about a one-year gig that pays $14 an hour. No benefits. I turned it down because after transportation, I'd be making the same $ as I am now unemployed. If the contract were only for 90 days, I would have taken it but I didn't want to commit to a yearlong project that paid that kind of $ because I knew I'd bail the minute something better came along. Flame away.

She also mentioned that people were moving from other states to take these $14-an-hour jobs and that in some cases it amounted to 50 percent pay cuts.

Oh and these openings required a college degree and several years of experience in that field.

Pass.
Posted by Slavery 2.0 on February 27, 2009 at 4:15 PM
25
I think I was sympathetic until you said, "I am not well suited to work under florescent lights and suck up corporate bullshit." Most people aren't well-suited for that. People do it because they have bills to pay, families to feed and stuff to take care of. There are plenty of hippie-children who grew up out in the woods with all that magical sauce and they still do the bullshit jobs -because someone has to do them.
Life isn't always lovely like that.
Posted by gfrancie on February 27, 2009 at 10:07 PM
26
Huh. I've seen that auto-reply from the city, too. It was in response to a job working in affordable housing. Why try to work in affordable housing, if you look down on people who work at 7-11 to make ends meet?
Posted by another unemployee on February 27, 2009 at 11:11 PM
27
I've been unemployed since October. It doesn't annoy me for a very specific reason: $175,000 in available credit. When demand returns, I can make it all back, just like in the last recession. Until then, I won't be competing with anyone for the crumbs.
Posted by john on February 27, 2009 at 11:57 PM
28
Sophia imagines soul-sucking jobs will still be plentiful, and that she will catapult to the front of the line (ahead of more willing workers) when her unemployment runs out.

john @ 27 imagines this is just a dip, "just like in the last recession".

In other developments, Darwin is 200 years old.
Posted by RonK, Seattle on February 28, 2009 at 8:47 AM
29
#25: Aww, Gfrancie, how I knew thee on Seattle IRC and Livejournal. The social-climber who was the first to backstab your friends who were looked upon unfavorably by the in-crowd. Of course, the "in-crowd" there consists of parolees and welfare moms, but you were happy to deny yourself and suck up to them. Oh, Gfrancie, the one who sat back and giggled as your sociopath buddy Travis harassed others, including heavy women, despite (or maybe because) that you could have easily been his target in that regard. It's unsurprising to see you here, advocating the blogger become a duplicitous suck-up like yourself. Hopefully, she won't entertain any notion of being like you. Last I heard you were out of the corporate world, lucky to have a husband to support you as you enjoy more fulfilling pursuits. Hypocritical much?
Posted by Outsider on February 28, 2009 at 12:20 PM
30
#29 Outsider WTF is your problem? You have some sort of personal issue with gfrancie take it offline - or at lease off this public forum. As someone who knows gfrancie personally I feel your comments are not just nasty and out of line - but absolutely incorrect and slanderous.

Her response is completely valid - regardless of whether she works or not. You know nothing of people's personal experiences - and just because someone is in one place at this point in their life doesn't mean they were always there - case in point my mother grew up dirt poor - and I mean the kind of poor where you eat potatoes every meal, every day, for years. With no college degree and only a strong work ethic - and the victim of horrendous underpayment (since there is no equal pay) she worked her ass off for years - by the year 2000 when I was 6 years out of college my mom and I both made the same amount of money (approximately $32,000 a year). Last year my mom bought us a $215,000 house for the two of us when I had to come home and live with her due to serious illness. She is now in a position financially that she never imagined she would be - and we are no where near wealthy. In fact, she is still grossly underpaid.

Gfrancie is entitled to her opinion about this post - if you have one let's hear it - but all I hear is you attacking another commenter. Too bad people like you never behave online the way they would to someone's face because let me tell you I DO - and if I were face to face with you right now I'd punch you as hard as I possible could. Bullies suck. Go look in the mirror, douchebag.
Posted by xina on February 28, 2009 at 1:09 PM
31
your boyfriend sounds like a jerk - calling his unemployed gf classist when she implies she doesn't want put her college degree to work at 7-11. that's lame.

no, the world doesn't owe you anything. and there is nothing wrong with working at 7-11; our lives are measured by how we treat the people we love, not the size of our paycheck. but the world also isn't interested in your guilt about being a white, college educated woman with aspirations to work in the "knowledge industry." so what? that's you. own it. be ambitious. go big!

Do you remember what did Nelson Mandela said?

"Our deepest fear is not that we are inadequate. Our deepest fear is that we are powerful beyond measure. It is our light, not our darkness, that most frightens us. We ask ourselves, 'Who am I to be brilliant, gorgeous, talented, fabulous?' Actually, who are you not to be? You are a child of God. Your playing small doesn't serve the world. Thee's nothing enlightened about shrinking so that other people won't feel insecure around you. We are all meant to shine as children do. We were born to make manifest the glory of God that is within us. It's not just in some of us, it's in everyone. And as we let our own light shine, we unconsciously give other people permission to do the same. As we're liberated from our own fear, our presence automatically liberates others."
Posted by aff on February 28, 2009 at 1:22 PM
32
actually Nelson Mandela was quoting Marianne Williamson, oops.
Posted by aff on February 28, 2009 at 1:25 PM
33
Actually that was Dennis Leary, on Letterman. Marianne Williamson totally ripped it off.
Posted by Phoebe on March 1, 2009 at 1:59 PM
34
32 and 33, beautiful, refreshing. most every other comment...please.
Posted by expectant on March 2, 2009 at 2:54 PM

Add a comment

Advertisement
 

All contents © Index Newspapers, LLC
1535 11th Ave (Third Floor), Seattle, WA 98122
Contact Info | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Takedown Policy