Slog

News & Arts

The Stranger Suggests

Critics' Best Bets
Music Arts & Food


Line Out

Music & the City
at Night

Friday, December 5, 2008

When Paris Hilton Is the Best Thing in Your Movie...

Posted by on Fri, Dec 5, 2008 at 7:43 PM

...you're basically fucked.

There's one last thing opening today: Darren Lynn Bousman's Repo! The Genetic Opera, a gory musical about a futuristic organ snatcher.
humanpuppet.jpg
Thinking of checking it out? Read Jesse Vernon's excellent, thoughtful review. And then, if you have any sense, stay home:

I want to dissect this movie, deftly remove its pulsing, “singing” heart and churn it through my feminist meat-grinder. At first I chalked up my feelings of numbness and shock after leaving the theater to feeling out of place surrounded by tight-black-leather-clad teen goths, who burst into song as they awaited the film. The white-mask wearers (an image from the film, a dull hybrid of Joker and V) scattered throughout the audience upped the creep level even more. Huddled on the beach at Alki afterward, I gazed through the mist at the sparkling city and digested this “rock opera.”

As a recent convert to the Buffyverse and an admirer of that show’s musical episode, I had high expectations for Anthony Head (Buffy’s Giles) as the Repo Man. And Paris Hilton’s dominatrix persona on My New BFF and her fake presidential candidacy have lately warranted the heiress a second chance at dimensionality—here she plays Amber Sweet, “addicted to the knife” and vying for daddy’s fortune.

It's 2056, the rich/poor divide is cavernous, and everyone is addicted to body-modifying surgery and its complementary painkiller, Zydrate. The introductory montage teeters between homage and cheap meme—black-and-white comic strips illustrate the back-story and introduce the characters, punctuated by streaks of red. The residents of this dreary yet technologically advanced future purchase their abundantly accessible organs on loan. Which means that when they default on their payments, guess what? The Repo Man collects. Literally. It's a decent premise with potential for enticingly gory imagery—campy costumes and acting veiling an ironic critique of a beauty/violence obsessed culture.

But any expectations of Joss Whedon-style powerful and sexy women were promptly shattered. My horror was not at the mutilation-as-beautification theme, the plentitude of disembowelment scenes, nor the human hand-puppet (not the HUMP! kind, the hand-shoved-in-slashed-stomach kind). I can do gore. It was the utterly disappointing, yet familiar, female characters, who were introduced and then promptly relegated to the margins. There’s 17-year-old Shilo, locked in her room, sickly, and easily manipulated; Blind Mag, a tool of the powers that be who dies impaled on an iron fence; and Amber Sweet, a whiny addict who wants daddy’s fortune. Oh, and Dead Marni, who’s, um, dead. The nameless T&A, whose bodies are literally props to be violated, with rape jokes or knives, are dubbed the Scalpel Sluts.

My one respite: Paris Hilton, who, holding the mic with one hand and her malfunctioning wardrobe (read: peeling-off face) with the other, was utterly delightful.

That's hot.

 

Comments (17) RSS

Oldest First Unregistered On Registered On Add a comment
1
I loved REPO, I saw it on the road tour, and will see it again and again!
Posted by Chivahn on December 5, 2008 at 8:49 PM
2
Everyone thinks Paris Hilton is sexy, but with that big square jaw and preppy background, I just imagine her fat ass swathed in a Laura Ashley print dress, waddling around on some Ivy League stone pathway, going from Commons to Comp Lit Class.
Posted by Old Nassau on December 5, 2008 at 10:07 PM
3
i just went to see "Let the Right One In" at the Varsity on the Ave. (which, BTW, is an AWESOME vampire flick - Sweden is the PERFECT setting for a modern-day vampire movie!)

aaanyway - the freaks were OUT for the Repo! movie. We didn't really know what was going on at first. I thought we may have stumbled upon a Rocky showing, but the freaks didn't look quite right for a Rocky. Once we got in we realized what they were there for.

The trailer looked pretty stupid.
Posted by pffft on December 5, 2008 at 11:09 PM
4
I wanted to like this movie when I first heard about it, but it sounds like they fucked it up in one of the few ways they could have to underwhelm my (in this case, admittedly low) entertainment threshold.

It'll probably still be fun to mock on DVD with friends.
Posted by Asa on December 5, 2008 at 11:30 PM
5
Feminism is for fags.
Posted by Commie F on December 6, 2008 at 12:10 AM
6
I think viewing this through a feminist view is the wrong way to dissect a film that is at once satire and trash, with a hint of critique at the modern world.

Even so, lets look at the female characters. Its no coincidence that Paris Hilton plays the whiny selfish daughter, addicted to plastic surgery, glamour and beauty. Sarah Brightman as Blind Mag is perfectly fitting as the operatic singer who frequently flies during her opera. And Alexa Vega, struggling to break the chains of her roles in Spy Kids...as the girl who was locked in her room (and she wasn't easily manipulated, as Jesse says). The irony Jesse was looking for was not where Jesse was looking.

The art direction and style of the movie are frequently amazing, if you like the whole Blade Runner meets Bauhaus (print) meets Russian Propaganda filtered through the early 90s goth scene. The main faults, I believe, is in the music. The singing is frequently not that great (or, just not mixed well). And, the story is a mutant yet generic operatic plot about jilted love, revenge, and murder.

But, the unrepentant corporations doing mass repossessions of people's organs seems especially relevant in the current economic state. And, the style, as said before, is kind of amazing at times...and at others it feels like a movie made by your local goth bar with a budget. It teeters between unwatchable and fucking amazing, making it a...well...making it something to witness.
Posted by TheMisanthrope on December 6, 2008 at 12:33 AM
7
@6: no, this is exactly the kind of film to look at through a feminist lens. It's not just serious entertainment that should be looked at- it's everything. And considering the filmmakers are trying to say something about society, being misogynistic (if they are, I haven't seen it, so I can't comment on the actual content) just seems lazy.
Posted by Abby on December 6, 2008 at 7:42 AM
8
This reviewer has not taken into consideration the fact "Repo! A Genetic Operia" also treats male characters in a two-dimensional, unflattering & unrealistic manner. It's not as if the male characters are studies in psychological realism, while the female characters are diminished. Perhaps the film is not misogynist, but merely bad--or, perhaps it's delightful, tacky trash in which all characters are reduced to caricature. It seems that the reviewer's "high expectations" were not warranted...
Posted by Patrick on December 6, 2008 at 9:16 AM
9
Lindy Lindy Lindy West!
Lindy Lindy West!

Lindy Lindy Lindy West!
Lindy Lindy West!

You make me wanna wanna laugh
You make me wanna wanna cry
You make me wanna wanna wanna...

CUM IN YER EYE!!!

Lindy Lindy Lindy West!
LINDY IS THE BEST!!!

"Ode To Lindy West" by Cookie W. Monster
(c) 2008 Here's Cum In Yer Eye Music
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED, MOTHERFUCKERS!
Posted by Cookie W. Monster on December 6, 2008 at 12:21 PM
10
I was looking forward to this, unsure if it'd be simply trash, or good trash. Sounds like trash, from what I've heard. In this economy, I'll take a pass. I can eat two meals for the price of one showing.
Posted by Recession-Po! on December 6, 2008 at 2:35 PM
11
@7 The film is not merely misogynistic. Its misanthropic. Its hatred for men, who are just as much fodder for bloody death as the women, is legion. To view it as misogynistic only is to miss the blatant misandry that is present in the film as well. Thus, to view the film as being ONLY mysogynistic is to be misandropic.
Posted by TheMisanthrope on December 6, 2008 at 2:58 PM
12
I don't do gore, but I found it completely enthralling. Though it should be noted, if it had a point, I missed it.
Posted by Lily Fluffbottom on December 6, 2008 at 4:01 PM
13
It was a decent movie. Better than I expected (I had low expectations). Kind of fun/interesting trash, I guess. But misogynistic? To look at it through your feminist lens completely ignores the male characters, who were treated just the same as the female characters. I don't know what you were expecting, but your review is terrible and misses major parts of the movie.
Posted by N on December 6, 2008 at 7:09 PM
14
Anybody who thinks Buffy is a feminist manifesto should take a second look. Sure, Buffy herself gets to be strong - but in the Whedonverse any girl who is smart (rather than ass-kicking or "chosen") is totally fucked. Whedon seems to think that nerdy girls who aren't classically pretty need to be punished. Willow's story arc is pure tragedy - Fred (on Angel) paid for her intelligence by being sent to another dimension, enslaved and ultimately consumed by a sexy she- demon (because sexuality is scary!) and River (also a hyperintelligent female) was kidnapped and tortured for years!

I really wanted to like Buffy - but viewing from a feminist perspective it turns into a show about how only the attractive and not-so-smart girls are "chosen" and the less attractive but brainy girls often end up being victimized because of it. So yeah, I guess Buffy IS a feminist manifesto - if you happen to be a cute, white, blonde chick who doesn't read too many books.
Posted by robot on December 6, 2008 at 8:24 PM
15
*shhh* Nobody tell her about that Zombie Strippers movie - okay? ....
Posted by Colton on December 7, 2008 at 11:50 AM
16
Yeah, I'm gonna pass.
Posted by Greg on December 8, 2008 at 9:56 AM
17
I went to see this on Friday night and thought it was horrible. There are two types of goth. There's goth that is informed by a sense of history and glamour - and is really hot when it's done right (think Siouxsie, Patricia Morrison, Rose McDowall, Bauhaus).

There's another type of goth that looks like goth for poor people - suburban white trash goth - and this type of goth is always ugly. Repo was filled with this ugly type of goth and so was the audience.

There's bad that's so bad it's good, and there's bad that's just bad - and that was Repo.
Posted by PussyDunkinHines on December 8, 2008 at 10:11 AM

Add a comment

Advertisement
 

All contents © Index Newspapers, LLC
1535 11th Ave (Third Floor), Seattle, WA 98122
Contact Info | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Takedown Policy