Slog

News & Arts

Line Out

Music & Nightlife

Friday, November 21, 2008

USS Mariner Blogger Loses Scholarship Competition

Posted by Jonah Spangenthal-Lee on Fri, Nov 21, 2008 at 3:57 PM

USS Mariner blogger Dave Cameron fell about 7,000 votes short of winning an online competition for a $10,000 college scholarship.

Cameron managed to pull in a whopping 13,000 votes, but it just wasn't enough to overcome the massive flood of traffic generated by Daily Kos for their own David Mauro, who ended up with about 20,000 votes.

While some Kos bloggers turned into giant fucking assholes during the competition, it appears the commie pinko political site is trying to make good, and has posted a link to USSM, which is now holding its own fundraiser to get Cameron a well-deserved scholarship. So far, USSM has raised about $500.

If you're completely baffled as to why anyone would give money to a sports blogger, check out a few of these comments left on my earlier post:

Uh, Nate Silver of fivethirtyeight.com was a stupid baseball blogger until this year. Now he's probably the most insightful and original progressive blogger on the planet. I don't even like baseball but I've been following Cameron and Silver for years because they're a couple of the best thinkers I've ever read.

Posted by jrrrl

If you just ignore the content of the two blogs (for a sec) and consider what the two have accomplished, you have to go with Cameron. His analysis of the product the Mariners sell to their fans has made the very stubborn (and sometimes woefully dumb) franchise to change their ways (see Cameron's report on the coaching of Felix Hernandez a couple seasons back). In a way, he's somewhat like Ralph Nader leading a consumer's movement to install protective dashboards in cars(somewhat. don't go crazy). I can't think of anything the Daily Kos has been directly involved in any change towards what it writes about.

Posted by Shoot me down, I dare you

The thing is, Dave Cameron is a really, really good baseball blogger, one of the best in the entire field, while David Mauro is an extremely pedestrian blogger on local Texas politics. Cameron has a much greater impact on the community at large; his readership is extraordinarily high, and (unlike Mauro) his entries generate hundreds of insightful comments. Mauro's entries typically get two or five comments.

It also deeply annoys me that the Kossacks have taken a stupid joke about getting the Freepers and other right-wingers to vote en masse for Cameron as if it was a serious expression of Cameron's true fan base. That's ridiculous. I honestly have no idea where Cameron fits on the political scale, because he zealously avoids even passing mention of it — and he's deleted comments of mine at USSM that inappropriately brought it up. He was right to do so.

Cameron is actually advancing the state of the art at USSM, and making advanced ideas of analyzing baseball comprehensible to many, many people. He's made something like six thousand posts there, and with few exceptions they've been brilliant.

So, yeah: vote Cameron.

Posted by Fnarf

 

Comments (15) RSS

Add a comment Oldest First Unregistered On Registered On
1
As a longtime USS Mariner lurker and Slog rare-commenter, it's worth all the typing to mention how happy it makes me to see Slog taking the time to recognize good work, even if it's about a subject many Slog readers aren't interested in.

And my happiness is really what this all is about... right?
Posted by Dave in Chicago on November 21, 2008 at 4:16 PM
2
"I can't think of anything the Daily Kos has been directly involved in any change towards what it writes about."

They're only responsible for thousands of dollars in donations to progressive candidates.
Posted by w7ngman on November 21, 2008 at 4:20 PM
3
I forgot, but someone mentioned in the first thread that Keith Olbermann was also a stupid baseball commentator and historian for years before he got his MSNBC show.
Posted by jrrrl on November 21, 2008 at 4:24 PM
4
"commie pinko political site"

You are way out of line JSL and disregard a site that was a straight up game-changer (to use your sports lingo) in the "blogosphere", its importance in the Political process, and the relevance of your very own little Slog.

Sports are an existential waste of time, and blogging about such only compounds its complete and utter lack of societal utility.
Posted by Non on November 21, 2008 at 4:27 PM
5
You are a waste of time.
Posted by jonahsl on November 21, 2008 at 4:34 PM
6
awesome response, you little baby.
Posted by Non on November 21, 2008 at 4:39 PM
7
Troll on, brother.
Posted by jonahsl on November 21, 2008 at 4:42 PM
8
Don't you guys see how essential professional sports is to civilization? Think about the humble advertisers, underpaid athletes, civic-minded team owners, and even brilliant bloggers who dedicate countless amounts of money, time and energy to this most noble of pursuits. And to those who complain about misuse of taxes and "corporate welfare", think about the children. Would you want them to grow up in a world without television-worthy stadiums or even decent teams to root for?
Posted by marinersfan on November 21, 2008 at 5:00 PM
9
I'm bummed. I tried voting several times for him but every time the voting was temporarily turned off due to server load issues.
Posted by PopTart on November 21, 2008 at 5:19 PM
10
Same thing happened to me, PopTart. Must be part of the liberal mainstream media conspiracy!
Posted by marinersfan on November 21, 2008 at 5:31 PM
11
Jonah, your concept of what trolling is probably equates to somebody who disagrees with you.

And you're wrong.
Posted by Non on November 21, 2008 at 5:47 PM
12
Kossacks is such a great portmanteau, Fnarf, and I want to give you a high-five.

Non, I rather think that Jonah's concept of trolling is asserting a virtually untenable position with one sentence and no supporting details, that is likely to piss off a majority of people. Sports are a waste of time, indeed.
Posted by Chris in Tampa on November 21, 2008 at 9:07 PM
13
Ahhh, feels good to have had a part in taking down both the USS Mariner, and Lookout Landing from one lonely little computer. Just knowing that I could have riled up the tidal wave of the mighty KOS with a few little posts makes my heart go pitter patter. Whats more, I could give a shit about KOS, or the dipshit that they promoted. The Lookout Landing boys should know that they caused the loss, moreso than Dave's own site. Jeff Sullivan put the nail in Camerons' coffin, shouldn't talk shit starting a local blog war when stumping for votes, douchebag.

It was so easy to manipulate these guys into hanging themselves, but it was fucking beautiful. Almost as pretty as watching them cry now.
Posted by graham on November 22, 2008 at 12:28 AM
14
Hey non - what do you think has social utility? Specific examples, please.
Posted by UnoriginalAndrew on November 22, 2008 at 2:03 PM
15
I read USSMariner and enjoy it, but I certainly wouldn't say Cameron is more deserving of a scholarship than say... someone who expends a huge amount of effort applying for a scholarship from Research Councils and private funding organisations. It's a nice baseball blog, but if Dave Cameron is one of the best thinkers you've ever read then you probably don't have a great exposure to great thinkers. Let's not forget that competing with academics is a slightly more difficult task than arguing against the ideas of Geoff Baker and Joe Morgan. If he's not as gifted academically as those people who do acquire college scholarships in his field then I can't see the justification for donating money to fund his studies.
Posted by aryon on November 22, 2008 at 5:35 PM

Add a comment

 

All contents © Index Newspapers, LLC
1535 11th Ave (Third Floor), Seattle, WA 98122
Contact Info | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use