Comments

1
The idea that an incoming police chief would take it upon himself to reduce punishments meted out by his predecessor shows a complete lack of understanding of where the department is now with respect to the public trust and Justice Department oversight.

This is precisely how officers get away with misconduct time and again. They are slapped on the wrist at first, but the punishment and complaint are overturned on appeal or at the request of the union. Officers learn that if they wait it out the ramifications of their behavior will more often than not disappear.
2
Murray looks incompetent here. Ditto the acting SPD chief.
3
...and this all happened without anyone going to anyone else's place of work and harassing them.

However, I strongly suspect there was some "come-at-me-bro" posturing behind closed doors. Metaphorically, at least, if not in real physical terms.
4
Admitting something was wrong, correcting it, and taking responsibility.

I'm not seeing that as a weakness.
5
@4: It is if they were only sorry that they got caught. Admitting you were wrong isn't a "get out of jail free" card. It is part of a process. Right now I would say there is a 0% chance they would have admitted this wrongdoing preemptively or without it being rubbed in their faces. As such, their apology means nothing.
6
Ed Murray is a dumbshit. Expect 46 more months of this incompetence. I can only hope he doesn't do any real damage to the city in the meantime.

Thank you Dominic Holden and The Stranger staff for shedding light and holding Murray accountable for his terrible decisions. Keep it up, there will be more.
7
@6: He has already done significant damage to SPD. The reformers in the department have been canned, demoted, or reassigned and the message this has sent to the rank and file is clear: keep your head down and don't say a thing.

Unless Team Murray is willing to admit that everything they've done so far is wrong and start from scratch, we are indeed in for an awful 46 months.
8
I'm sensing that we have another one-term mayor in the making.
9
Off. Marion's problem does not stem from lack of training but from a more fundamental problem. He exhibits a confrontational attitude, a bullying posture towards the public he is supposed to be serving.

That attitude serves to escalate interactions, when a competent and professional officer seeks to de-escalate them. Mr. Holden may be a smartass but he was doing nothing illegal, nothing "wrong" in any sense of the word.

An officer who overreacts to such a benign matter probably shouldn't be on the force. One day's further training won't cure an emotional problem.
10
Saw a Seattle police car on Cap Hill that was black and white instead of blue. A shame we are losing that small bit of character.
11
All the headlines and the criticism from people like CM Burgess must have hit them like bad polling results.

This is also embarrassing for Officer Marion, because it draws out the unwelcome attention he's getting. It's not that he doesn't necessarily deserve it, but it would have much better for him to have taken the punishment and been done with it already.

Can we get the supporters of the original decision to denounce Bailey and Murray for changing their minds? raindrop? M. Wells? Whoever else?
12
Murray talks about reforming the OPA system - that system is bargainined for - the stupid archiac way in which things are handled is due to the system created by the SPOG ans SMA contracts.... so, if you want to change it Mayor, you need to go back to the bargaining table with the same people who endorsed your campaign.
13
A world where nobody learns from their mistakes.

I know we haven't seen much of that from the nayor's office over the past 12 years, but I'm willing to give it a try.

(Damned either way, might as well make things right.)
14
You voted for him, Seattle. Enjoy!
15
"For the record, my experience with Officer Marion is arguably minor when compared to well-documents violent acts of police misconduct, particularly toward racial minorities."

"Arguably"??? Somehow, Dominic, you never cease to be a privileged little prick.
16
Beats the shit out of 4 more years of McGinn. It was always somebody else's fault with that guy.
17
Murray might be going down faster on this than McGinn went down on his early-term tunnel turnabout.

Very impressive dive velocity...especially combined with the flips and twists, Team Murray!
18
So, are you going to be requesting records on other people's misconduct complaints and keeping on top of them? It seems like that's what the public needs to do right now and reporters seem like a good fit to facilitate that for the public.
19
Thanks, Mayor and Chief, for reverting from a training check-box to a firm wrist slap for Seattle Police Department Officer John T. Marion #6963.

It's not enough. Mr. Marion is not likely to be trained to respect anyone's Constitutionally-protected rights. I wouldn't hire a hot-head like that to be a counter clerk, much less to carry a gun and use it with impunity. He should be fired.

Every one of our peace officers should know that if they lie to people about the legality of standing on a public transit plaza or sidewalk, and if they try to intimidate people into not observing and documenting their on-the-job actions, they're putting their jobs in jeopardy.
22
@14 I didn't vote for him. No one in my house voted for him. We didn't give him this authority because we knew this would happen.
23
Right now in this week of flip flops we might be enjoying the high water mark of Ed Murray's administration's police reform. Can you imagine what it's going to look like when a really difficult police misconduct case lands in Murray's lap? John "Come at me bro" Marion did not exactly require the deepest oceans of wisdom to adjudicate who the fuckup was. Hint: it's the cop who started a fight over doodly squat with a reporter, on video.

I'm sure right now the mayor's celebrating a win down at city hall. It don't get any better than this.
24
@15:

In this context, I don't think "arguably" means what you think it means...
26
This is worse than announcing you are going all in on a new sea wall when nobody was expecting it.
27
We've got 3 years and 10 months more of this jerk.
28
And all of this could have been avoided if it wasn't (apparently) so damned important to replace one Interim Police Chief with a different Interim Police Chief only a week after taking over the Mayor's office. I realize a new Mayor has the right to replace anyone they want, but there's something to be said for taking the time to evaluate your employees and making those decisions based on performance. Especially for an employee who is already serving in a temporary role, a role which you're planning to fill permanently very soon. This is all so petty I can hardly believe it.
29
Presumably the other six cases that he reversed basically because he could will be left as is?
30
Dominic,
Here's the basis of your complaint about Officer Marion, who till then had an unblemished record. You filed a formal complaint because he supposedly said, "I'm going to come into The Stranger and bother you while you're at work." Wow. That's really an outrageous violation of your civil rights! And don't you work for a publication that routinely tells people to fuck off, etc. So the Stranger itself is a model of civility? Where do I complain about the Stranger.

Dominic, your self righteous posturing and ethically-challenged performance in this does a real disservice to people who have real, significant complaints with police officers. You're a privileged white boy who heard rude words. Grow up. Get some perspective. And give coverage to people who truly know what civil liberties mean,
31
@30 before Dominic pursued this how much mainstream talk was there by any Mayor in the past few generations -- not just elections -- to really crack down and pursue reforms?
32
@11, no, Officer Marion is not going to be embarassed. Anger-management cases with guns (which probably includes half of the SPD) don't get embarassed.
33
@30 - The officer did not "supposedly" say those things. He said them in actual fact. There is video. You can watch it yourself.
34
*Now* can we have a Civilian Police Review Board? Letting the SPOG-controlled temporary placeholder chief overrule disciplinary decisions obviously isn't working out so well.

At the very least the DoJ needs to step up from 'monitoring' to 'intervention'.

(And 'Dominic the cry baby', you obviously didn't watch the same video that everyone else managed to see. The incident was over, and the SPD crew was getting ready to leave the scene when Mr. Holden approached to find out who was in charge of the specific incident. All the officer had to do was answer one simple question from a member of the media; ins tea she decided to go on a juvenile tirade. If Mr. Holden had waited much longer all of these officers would have been gone, leaving nobody to answer any questions.)
35
Holy fucking SHIT, Batman, Gotham City is in a mess!
36
Dominic, I applaud your forceful & forthright reporting on this issue. By shining a spotlight on this shameful episode by the Seattle PD, you have forced the City of Seattle to deal with it—finally!—in the right way.

No doubt Mayor Murray wanted to make a public show of support for his police chief—but at the same time, i also have no doubt that discussions were going on behind closed doors to find a way out of the mess. Had you not continued to bring this issue to light, the mayor would most likely have let Chief Bailey's unfortunate decision slide.

Conscientious reporting like this is the *only* way to rein in the ongoing egregious behavior by Seattle's Finest. Bravo to you Dominic, keep up the good work!
37
Wait: vigorous questions not backed down from brought about...change? And an apology?

What city do we suddenly live in? Sure, the GOP coinage of flop-flop might suit, but is it possible someone just got a valuable lesson beat into them by the press?

Kudos, sir.
38
Bravo, Dominic! I hope you get a Pultizer Prize and a MacArthur Genius grant for standing firm in a war zone! Imagine, no helmet or flak jacket while that police officer unleaded a tirade, saying he would "bother" Dominic. I don't even have to have a dictionary to know that "bother' is hate speech of the most cruel sort. Just as there are statues of America's great leaders, there should be one of Dominic standing up to that Bull Connor, who would have said something much worse than "bother," only that's the word that came to mind with that bully Nazi thug jerk. Let's name a street after Dominic. We can call it Whinners Way.
39
@11 Seatackled, I think @4 has it just right;

"Admitting something was wrong, correcting it, and taking responsibility.
I'm not seeing that as a weakness."
40
The time and attention this is taking is ridiculous. If it were me Holden would have been encouraged to move on. By stopping and inserting himself in police business he incited the officer, which was his intent to begin with. The cop should have given him a minute to get his pack together and move on.
41
by the way, I'd ask Holden, what do you want the Mayor and Chief to do with the officer? Do you want him suspended or fired?
42
@ 40 He "incited the officer" - really? So a reported asking a question is "incitement", like inciting a riot? Wow, the cop must have a really short fuse to get all fired up by a little "incitement".
43
@40: Your first sentence is correct, the rest is foolish. When an officer behaves as obviously inappropriately as Marion, it shouldn't take this much time and attention to make sure he is punished.
44
There's no way this was an isolated incident. I'm sure Marion has harassed dozens of other citizens in the same manner (or worse). Fortunately for us, Marion finally fucked with the wrong person. I hope he's learned his lesson. Another incident like this one and he should be terminated.
45
is the police union trolling slog now?
46
Four the last four years, all we heard from the peanut gallery was incessant whining that McGinn was "divisive" and "thin skinned".
Well, assholes, now you actually do have a thin skinned, divisive little toady running, or rather ruining, the city. Hope y'all are happy.
Murray has quickly proven every negative thing said about him during the campaign.
I have no doubt that he will be judged as the worst mayor in the history of Seattle by the time his one and only term ends.
Here's hoping we can recall him before then.
47
The best outcome for Seattle would be Murray walking against the light while texting and getting hit by a bus. Short of that this city is fucked.
48
@40, Dominic is not the cause of this problem. Officer Marion acted like a sociopath with very real anger management issues. As such, he should not be in a position of protecting the public as a police officer. So yes, he should be fired ...better yet, he should never have been hired in the first place. Seattle PD hiring practices & training are related topics that need to be addressed.
49
One positive thing comes out of this mess: it's clear that sexual orientation is not much of a bar to full participation and opportunity in society. Now gay people have full opportunity to become incompetent political hacks just as straights did forever...
50
@49 ?
51
There still seems to be that Shroud of Silence and Secretiveness with SPD and City's elected and departments as a whole. Never will Trust any of them, Case closed.
52
SEA elected Bertha Knight Landes as Mayor of Seattle in in 1926 and she served this town until 1928.

That is all.
53
@46: "Now, actually"? Make no mistake, McGinn was too, it's not mutually exclusive. They're *both* divisive thin-skinned toadies who claim to be progressive but let SPOG walk all over them and would rather wet their pants than give the Chief a direct order, or stand up for what's right rather than "stand by your man" no matter what. McGinn and Murray, both petulant little primadonnas who don't have a clue how to lead or even simply do the right thing. Needless to say, I voted for Steinbrueck.
54
@40
If you are an officer I hope that you know that you are not allowed to order people off of public property for no reason.
55
@54 & 40: seriously. If tdean is actually an officer (here, there, anywhere) then he needs to watch the Sheriff Urquhart video Dom linked to.

Tdean, you make it sound like you're in law enforcement and if so, then you're a bad apple that needs to go. Everything that Dom did is not just legal, but constitutionally protected, both as a private individual and as a member of the press. If you had done anything other than answer his question about who was in command of the scene, you would have been in the wrong.

If you don't like that, find a new job or another country.
56
Again, Mr. Holden cant forgive can he? No matter what anyone does, it will never be good enough because Mr. Holden has been a cop for years, he knows what it means to be a walking target with a badge on and knows the criminal mind from watching countless hours about it on TV. Mr. Holden has a real sense of civic duty, when really he is just acting obnoxious and looking for a fight, as he probably did on the day he had the run-in with Officer Marion. I don't doubt things were said in the heat of the moment,and surely Mr. Holden is certainly free from that sin but its time to move on. I said it once and I will say it again, when it boils right down to it and a gang-banger is attacking someone, or someone is trying to invade my home, or attempting to rape a woman, I want a cop that isn't afraid to do something about it as opposed to complainer like Mr. Holden who just wants to whip out his camera phone and take pictures. I woe the species and their ignorance of the world sometimes.
57
Does anyone other than me think that a mistake in a public relations speaking incident is not exactly what FDR meant.

Roosevelt: "The country needs and, unless I mistake its temper, the country demands bold, persistent experimentation. It is common sense to take a method and try it: If it fails, admit it frankly and try another. But above all, try something"

Murray: "I am admitting frankly that our method to address accountability and culture change in the Marion case failed. And I am pledging that we will attempt another. And when we do, we will take better steps at involving the community"
58
What up with all the high-powered, expensive, experienced, better than McGinn, brilliant, dedicated policy staff that was hired. Anybody back there? Anybody?....
59
Many of these comments (and, seemingly, the people who posted them) are completely bat guano crazy.

All of you defending the police need to stop. The only thing that cops protect and serve are the interests of other cops. That's truth.

#56 your comments are particularly egregious and naive. I can only hope that if the time arrives, you will get the full experience that the type of cop you describe has to offer. And please, don't try and tell me that the situation I suggest could never arise because you don't decide who gets bitten when a pack of dogs are blinded by rage.



60
"Mayor, Chief Say They Were Wrong to Remove Cop's Misconduct Verdict"

Of course, but they still did it and will still continue to support it.

@6: "Ed Murray is a dumbshit."

Not as much as the Sloggers who proceeded to lecture us on how they voted for Murray (and were therefore better than the rest) because only HE cared about police reform.

Please wait...

Comments are closed.

Commenting on this item is available only to members of the site. You can sign in here or create an account here.


Add a comment
Preview

By posting this comment, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use.