Comments

1
It is interesting that some people ask about another person's past and then don't like the answer.

Don't ask a question if you fear the answer.
2
Yay! A nice simple DTMFA that the person followed through on. Such an improvement from yesterday's clusterfuck.
3
I love a happy ending.

Was the guy Catholic? Sounds like he had Catholic damage, or maybe Mormon.
4
@1,

But then how can you beat the other person over the head with their past for the duration of the relationship?
5
As far as my boyfriend knows, I spontaneously came into existence in the woods, moments before he met me. Nobody tell him otherwise. It would break his heart.
6
First of all, if you didn't get paid you aren't a whore. Whore's are pros. People who just sleep around for free are sluts, and anyone who can't appreciate a slut doesn't deserve to have on in their lives.

7
I don't understand why she needed Dan's stamp of approval to make a choice she was obviously champing at the bit to make. She made the right choice of course, but this decision clearly didn't require feedback. Nice short answer though.
8
@3 - Sounds like generic American male sex hangups to me...
9
@6: Word!
10
@3 and @8: Yeah, it could Madonna/Whore, and/or "The One", and/or something his (bio) mom or a (Catholic) Father told him.

Those are clearly pathological belief systems, but how about the one we all mostly present and that Dan promotes, "Your kids deserve not to be burdened imagining their parents as a sexual beings."? Part of that artificial image of their parents is that mom and dad had no partners before they met. How much does that BS contribute to the myth of "The One" and how the ideal spouse/mother is so chaste? Likewise, that attempted presentation of effortless monogamy contributes more than the media to an assumption that monogamy is easy and completely satisfying.
11
"Men need to believe that they’re Marco fucking Polo when it comes to sex - like they’re the only ones who’ve ever explored new territory. And it’s hard not to let them believe it. I let my boys run with it for awhile - feed them some of that “I’ve never done this before...” bullshit, and let ‘em labor under the delusion that they rockin’ my world, until I can’t stand them anymore. Then I hit ‘em with the truth.

It’s a sick game. The world would be a better place if people would just accept that there’s nothing new under the sun, and everything you can do with a person has probably been done long before you got there."

-from a film
12
Goofy letter... obvious answer... filler?
13
@5 Your boyfriend is a Sasquatch?

Just spitballing who would be out in the woods and would fall for that story...
14
Kids.

I met my wife when we were both in our 30s. We both (correctly) assumed that we had fucked a bunch of people before we started dating each other. We'd be kinda weird otherwise.
15
@11 Chasing Amy, specifically. It's weird that I remember that.
16
"It's all been done before... the lesson every gay man learns after his second theme costume party." - Angels In America, I think. (And I probably got the quote wrong too.)
17
@13 - Yes, he's a Sasquatch. That's what he told me anyway.
18
8, it's not just America. In fact, compared to the rest of the world, we have a good percentage of males who aren't hung up on the Harem trope.

I feel the term "Harem" is more accurate than "Madonna/Whore complex." It is more descriptive of the mania/psychology of chauvinism-- The male can have many female partners, who must be virgin before they met him, and have no partners from now on. Women are there for sex/keeping the house and nothing else. Any males in the picture are threats and must be emasculated somehow. If they're gay, they've taken away the male's power to emasculate, and is thus worse than a threat: they must be exterminated. A man who has sex with an ex (or "former member of the Harem') is getting "sloppy seconds" and is to be derided. Unless they "stole" the female, in which case they are a threat, as well as the "stolen property" which is now a whore.

I could go on, but you get the idea. Harem thinking can be smelled for miles. Ladies, if you get even a whiff, run.
19
Would you hire a carpenter to build your house if he'd never built one before?
20
@6 you made my day!
21
It can be a serious blow to the male ego to realize that some dude fucked your woman much better than you ever could.

Let me tell you, it's nice not to have that problem.
22
Fortunate @6, +1.

[And for the record, I sprang fully formed from the foam of the sea.]
23
Short, quick, to the point. Well done, Dan! (and why she needed his advice to break it off is beyond me. But many people need someone else to tell them about what is in front of their nose it seems.)
24
@22: Wait. I seem to recall reading about that in the paper. Something about a family power struggle and severed genitalia. So you're the product of that whole scene? Wow.
25
BLT! HA HA HA HA HA
26
I hope the dumped boyfriend marries the kind of woman he respects and she's either a "saddle back virgin" that lied about saving it for marriage or a "sex hating, never having it ever virgin" because that's what the jerk deserves. I wish a lifetime of boring vanilla baby-breeding-only sex on this jerk.
27
5, 6, 22 & 24: I heart you so much.
I feel for the letter writer. My first husband had that same hang up. He was much younger than me, and I was his first, so really it was the Harem thing kind of turned on its head in a way I guess. Anyway watching Chasing Amy with him, film which I love, did not go well.
He managed to make me feel bad about being friends with my exes, but since at the time I lost my virginity in 1983 at the tender age of 20 he was 9 years old, trying to pitch that somehow I should have waited for him just wasn't going to fly with me.
28
@9Sounds like generic American male sex hangups to me...

Yup. Speaking here as an atheist who once dealt with having these hangups. Except I didn't try to guilt the other person and kept the problem how it should be: mine and only mine.
29
Sorry, @8 not @9.
30
the madonna/whore complex is a different thing than harem thinking. the madonna/whore complex doesn't necessarily go along with a guy thinking he deserves to have more than one woman at a time, or thinking in terms of more than one woman at all. it's more a thing of how he relates to the woman he's with at the moment. he'll go into one of two modes depending on whether he sees the woman as a cheap woman or an expensive woman. the difference in mode can be pretty marked.
31
saxfan @24, look, I know my family is a mess, but I am sick and tired of this media fucking rumor-mill bullshit!

...sorry. I get a little edgy. This libel case against Cicero is dragging through the courts, and fucking Boticelli--the fucking Medici-Anus-Sucking Fuck of aPaparazzo I...

Jeez, I'm sorry...I gotta go.
32
Good job!
33
@31

Just don't get a migraine.
34
@31 Please don't go. We like it when you come out of your shell.
35
@18 is right, it's not just American men, and it most definitely isn't just Catholics or even "religious" types - my BIL is an asshole of this stripe and an avowed atheist (about the only thing about him I can stand).

@6 - I love my wife dearly, despite a ginormous experience gap, but yes, you are a thousand times correct: people who don't appreciate sluts don't deserve them; pearls before swine, IMHO. Not all of us have an issue with a (more) experienced or freaky partner.

Bottom line: she's happier because she isn't stuck with someone who doesn't respect her - it could simply be looking down on (having contempt for) her for some other reason - financial, religious, etc., differences.
36
BLT can also mean Better Luck Tomorrow which kinda sorta makes sense here.

DS FTAW

*Dan Savage for the Accidental Win
37
@14 Your comment is like the alternate universe version of "How I Met Your Mother," and this pleases me.
38
Of course, the flip side of this particular coin is hopping into bed with someone new and finding out later that they have had a suspiciously low number of partners before you (not in the "I was in a long-term relationship for 10 years so my number is low" way, but in the "practically a virgin" way) and then feeling weird about it forever.
39
@ 34 Alanmt - Botticelli?
40
"Why you wanna ask your woman how many guys she's fucked? 'Cause no matter what she says it's too much for you. She could be like "Two" and you're like "Two?! Two?! Oh no no no no, two?! TWO?! Woo! I guess that's how you was raised."
- Chris Rock, Bring The Pain
41
Ophian: Everybody knows that beings that arise from the foam of the sea on the half shell are aphrodisiacs of the highest order. So...I guess I'm saying I believe your origin story, mon chapeau rose. Happy Valentine's Day, my hot yogic bisexual friend. My llfe is richer for having flirted with you.
42
Hey Ophian-Aphrodite, before any encounters with Ares, don't forget to mangle Hephaestus' nets. That scum knows it was all an arranged marriage, but he would still call the paparazzi to take pictures - he's that kind.

@Alanmt 44 : LOL !

@Fortunate : sooo true !
43
@lolo, smooches to you, mon acajou.

Please wait...

Comments are closed.

Commenting on this item is available only to members of the site. You can sign in here or create an account here.


Add a comment
Preview

By posting this comment, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use.