Comments

2
Honest question, not trying to be snarky or anything, I'm just not familiar with the authority of churches in the matter: Does a church have a say on what straight couples get married in it, or are they obligated to host services for any straight couple that asks?
3
Does Reverend Ken know that lying is a MORTAL SIN?
4
Dear Ken,

My relationship is none of your fucking business. You're going to lose this one.

Crawl back into your hole & worry about your own damn life.

5
@2: A church doesn't have to marry anyone, including straight couples, if they don't want to. I know several couples who were turned away from a couple Catholic churches they wanted to get married in because only 1 of the partners was Catholic, for example.
7
I'm not going to waste my time listening to Steve Scher, least of all Steve Scher interviewing Hutch. But does anyone know, was there any recent marriage ruling in a Hawaii court? Is he just totally delusional? Or misinterpreting a real thing that exists?
8
"Scher was so unprepared for that interview, it was not informative nor compelling. "

So par for the course then. Glad to see he is at least consistent.
10
I'm telling you, Traumatic Brain Encephalopathy among former football players is reaching epidemic proportions.
11
Is Ken Hutcherson really the best voice that those who oppose marriage equality can come up with? I'm 100% for marriage equality but even I can come up with a couple folks who are brighter and more articulate than this guy is. All for the best I suppose. As long as Hutch is the face of those who oppose marriage equality then we shouldn't have a problem if it makes it to the ballot in Nov.
12
Stever Scher and Hutch together?

I'm so happy I don't have to listen to that.

@2 and @7- @9 gives you the Hawaii case and I think there was a similar ruling in Massachusetts. Basically churches aren't required to marry anyone, but if they rent out their facilities then they're operating as a public accommodation and can't discriminate. Lots of churches have reception areas and halls they rent to couples getting married by other clergy or JPs, it's a nice revenue source. So the preacher and congregation aren't being forced to affirm any union (which is why it's not an infringement on their religious right to be assholes), they're just being told that they can't discriminate in their commercial enterprises.
13
The Hutch also made an appearance on Channel 13 news this morning, beating this same old drum...

That reminds me, I need to email their news director and ask why bigots are being allowed airtime in Seattle......
14
@10 For those that wish ill upon Hutch, TBE is the worst thing he could end up with. Unlike cancer, it doesn't kill you, it just makes you want to kill yourself, if you can ever muster the faculty to do so.
15
I do believe that this man just said "brah" non-ironically. I can't handle that.

Of course, he also doesn't seem to know the difference between the courts and the legislature, but that might require some actual research, so that's okay then.
16
There is no way this is an accurate transcript. For instance, it says:
Steve Scher: The governor is going to introduce a bill to legalize same sex marriage in Washington State. It has to be passed by the legislature. What does your legislator think of this bill, do you know yet?


It's just impossible. At best, it was probably more like:
Steve Scher: The, uh, governor is, um, going to, uh, introduce, uh, a bill, um, to legalize, uh, same sex marriage, uh, in Washington, um, State. It, uh, has to, uh, be passed, um, by the, um, legislature. What, uh, does your, um, legislator, uh, think of, um, this bill, or, um, do you, uh, know yet?

17
Even in countries where same-sex marriage is already legal, exactly zero religious entities are required by any law to perform same-sex marriages. Let no one argue otherwise: no church, no synagogue, no mosque, no temple is forced anywhere in the world to perform same-sex marriages. They can if they want, and many choose to, but none are forced to, whatsoever.

In fact, in European countries church weddings aren't even "official": even straight couples must get a civil marriage to be married in the eyes of the government in any European country. They can optionally get a church wedding, as well, to be married in the eyes of their deity, if they wish. But civil and religious marriage are well separated in Europe. Canada does not required any religious institution to perform same-sex marriage, either.

What @12 said is exactly right: churches that rent out space commercially are subject to nondiscrimination laws where they exist, as is the case in Hawaii. But the church can choose not to rent out space to avoid this, and under no circumstances (whether rented out or not) are the congregation or religious officiant required to marry a same-sex couple.
18
Both Hutcherson and Scher are both idiots. Scher needs to be fired from KUOW. He hasn't made a good decision for KUOW since he became the GM.
19
I heard Hutch say that marriage is one man and one woman and has been that way ever since Adam and Eve and that his Bible tells him that this is the only right way. Doesn't his Bible have Abraham (with two wives), Jacob (two wives and two other women), or Solomon (hundreds of wives)?
20
You know who determines if you are married?

The state.

you can get married in a fucking innertube as long as there's a witness and you both sign the license.

Churches are superfluous and have no authority outside their own cult members.
21
@6, the Catholic Charities adoption story is a little more complicated than that. I can't recall all the details, and I don't have time to research it again. The board of Catholic Charities and the hierarchy of the church were at odds over how to proceed. The church leadership prevailed and ended their adoption program. The state did not tell them that they had to close shop, though the state would probably have done so if they insisted on excluding same-sex couples from that point onward. (I probably screwed up my summary somewhere. Like I said, it's a tangled, complicated story. And if I recall correctly, the agency had placed kids with gays prior to the state recognition of same-sex marriage.)
22
@17 Not exactly true... Here in Sweden atleast (its kinda different across Europe) the church has the right to marry a couple, not just perform the ceremony but the actuall legal part, IF it agrees to marry all those eligible for marriage within their own community. They cant be forced to marry those who doesn't share their own religion.

Some churches has declined the right to legally marry to be able to stop gay members of their religions to do it within the church/mosque/synagogue so any ceremony with them must be doubled up with a quick ceremony at the local council house to finish the legal part of it.
23
I thought this piece of shit was dying of cancer?

Please wait...

Comments are closed.

Commenting on this item is available only to members of the site. You can sign in here or create an account here.


Add a comment
Preview

By posting this comment, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use.