My additional two cents:

You (and your partner & friends) have a tremendous gift, of being hiv- (so far in life). Once you lose this you can't get it back. I've had enough friends die of aids who didn't get a choice, who didn't know how its spread and how to play safe. And I have enough friends who are living with hiv and see the shit they have to go through daily and weekly that it's make it hard to imagine that anyone would willingly increase their chances of being infected.

Don't do it.

Tell him he's being stupid.

@3 is right: HIV/AIDS is the gift that keeps on giving --- and there's no return counter.

We've all met those loudly "monogamous" guys who then end up getting HIV, syphilis, etc. etc. How does it happen? Well, most deal with their reckless fantasies by bottling them up tight and not even humoring the thought of what they'd really like to do out loud - it's fear versus lust, and for a long time fear wins. Until one day when lust turns the table for a few hours...and they do something stupid that can't be undone. That "just say no" shit never works.

At least this guy is actively thinking about the fantasy, thinking about the risks, and trying to find a way to accomodate his lust and reduce the danger with some open communication and a few somewhat-intelligent (but not foolproof) precautions.

Is he entering dangerous territory? Absolutely. Is he doing it more responsibly than most? Yes, you clucking hens, he is.

But, one night my partner didn't use a condom with a trick. He didn't tell me. 6 months later he tested positive. We had been barebacking the entire time.

I went through a year of HIV tests waiting for the dreaded result. By some miracle I never seroconverted, while he went downhill rapidly before starting (then brand new) ART therapy.

We broke up, not because of HIV, but because I couldn't trust him any longer, and the strain of repeated testing pushed us both over the limit. We still keep in touch, and although he's still on a drug cocktail, his health is pretty terrible, and has quite a few side effects.

In the past couple years, 16, count them, 16 of my good friends who practice "serosorting" have seroconverted. It's not a very good method of HIV prevention.

Moral of the story: Your one night of fantasy could become a lifetime of regret. Really ask yourself - is a hot one night possibly worth a potentially shortened lifetime of meds and telling people you're positive before sex? If it is, then go for it. Maybe nothing bad will happen. Maybe it will. But there's no going back. And yes, it's a slippery slope. After a hot bareback gang bang do you really think you can go back to condoms and get the same feeling?

(PS I'm not sex-negative or anti-POZ. To this day I am negative and my husband of 8 years is positive. We fuck all the time. We use condoms. They work.)

Good luck, and stay safe.

Thanks for your heartbreaking story. You said it better than I could have.

Way back in the day, when AIDS was new, we dreamed of a day when we would know how this disease was transmitted, and how we could protect ourselves.

When we learned how, we dreamed of day when the rate of new infections would drop to virtually zero, because we'd all lost so many of our lovers and friends.

It breaks my heart to face the reality that so many young gay boys are still getting infected every day of the week, even when we know how to stop getting infected, and its not all that hard to do.

When you are HIV + you lose a lot of your life. Its like having a part-time job that eats up your time and drains your money instead of paying you money, and its a part-time job you can't ever quit.

What won't you be able to do if you are living with HIV, just because you have less time and money to spend on things? Maybe you won't be able to go back to school, or maybe you won't be able to develop as an artist, because what time you do have will be spent on making the rent first, maybe you won't be able to run as a political candidate for a cause you care about.

Yes, there are HIV + people doing all those things and more, and more power to them. But there's no way to deny that living with HIV brings a bunch of challenges and barriers that take more time, money and willpower to overcome.

If the quality of your relationship depends on possibly increasing the risk of you or your beloved partner to this kind of future - especially when you have the choice not to - because fucking without condomns is really so impportant, perhaps you should reconsider your'alls relationship. Usually when people really love and care about each other they want to protect themselves and their loved ones from harm.

Yes, its good to consider your fantasies in a conscious and thoughtful way, and its generally good to ask what other people think about possible choices and mull over their responses. Yes, you are a grown up and will make whatever choices you will.

Many times in life we all are faced with having to make a choice when we don't have enough information. This sounds like one choice where you have all the time in the world to consider the options and the consequences.

I'd say please make darn sure whatever you decide is worth the risk.