Slog News & Arts

Line Out

Music & Nightlife

« I Can't Take It Anymore | Could've Been Worse »

Monday, June 9, 2008

SPD, King County Jail Settle Another Brutality Case

posted by on June 9 at 13:22 PM

It’s time to reset the ol’ Days Without a Settlement clock: The Seattle Police Department has settled another brutality suit for $5,000, this time from a 2006 incident in which a Woodinville man claimed he was roughed up by police. Brad Nebinger, 22, also settled a related suit with the King County Jail last March.

In March 2006, Seattle Police arrested Nebinger—who was 20 at the time—at a downtown Seattle bar for harassment. Police claim the Nebinger resisted arrest, while Nebinger claims officers roughed him up before he was taken to the King County Jail.

At the jail, Nebinger got into a verbal altercation with a jail guard—whom Nebinger called a “faggot”—and was punched in the face by the guard, leaving him bloodied.

Soon after the incident, King County fired the jail guard and last March, paid Nebinger $20,000 to settle his claim. Last week, the city offered Nebinger $5,000 to settle his claim against SPD.

While Nebinger received a relatively small sum from SPD—several attorneys who handle suits against the department refer to small settlements like Nebinger’s as a “nuisance payoffs”—these smaller payouts are building up.

The city has spent more than $400,000 settling misconduct cases since January 2007, and that number will go up to nearly $700,000 if the city doesn’t get a new trial in the Romelle Bradford case. On top of that, the city has paid more than $6,000,000 in legal fees to Stafford Frey Cooper, the law firm that handles SPD’s misconduct cases.

In the end, the city will end up paying an additional $5,000 in legal fees on top of the $5,000 it cost to settle with Nebinger. Maybe it’s time for the city to ask Stafford Frey Cooper about getting a two-for-one deal.

RSS icon Comments

1

I wonder what's got the city is such a settling mood.

Does it look bad for the city to allow five or more years with no effective public oversight and then agree to huge pay raises in exchange for effective public oversight?

It's almost as if they knew they haven't done something they knew should have done.

Posted by six shooter | June 9, 2008 2:16 PM
2

What do you expect to happen if you call a police officer / jail guard a faggot?

I'm going to go out on a limb here and guess that Nebinger was either in Pioneer Square or one of the equally classy joints in Belltown. Maybe Belltown Billiards?

Posted by john cocktosin | June 9, 2008 2:49 PM
3

Nebinger sounds like a first-class toilet bowl, and will no doubt be intimately acquainted with many, many different cops and jail guards in his hopefully short life.

Posted by Fnarf | June 9, 2008 3:32 PM
4

Take note, scallywags: Keep your mouth shut when you're arrested and in jail.

Posted by six shooter | June 9, 2008 3:49 PM
5

Why don't the decent people like packratt get the big money?

Posted by vooodooo84 | June 9, 2008 3:56 PM
6

6 mil in attorney's fee + 700K in payments?

$6.7 million/800k seattle residents = approx. $8/resident.

Posted by max solomon | June 9, 2008 4:16 PM
7

Well, thanks a lot for the math, Max. I want my $8 back.

Posted by Damien | June 9, 2008 4:19 PM
8

John Cocktosin wrote:

What do you expect to happen if you call a police officer / jail guard a faggot?

I expect the reaction to be the same as if he had said just about any other nonsense. Our police have a high-stress job. Part of the qualification for doing that job well is to remain calm and professional in the face of insults from some jackass. That we're paying to settle out of court because some cop couldn't keep his cool is a strong indication that the cop needs to find a different job. We should fire him.

It's not okay for you or I to beat someone because he tossed a juvenile insult at us. (That John thinks it is okay does not make it so, it just makes him equally juvenile.) It's even less appropriate for someone in such a position of authority -- and with such potential for abuse -- as a cop or jail guard to do so.

Posted by Phil M | June 9, 2008 5:11 PM
9

Phil M

Reread the article. Dude was punched out by a jail guard, not a police officer. And yes, there's a difference. Hard to take your opinion seriously when you don't know that.

Posted by snort | June 9, 2008 5:37 PM
10

Snort: I was responding to John's comment, not to the story. I apologize if my quoting John did not make this sufficiently clear. He asked about "a cop or a jail guard".

As for my suggestion that the City's settlement indicates a cop needs to be fired, that was a mistake. Substitute "guard" for "cop" and the rest stands.

I'm tired of this hillbilly "he got what he had coming" attitude that appears every time someone dares to mouth off to someone in law enforcement or the criminal justice system.

Posted by Phil M | June 9, 2008 6:00 PM
11

This could be a trend. A student on the Seattle Central student was recently arrested in a violent manner (witnesses disagree as to whether he 'deserved it' or not).

One activist group and some lefty newspapers are calling it "police brutality." Will this become the next case? Or is Julio Hernandez just lucky if someone can afford to bail him out for $75,000?

Just a week before that, a South Seattle youth won a $269,000 in an excessive force case against the SPD.

Besides the ever-present concerns about racial profiling, can our regional government really afford to treat citizens this way, even if someone pays Hernandez's bail?

Posted by zellers | June 10, 2008 1:54 PM

Comments Closed

Comments are closed on this post.