News Hypocrisy at the PI: Elite Luncheons
posted by May 7 at 10:41 AM
onKenneth Bunting, the associate publisher of the PI, wrote a lengthy editorial last week, “New York Times reasserts its principles,” applauding the New York Times for bowing out of the annual correspondents’ dinners at the White House.
Wrote Bunting:
Rhonda Chriss Lokeman, a columnist for the Kansas City Star, opined during the March discussion that the media’s chumminess with Washington power brokers at such black-tie and white-tie spectacles is wholly inappropriate and unbecoming. Perhaps Lokeman was right. Some journalists manage to transform themselves into Washington socialites at such events. Why should the public think they could be arms-length watchdogs, critics and uncompromised observers at other times? But more interesting will be whether any others among the nation’s media elite follow suit. In what we in Seattle call “the other Washington,” hobnobbing is a well-accepted way of life.
The other Washington? I’ve got three creepy words for you Mr. Bunting: Community Development Roundtable.
As you know, since you’re a member, the CDR is an elitist, private membership group of big business power players like Greg Johnson, President, Wright Runstad & Company; Ada Healey, Vice President, Real Estate, Vulcan Inc.; Stephanie Daley-Watson, VP, Secretary, Assoc. General Counsel, Safeco Corp; Jared Smith, Vice President, Area Manager, Parsons Brinckerhoff; and Don Stark, Managing Partner, Gogerty Stark Marriott; and media leaders Mr. Michael Fancher, Editor-at-Large, The Seattle Times; Ms. Jill Mackie, Vice President, Public Affairs, The Seattle Times; Mr. Mark Trahant Editor, Editorial Page Seattle Post-Intelligencer; and Mr. Emory Thomas Publisher Puget Sound Business Journal, that meets for private lunches at the snooty Washington Athletic Center (WAC) on Mondays.
Its explicit purpose since its formation (by the Chamber of Commerce and the publishers of the dailies back in the 1930s) is to bring together the city’s media, political and business elite behind closed doors for off-the-record discussions and, not coincidentally, to cement the Establishment’s hold over civic affiars. It fosters a clubby atmosphere between the rich and powerful movers and shakers and the top editors and executives of Seattle’s newspapers.
Aren’t the power players on this list, the same people you’re supposed to be covering?
The question, Mr. Bunting, is not whether national media will follow the NYT’s example by pulling out of the once-a-year correspondents’ dinners, but if you will follow your own advice and pull out of the clubby weekly CDR.
I’ve linked the membership list below to give readers a real sense of who the media is hanging out with—I see former Port Commissioner Mic Dinsmore on there.
Mr. Scott Armstrong
President & CEO
Group Health CooperativeMr. William Bain
Consulting Design Partner
NBBJMs. Ernesta Ballard
Sr Vice President Corporate Affairs
Weyerhaeuser CompanyMr. Randy Bannecker
President
Bannecker & Associates Public AffairsMr. Charles Barbo
Chairman & CEO
Shurgard Storage Centers, Inc.Mr. Stan Barer
Chairman Emeritus
Saltchuk ResourcesMr. Chris Bayley
Chair
Stewardship PartnersMs. Debbie Bevier
President
DL Bevier Consulting, LLCMr. Bernt Bodal
Chairman & CEO
American Seafoods GroupMr. Jonathan Bridge
Co-CEO/General Counsel
Ben Bridge JewelerMr. Jeff Brotman
Chairman
Costco WholesaleMr. Kenneth Bunting
Associate Publisher
Seattle Post-IntelligencerMr. Phil Bussey
Senior Vice President Corporate Affairs
Puget Sound EnergyMr. Patrick Callahan
CEO
Urban Renaissance Group, LLCMs. Phyllis Campbell
President & CEO
The Seattle FoundationMr. Bruce Carter
President & CEO
ZymoGenetics, Inc.Mr. Bill Center
Past President
Washington Council for International TradeMs. Lynn Claudon
Principal
Lynn Claudon Consulting, LLCMr. A.M. Clise
Chairman and CEO
Clise Properties Inc.Mr. Arlan Collins
Principal
CollinsWoermanDr. Richard Counts
President & CEO
Puget Sound Blood CenterMr. Don Covey
Chairman (Retired)
Unico Properties, LLC.Mr. Russell Crawford
Partner
KPMG LLPMr. Andrew Dale
Managing Partner
Buerk Dale Victor LLCMs. Stephanie Daley-Watson
VP, Secretary, Assoc. General Counsel
Safeco CorporationMr. M.R. Dinsmore
CEO
Port of SeattleMr. Bob Drewel
Executive Director
Puget Sound Regional CouncilMr. George Duff
Senior Advisor
Greater Seattle Chamber of CommerceMr. James Dwyer
President & CEO
Washington Dental ServiceMr. Mike Dwyer
Shareholder
Lane Powell PCDr. Philip Eaton
President
Seattle Pacific UniversityMr. Karl Ege
Chief Legal Officer
Russell Investment GroupMr. James Ellis
Founding Partner
Kirkpatrick & Lockhart Preston Gates Ellis LLPDr. Mark Emmert
President
University of WashingtonMs. Joan Enticknap
President & COO
HomeStreet BankMr. Daniel Evans
Chairman
Daniel J. Evans & AssociatesMr. Michael Fancher
Editor-at-Large
The Seattle TimesDr. Jack Faris
President
Washington Biotechnology & Biomedical Assoc.Ms. Anne Farrell
President Emeritus
The Seattle FoundationMs. Patricia Fearey
Chairman & CEO
The Fearey Group, Inc.Mr. Jon Fine
President & CEO
United Way of King CountyMr. Tom Flavin
President & CEO
enterpriseSeattleMr. Mike Flynn
Principal
Mike Flynn & AssociatesMs. Petra Franklin
General Partner
Vault CapitalMr. Daniel Fulton
President
Weyerhaeuser Real Estate CompanyMr. Jose Gaitan
Managing Partner
The Gaitan GroupMs. Marcia Garrett
Executive Director
WSU WestMr. William Gates, Sr.
Co-Chair
Bill & Melinda Gates FoundationMs. Donna Giordano
President
Quality Food CentersHon. Slade Gorton
Of Counsel
Kirkpatrick & Lockhart Preston Gates Ellis LLPMr. Mark Gould
Senior VP/Seattle Branch Manager
Federal Reserve Bank of San FranciscoMr. Leo Greenawalt
President & CEO
Washington State Hospital AssociationMr. Frank Greer
Partner
GMMBMr. Scott Harrison
President & CEO
BarclayDeanMr. Randal Hassler
VP, Amgen Washington Site Administration
Amgen Inc.Mr. Ray Heacox
President & General Manager
KING TV, KONG TV & Northwest Cable NewsMs. Ada Healey
Vice President-Real Estate
Vulcan Inc.Mr. John Hempelmann
Chairman
Cairncross & Hempelmann, P.S.Mr. Jerry Henry
Senior Advisor to the Chairman
Puget Sound EnergyMs. Sheryl Hildebrand
Managing Partner, Seattle
Deloitte & Touche LLPMr. John Hough
Chairman
Rockey Hill & KnowltonDr. Lee Huntsman
Executive Director
Life Sciences Discovery FundMr. Keith Jackson
Chairman & CEO
Charter BankMs. Sally Jewell
CEO
Recreational Equipment, Inc.Mr. Peter Joers
President, Bank of America Washington
Bank of AmericaMr. James Johnson
President & CEO
Washington Athletic ClubMr. Gregory Johnson
President
Wright Runstad & CompanyMs. Kate Joncas
President
Downtown Seattle AssociationMr. William Justen
Managing Director, Real Estate
Samis Land CompanyDr. Gary Kaplan
Chairman & CEO
Virginia Mason Medical CenterMs. Carolyn Kelly
President & COO
The Seattle TimesMs. Linda C. Killinger
President
Olympic Consulting Partners, LLCMr. Ken Kirkpatrick
President, Washington State
U.S. BankMr. Charles Knutson
Vice President, Public Affairs
Greater Seattle Chamber of CommerceMr. H.L. (Skip) Kotkins, Jr.
Chairman & CEO
Skyway Luggage CompanyMs. Kaycee Krysty
President & CEO
Laird Norton TyeeMr. Stewart Landefeld
Firmwide Chair, Business Practice Group
Perkins Coie LLPMr. Earl Lasher III
Senior Partner
Lasher Holzapfel Sperry & EbbersonMr. Steve Leahy
President & CEO
Greater Seattle Chamber of CommerceMr. Bill Lewis
President
Lease Crutcher LewisMr. Howard Lincoln
Chairman & CEO
Seattle Mariners Baseball ClubMr. Gary Locke
Partner
Davis Wright Tremaine LLPMs. Kathy Lombardo
Senior Vice President, Manager NW Region
CH2M HILLMs. Jill Mackie
Vice President, Public Affairs
The Seattle TimesMs. Sandra Madrid
Assistant Dean, Students and Community Relations
University of WashingtonMs. Susannah Malarkey
Executive Director
Technology AllianceMr. Jerry McKenna
Vice President, Market Manager
Entercom SeattleMr. Herman McKinney
Executive Dir.
Associate MemberMr. Neil McReynolds
President
McReynolds Associates, Inc.Ms. Mary McWilliams
President
Regence BlueShieldMr. Nate Miles
Director of Government Affairs Western US
Eli Lilly & CompanyMr. William Mohler
President & CEO
KCTS TelevisionMr. J. Shan Mullin
Partner
Perkins Coie LLPMr. Steve Mullin
President
Washington RoundtableMs. Carla Murray
Vice President Operations, NW Region
Starwood Hotels and ResortsMr. Kirk Nelson
President - Washington
QwestMr. John Nesholm
Partner
LMN ArchitectsMr. William Neukom
Kirkpatrick & Lockhart Preston Gates Ellis LLPMr. Clare Nordquist
Director
Cascadia Capital LLCMr. Robert Nuber
Chairman Emeritus
Clark Nuber P.S.Mr. Roger Oglesby
Editor & Publisher
Seattle Post-IntelligencerMr. John Oppenheimer
CEO
Columbia HospitalityMr. Peter Orser
President
Quadrant HomesMs. Patti Payne
Principal
The Payne GroupMs. Pam Pearson
Vice President & General Manager
KCPQ (Tribune Television Northwest)Mr. James Peoples
President, Seattle-Cascades District
KeyBankMr. Bob Peters
Market Executive, Commercial Banking
Bank of AmericaMs. Jennifer Potter
Managing Director, Initiative for Global Development
Initiative for Global DevelopmentMr. Jim Potter
Chairman
Kauri Investments, Ltd.Mr. John Powers
Sr. Managing Dir., State of Washington
Colliers InternationalMr. Arnie Prentice
Chairman & CEO
Kibble & Prentice, a USI CompanyMr. Tom Pursley
Worldwide Partner
Mercer Human Resource ConsultingMr. Bruce Pym
Attorney
Heller Ehrman LLPMr. Bob Ratliffe
Sr. Vice President, Capital Markets
Kennedy Associates Real Estate Counsel, Inc.Dr. V. Lane Rawlins
President
Washington State UniversityMr. John Rindlaub
CEO, Pacific NW Region
Wells FargoMr. Stuart Rolfe
President
Wright Hotels Inc.Mr. Skip Rowley
Chairman & CEO
Rowley Properties, Inc.Mr. Charles Royer
President
The Institute for Community ChangeMs. Judith Runstad
Of Counsel
Foster Pepper PLLCMr. David Sabey
President
Sabey CorporationMr. Stanley Savage
Chairman, President & CEO
The Commerce Bank of WashingtonMr. David Schooler
President
Sterling Realty OrganizationMr. Jared Smith
Northwest Manager
PBMr. Alex Smith
CEO
Kaye-Smith EnterprisesMr. John Spellman
Of Counsel
Carney Badley Spellman, P.S.Mr. William Stafford
President
Trade Development Alliance of Greater SeattleMr. Frank Stagen
CEO
Nitze-Stagen & Co., Inc.Mr. John Stanton
Partner
Trilogy PartnersMr. Donald Stark
Partner
Gogerty Stark Marriott, Inc.Rev. Stephen Sundborg, S.J.
President
Seattle UniversityMr. Paul Suzman
Owner
OfficeLeaseMr. David Tang
Partner
Kirkpatrick & Lockhart Preston Gates Ellis LLPMr. Emory Thomas
Publisher
Puget Sound Business JournalMr. Mikal Thomsen
Partner
Trilogy PartnersMr. Mark Trahant
Editor, Editorial Page
Seattle Post-IntelligencerMr. James Tune
President & CEO
ArtsFundMr. Wes Uhlman
President
Wes Uhlman & Associates Inc.Mr. James Vesely
Editorial Page Editor
The Seattle TimesMr. Jeffery Vincent
President & CEO
Laird Norton CompanyMr. Wally Walker
President & CEO
Seattle SuperSonics & Seattle StormMr. Robert Wallace
CEO
Wallace Properties, Inc.Mr. James Warjone
Chairman & General Partner
Port Blakely CompaniesMr. J. Tayloe Washburn
Executive Committee Chair
Foster Pepper PLLCMr. Bob Watt
VP, Gov & Community Relations
The Boeing CompanyMr. Stephen Welch
CEO
Todd Pacific ShipyardMs. Monica Whaley
Executive Director
National Center for APECMs. Kathleen Wilcox
President & CEO
WSAMr. Bruce Williams
Chairman & CEO
HomeStreet BankMs. Colleen Willoughby
President
Washington Women's FoundationMs. Kate Wilson
President
Washington Council for International TradeMr. Scott Woodward
Vice President for External Affairs
University of WashingtonMr. H.S. Wright III
Chairman & CEO
Seattle Hospitality Group LLC
Comments
Yes, clearly the people who actually run things in this town should follow the open model of the pride parade.
HMMM. I kinda wondered why neither the times nor the pi have run any stories in the past couple of years about the financings and tax impacts of Sound Transit.
Numerous property developers and commercial landlords are on that list. Their wealth shoots up when those trains pump thousands of extra workers downtown daily.
And look at how well the financiers (and general legal services providers) for ST are represented:
Mr. James Ellis
Founding Partner
Kirkpatrick & Lockhart Preston Gates Ellis LLP
Hon. Slade Gorton
Of Counsel
Kirkpatrick & Lockhart Preston Gates Ellis LLP
Mr. William Neukom
Kirkpatrick & Lockhart Preston Gates Ellis LLP
Mr. David Tang
Partner
Kirkpatrick & Lockhart Preston Gates Ellis LLP
Mr. J. Tayloe Washburn
Executive Committee Chair
Foster Pepper PLLC
Ms. Judith Runstad
Of Counsel
Foster Pepper PLLC
Mr. Peter Joers
President, Bank of America Washington
Oh, my gosh! Yes, the fact that a multi-billion dollar project involves banks and lawyers -- conspiracy! The fix is in! They're hiding something from us!
We should just let the trains build themselves, organically.
Dagny Taggart would not approve.
@ 3 wrote: " The fix is in! They're hiding something from us!"
I agree. When the city's power elite wanted SMP to go down in that vote, the dailies published stories highlighting how many years of the tax there would be (50 years, est.) and what the YOE costs would be - about $11.5 billion. Those figures included financing costs and the effects of inflation.
But with RTID and ST2 coming up, the media organs in this CDR have not reported the costs in that way.
I'm with fnarf - the dailies (and entercom - 710 KIRO pimps the upcoming ballot meausre) are slanting their coverage to keep the real financial details of the upcoming ballot measure hidden.
Sarcasm is lost on you, apparently.
I read fnarf sticks quarters up his nose.
fnarf:
Let's say ST2 is approved. Do you agree that it would provide additional taxing authority to ST for spending on projects described in Sound Move? That'd be allowed under sec. 2 of SHB 1396, which passed this past session.
What is your estimate of the sum of the annual tax collections over the next five decades by both ST and RTID over the next five decades (assuming the measure in November passes)?
Look, if you don't have a clue, that's fine too ... just say so.
Sotty, fnarf, I'm with Josh on this one. This is where I came in 40 years ago, except that the movers and shakers met at the Rainier Club then.
Nothing will ever stop power from exercising power, but I want all the daylight on it that I can get, and so should you.
I meant sorry. Fucking typos.
Kenjei: I don't give a fucking shit. I want them to build the fucking train, period. The time for questioning the project is long past. Fucking over a few dollars in the financing plan at this point amounts to sabotage, and I don't like it. I want them to build the fucking train.
Which is not germane to the point I was originally trying to make, which is that the presence of important local figures from politics, banking, and law in a multi-billion dollar civic project is neither surprising or offensive. Who do YOU want to run it, Vern Fonk?
I want them to build an atomic-powered magnetic train!!!1!
Josh, this is interesting. Is this a "Public" council, or funded with tax dollars in any way? Would it not then be subject to the state open meetings laws? Perhaps not, as there are no *current* political officals on the list.
You raise an excellent point about the appearances created by the participation of not only the Times and P-I, but also several broadcast media companies, as well as the Puget Sound Business Journal.
We should not assume there's anything sinister going on, as I'm sure there are a number of very positive things this group promotes for the greater good of the community. But it's very much an all-powerful, well-monied group of people, and it never hurts to have some scrutiny by the Fourth Estate.
What reporter is going to risk their job by taking a critical view of a group in which the people who sign their paycheck is a member?
Maybe The Stranger could dig into the activities of this group a bit more, since no other media here in town is likely to do so.
Oh, and where did you get that list? Seems like a lot of "private" information in there. If this isn't a public council, then are you violating any journalistic ethics rules by publishing all of the contact details (and admin assistants) for this Council?
Uh, those are the same financiers who put together the Seattle Monorail Project's financing scheme. They are now trying to pitch ST2 and RTID. There are less taxpayer protection provisions in this November's ballot measure than there were for SMP.
Fnarf's reaction, while understandable out of a four-year-old (he wants his choo choo, whatever it costs), is not what we need out of voters in the fall. The cost issues need to be vetted well, and that hasn't happened in the mainstream media.
Looks like Josh got turned down at the P-I, which is too bad because we were expecting that big expose on Tim Keck.
Although I somewhat agree with Josh's point about the hypocrisy of Mr. Bunting's editorial -- a simple line disclosing his and other publishers' membership in the CDR would've at least brought some perspective to this piece -- we're taking this a bit too far.
Find me one newspaper whose publisher, executive editor or similar executive isn't involved with at least one civic organization -- be it the chamber of commerce, elks club or anything similar -- and I'll show you a publication that not only is missing stories that occur "behind closed doors" but also isn't doing its part as a local business.
Given the NY Times' recent past -- especially in light of Judith Miller's blunders -- pulling out of the correspondents dinner likely was a good and interesting PR move for the NY Times . And it does bring to light the ethical questions that come with media participation and coverage of these events, as Bunting writes.
But to imply that membership in the CDR constitutes being a part of some secret, hooded clique that decides what's covered in the papers and what isn't is juvenile and absurd. Let's give some credit to reporters for not being weasels.
The dailies aren't reporting on the true costs of RTID + ST2 because the editors are in the CDR.
The dailies aren't reporting on the true costs of RTID + ST2 because the "pro" side of the campaign is buying their silence (both with promises of campaign spending AND promises of post-victory ad purchases).
And FNARF - given the sorry history in this burg of voters being suckered, I strongly suggest you read every damn word of what you will be asked to approve in November. And that goes far beyond the ballot title in your Voters' Guide.
Your response seems selfish, FNARF (I'm sure you didn't mean it that way). This is not about whether any of us personally wants trains. It is about the costs to the poorest in our region of these regressive taxes, versus the benefits to the poorest in our region of the commuter trains. Don't be suckered in by the pitch: "it'll just cost you a latte a day!!!!!" RTID and ST2 is not about you or me. It is about the poorest in our community who don't need more sales taxes heaped on them. If you can't reasonably determine what the economic costs from the taxes would be during the next six decades, then you have no business voting for it (even if the notion of shiny new trains really seems exciting to you).
Just my two cents . . . .
@17: The notion that the daily newspapers are being bought with promises of ST/RTID campaign advertising is pretty laughable. Newspaper ads have only represented a small part of campaign spending in the last 25 years--most of the bucks go to mailing and TV/radio buys.
@3: Monorail conspiracy theories are old and sad. So are old monorail supporters who just can't let go.
Sarcasm fails twice in the same post! Amazing.
I agree with you, J.R.
Old stones, if you're going to demand an absolutely spotless, perfect funding plan, you're going to get nothing. Nothing is what we've had too much of. In fifty years, nobody will give a shit what the ballot initiative looked like; they will, however, be pissed if their train is a half-assed joke line. Besides, we already know that the tax system blows and is unfair. I don't care. JUST BUILD IT.
So, what's the name for the planning cabal of Dick Falkenbury, Peter Sherwin, Grant Cogswell, Joel Horn, Cindi Laws and Dan Savage? The "Back of the Napkin Brotherhood?"
Fnarf, from my experience, people whose sarcasm is continually misunderstood typically need to tone down on or rethink their sarcasm.
"RTID and ST2 is not about you or me. It is about the poorest in our community who don't need more sales taxes heaped on them."
Uh, the poorest - those who need mass transit the most, old stones?
What taxing source would you recommend? Property taxes?
At least business pays about half of all sales tax, and people who don't make a lot don't buy a lot of crap at Restoration Hardware.
The ST trains and commuter buses don't serve the poor (for the most part). They are a commute alternative for middle and upper middle class long-term employees who have jobs in downtown Seattle and Bellevue. Lots of government workers, and MSFT workers if Phase 2 passes. The people who don't make a lot are retirees on fixed incomes, the unemployed, those who get random grey-economy jobs, temp workers, and the self employed. They don't commute. Yet they'd be paying the sales tax on their light bulbs and shoes for their kids and toothpaste and jeans and socks and school supplies. We are near the top of the country in sales tax already, and adding more on this region just for commuter subsidies (and to increase developers' profits) is bad policy and harmful to families.
Hello everyone, wanna be part of some kind of community, possible here? anyone here?
Thanks for posting this, Josh. It is interesting. Especially how not all companies active in this area in particular sectors, be it high-tech, media, or financial, are represented here.
Now if we can get some info as to what are the topics at the meeting, who are the organizers, who attends, etc. maybe from the same source who provided the membership list?
fnarf states he doesn't care and wants "the train" built, yet the same power group killed a project that wasn't a boondoggle, didn't have all these KICKBACKS built into it, and didn't make a bunch of people millionaires - it was called the Monorail project - and would have cost considerable less - been considerably more valuable in the event of natural catastrophes - and riddled with far less corruption (if any at all!).
MSN I NIIPET
MSN
MSN I NIIPET
MSN
MSN I NIIPET
MSN
Hope you come back soon!! notem671
daoq hbgytlec qozsajx dtejzh auyzwx dtyaegwx dpkn
daoq hbgytlec qozsajx dtejzh auyzwx dtyaegwx dpkn
daoq hbgytlec qozsajx dtejzh auyzwx dtyaegwx dpkn
Comments Closed
In order to combat spam, we are no longer accepting comments on this post (or any post more than 14 days old).