Slog - The Stranger's Blog

Line Out

The Music Blog

« The Photos of Alan Chin | The Morning News »

Monday, August 28, 2006

Inaccurate!

Posted by on August 28 at 19:10 PM

GOP Senate candidate Mike McGavick recently apologized for his work on the 1988 Slade Gorton campaign when he ran an ad saying Gorton’s opponent, Mike Lowry, supported marijuana legalization. “We should have pulled it once evidence mounted that [the ad] was not an accurate reflection of his views,” McGavick wrote on his campaign blog last week.

Well, McGavick just released a radio ad accusing his current opponent, Maria Cantwell, of opposing the sales tax deduction on federal income tax—which brings in about $550 on average for Washington residents a year.

McGavick bases this wild claim on the fact that Cantwell voted against extending the sales tax deduction in a recent smorgasbord GOP bill. Of course she voted against it: The bill also included such GOP class warfare goodies as gutting the estate tax on the richest .2 percent of heirs and imposing a tip deduction on wait staff—which would have socked working class wages down to about $2.15 an hour.

Here’s what’s worse about McGavick’s ad: The reason Washingtonians have been able to save an average of $550 a year is because Cantwell struck a bipartisan deal to extend the sales tax deductibility provision in 2003. Meanwhile, she’s the lead sponsor this year, along with Texas Republican Sen. Kay Bailey Hutchison, of a bill that would make the sales tax deduction permanent.

Saying Cantwell is against the sales tax deduction certainly isn’t an accurate reflection of Cantwell’s views.

The Democrats have asked accurate! Mike to pull the ad.

Of course, McGavick is being technically! accurate when he says Cantwell voted against the recent sales tax deduction. But he’s also being disingenuous and uncivil.


CommentsRSS icon

And we all saw it coming a few weeks back when she voted against it!

What a crock.

THIS is what you hammer Mike on. Negative campaigning ain't Washington's style, and negative campaigning that's full of shit is worse. She's GOT to be able to get a few sound bites out of this -- "actually I SPONSORED the bill...."

It's smorgasborg.

I agree that imposing that deduction on wait staff was a really bad idea.

I also agree that "Disingenuous and uncivil" is accurate - however, it comes from the donkey as well as the elephant.

Tell me, Proud Gay Republican, name a recent local Democrat ad or even a public statement that was as slimy as this. I can list a plethora of Republican ads and statements. With this one being tame in comparison.

Are we still talking about gay Republicans? Those poor, deluded souls will be seig heiling the GOP even as the Repubs are dragging them off to the deathcamps. How retro... and insane.

I used the party mascots because I wanted to make the argument to a broader and national scale. Sen. Murray and Cantwell have both conducted decent campaigns, and I can’t recall any mudslinging from them. So I grant you a debate score on that one Tempusfi.

So if you permit me to go nationally, how about that red-herring chase to bring down Cheney and Bush over outing Valerie Plame (who was not in covert status at the CIA) and now it turns out to be former Deputy Secretary of State Richard Armitage. So this whole mess caused a reporter to go to jail, and got a White House aide nailed for lying under oath caused by the ripple effect of a scandal that was never a scandal. This was orchestrated by the Democrats – just as the Republicans orchestrated the excruciatingly long Whitewater goose chase under Clinton. See? I’m fair.

Andrew: Step out of your recycled hyperbole and realize that although Republicans have more homophobic party members than Democrats, courageous gays and lesbians are making inroads into the party. Why? Because our political dispositions are no longer satisfied by the cynical, anti-capitalist, nanny-state left wing that has taken over the party and that, most dangerously, are dragging their feet in acknowledging that we’re in a world-wide war against Islamic Jihadits. To resurrect a famous Reagan quote: I didn’t leave the Democratic party, the Democratic party left me. Only the most cynical gays bash the Log Cabin Republicans. Get hip dude!

It's smorgasborg.

No, it's not.

The Log Cabin Republicans are making inroads in the party? What planet are you living on?
Why would you want to be a member of the GOP when they hate us, condemn us and wish that we would have the good manners to simply cease to exist since they can't legally exterminate us (yet!).
As for the "cynical, anti-capitalist, nanny-state," perhaps you're referring to countries like Canada that have universal health care, gun control, same sex marriage, respect for human rights and international law, high education standards, less economic polarization, longer paid vacations, state paid maternity leave, and on and on. Canada is what the US would be like if the US weren't run by a group of deranged, hypocritical, doublethink liars straight out of 1984.
The GOP claims they're the party of small government, morality and fiscal responsibility when over the last five years they've increased the size and spending of the government to astronomical levels, systematically killed countless innocent civilians, and installed a totally illegal and unconstitutional domestic surveillance and spying system. They claim to be super patriots while shredding the Constitution and the Bill of Rights. They have nothing to offer gays and lesbians or anyone else for that matter. How fanatical do you have to be to constantly accept the fact that they always do the opposite of what they supposedly stand for? We need real solutions for the nation's problems and those will absolutely never come from the GOP.

So if you permit me to go nationally, how about that red-herring chase to bring down Cheney and Bush over outing Valerie Plame (who was not in covert status at the CIA)

Too bad for you the CIA disagrees with your ill-informed assessment.

So this whole mess caused a reporter to go to jail, and got a White House aide nailed for lying under oath caused by the ripple effect of a scandal that was never a scandal.

"Outing covert agents is never a scandal." Sheesh.

Especially one who worked on WMDs in the Middle East. But, I guess that sort of intelligence wouldn't be useful right now...

There's arrogance. And then there's Republican arrogance. It's even more so. With a tinge of massive incompetence and overwhelming debt for all but the incredibly wealthy.

The Swedish word is smörgåsbord. Note the d.

And outing a CIA agent causes people to die, people who have been seen talking to her. Gay Republicans are almost as stupid as black Klansmen.

I can't help but recall lesbian author and political commentator Tammy Bruce when she said something like "its far easier to tell other Republicans that I'm gay than to tell other gays that I'm a Republican."

Well, why don't you go do that then?

PGR,

This is in no way an attack on you personally, but it simply makes no sense to support a group of people who are actively trying to destroy you and the rest of us, too. The Republicans will NEVER disavow their anti-gay policies, because ignorance, hate and fear have been enormous cash cows for them, as well as generating huge turnout at the ballot box. They've controlled the Federal Government now for five years, and it's been an unqualified disaster. Not to even mention the outrageous lies and doubletalk that we're subjected to on a daily basis. They do the exact opposite of their stated beliefs. To paraphrase Ronny, I think it's fair to say the Republican Party has left you. Reward them with your vote when they actually implement laws and policies that benefit you as a PGR and they stop demonizing gays and lesbians.

PGR is a troll. Trolls like attention. That or seed.

Andrew: I used to have the same political sentiments as you do. But I kept an open mind. Instead of responding to your last post, why don't you take a few minutes and peruse http://online.logcabin.org and get back to me?

George W. Bush is indeed an arrogant, sanctimonious, and has committed blunder after blunder. Each party has their unsavory elements and I'll grant you that the GOP has more than their fair share. But I'm not going to sacrifice my political leanings just because of the venomous religious right wing of the party. It's too big of a party and too important of a party. Think how great it would be if a gay friendly Republican was running for President against a gay-friendly Democrat running for President. Doesn't it make sense to strengthen our community in both sides?

Will in Seattle: You are the troll, since all I get is crap from you and nothing of substance.

Want an example of a gay friendly Republican? How about Rudy Giuliani? Perhaps John McCain. You can probably add to the list Gov. George Pitaki and Gov. Mitt Romney.

Yes, they don't support gay marriage but neither did Bill Clinton, Al Gore, or John Kerry.

Another fact: Over 1 million gays voted for George W. Bush in 2000.

So, dear Andrew, you can see how important it is for BOTH PARTIES to be lobbied by gays and lesbians.

<a href=http://erosive-esophagitis.net>erosive esophagitis</a> all about

Comments Closed

In order to combat spam, we are no longer accepting comments on this post (or any post more than 45 days old).