Slog - The Stranger's Blog

Line Out

The Music Blog

« CHAC's Last Season | Bad Comet »

Wednesday, June 7, 2006

Conflict. Of. Interest.

Posted by on June 7 at 11:36 AM

Modern Art Notes is lighting up the blogosphere this morning with the revelation that NY Times stringer critic Grace Glueck is a trustee of the Clark Art Institute in Williamstown, Mass.—in direct violation of the Times’s ethics handbook, and laying open to question the respectability of its culture desk. (As if the Times needs another Jayson Blair/Judith Miller.) MAN is calling for a response from the paper. NY dealer Edward Winkleman has a great, tortured post about it all: he’s horrified, but holding back for fear of retribution toward his gallery, which recently received a glowing review from a Times critic. “I want this to be a big misunderstanding,” he writes.


CommentsRSS icon

I think that such stringer art critics should always be regarded with suspicion.

Many of these so-called writers are simply people looking for positions at museums or other arts organizations. Their main objective is to curry favor with those individuals who might aid their careers as curators or administrators.

There are even examples of such people in our community, although the publications thay write for have little "respectability."

Grace Glueck may officially be a "stringer" but she has been a regular Times art critic for decades. I don't suspect she's looking for something beyond the general adulation and respect we all crave but the point here is that, intended or not, her board position muddies the water and puts into question her objectivity as an art critic (and, as Tyler/MAN points out, the integrity of the Times).

But, really, why is the blogosphere up in arms about this? Glueck is an intelligent, gracious, respected critic -- I don't think anyone is accusing her of malfeasance (not yet, anyway). It's hardly "Jayson Blair/Judith Miller" territory. Glueck should resign from the Clark board and apologize. And, yes, the Times has a little explaining to do -- good that folks are keeping an eye on them.

Comments Closed

In order to combat spam, we are no longer accepting comments on this post (or any post more than 45 days old).