Slog - The Stranger's Blog

Line Out

The Music Blog

« Bad News for Rove's Election P... | Sugar Ain't So Sweet »

Friday, June 2, 2006

Coming Down/Going Up

Posted by on June 2 at 12:40 PM

Future installments of this column will delight in the conflicts that accompany major construction projects in Seattle, but our first stop, First Hill, is an exception to that rule. Here at least, developers are welcomed — or at least those who have the good sense to consult with neighbors before they call in the backhoe.

Says Michael Gray of First Hill Home Improvement Association, “We want a mix of housing. We have very high-end housing and we have low-end, but we don’t have much in between.”

Until now or very, very soon. First Hill’s got the boomingest condo market in the city, and most of these new buildings are targeting young Seattle professionals who make around $50,000. I’ve snapped pictures of all the ground zeroes. Next to those I’ve pasted artists’ renderings of the future project. Yes, this is illustrated land use wonkery.

In this post I’m only covering the major residential projects. There’s an expansion project at Harborview, as well as one at Virginia Mason, but as you’ll see we have more than enough condos and assisted living communities to discuss. I don’t want to clog the Slog, so the slide show presentation starts after the jump.

The biggest construction quagmire on First Hill is this intersection of Marion and 8th Avenue, designated as a pedestrian corridor in the neighborhood plan. This picture is looking northeast, so downtown is behind you.

8th and Madison.jpg

The construction you can see is the M Street project. A mixed-use building, it will top off at 15 stories and on the ground floor will be an urban market of roughly 12,000 feet. Tom Warren, president of Holland Development, partnering in this joint venture with Opus Northwest, says the firms are recruiting an independent grocer for that space. Gray says his fellow First Hill residents are thrilled at the prospect of finally being able to buy their groceries close to home. Above the market there will be 220 residential units.

For more recent news on the urban market, see this June 21 Slog post.

Here is a view of the project from the Seattle First Presbyterian Church parking lot, which is kitty corner across Madison and 8th:

8th and Madison C.jpg

And this is an artist's rendering of the finished product.

M Street Project AR.jpg

Holland and Opus (please resist the Richard Dreyfus joke here) are taking bids next week and the building's buyer will be able to decide whether the units will be condos or apartments. Warren says that either way, this building already has a demographic in mind: "We're really looking for people who value an established neighborhood, and this building is well-suited to professionals in the medical field young doctors, nurses and clinicians, as well as for young people who work in the financial field downtown.”

Across 8th Avenue at that same intersection with Marion an 8-story condo will begin construction next February. Here's what that site looks like right now -- we're looking northwest, so downtown is to your left.

901 8th Ave B.jpg

That brick building on the right side, adjacent to the parking lot, is going down. Of all the residential developments, this one is more modest, and prices will reflect that. Says Martha Barkman, project manager for the developer, Harbor Properties: "We're deliberately not building to the 160-foot height limit so we can keep the units affordable.” The building will sell to buyers with incomes ranging from $40,000 to $65,000. It will have 90 condo units in all.

There is room for about 2,500 square feet of retail space on the ground floor. "We'd love to do a coffee shop, but we're exploring what the neighborhood needs,” says Barkman, adding, "the neighborhood needs a hangout.”

Alas, Barkman says she doesn't have an artist's rendering to share. She says the building will be finished by the end of next summer.

Just one block south on 8th Avenue, at Columbia Street, is the site of what will be Skyline at First Hill, built by the nonprofit Presbyterian Retirement Communities Northwest. The $198-million project will take up all four sides of a city block, up to 9th and south to Cherry. Here's the view from 8th and Cherry.

710 8th Ave E.jpg

The Capri Apartments (just visible on the right side of the above picture) will be demolished. Marketing director Lee Blanchard said that a 26-story tower will rise from this location and that up the hill onto 9th Avenue there will be another 21-story tower. According to the group's presentation to First Hill residents, the complex will house seniors from independent living to assisted living, assisted living memory support (Alzheimer's and some dementia care) and skilled nursing. Construction will begin early next year and the facility is due to open in early 2009.

There will be ground-floor retail but Blanchard says it's too soon to know exactly what kind. Since the buildings' design remains a work in progress, no artist renderings have been released.

Staying on 8th Avenue, but two blocks north of Madison, a 23-story condo only just yesterday submitted a master use permit to build on 802 Seneca, kitty corner from Town Hall. This picture was taken from Town Hall's front step.

802 Seneca B.jpg

That brick apartment building is doomed, and the new condos will also absorb the adjacent parking light, on the right side of the above picture. Freeway Park is off the left side of the photograph, and by building open space and a pedestrian walkway into the park (as well as making their condos affordable to moderate incomes) the California-based developer, Levin Menzies & Associates, was allowed to exceed the 160-foot height limit, up to 240 feet. Freeway Park preservationists support the project, which would look like this -- this drawing is also from the vantage point of Town Hall:


06 02 27 RENDERING Seneca Tower sm.jpg


Like other developments, this one is targeting young professionals. "We're looking for a buyer who is working downtown, who walks to work,” says Bob Kagan of Levin Menzies. "Young and maybe married, about 25-40 but probably doesn't have children. This is kind of entry level housing.”

No final word yet on what type of retail will occupy the 1,500-1,800 feet of space on the ground floor, but Kagan expects a coffee shop or small restaurant.

Three blocks north, near the intersection of University Street and Terry Avenue, construction has begun on the expansion to Horizon House, an assisted living community. Here's what that site looks like today downtown is to the right.

Horizon House F.jpg

Also, here's a link to the live construction web cam. When finished, the building will be 19 stories high with 100 apartments, and it will look something like this.

Horizon House AR.gif

Heading up the hill and back toward Seneca at the intersection of Boylston, you'll arrive at the ambitious Skygarden project. Here is what the site looks like today:

1321 Seneca.jpg

That homely little building is going down and a tall, leafy one will grow in its place. The design plan, by Arca Architecture, calls for a 22-story, 97-unit condo tower. And as its name implies, all four faces of the building will be wreathed with lush plant life a different species depending on the height. In community meetings, First Hill residents have expressed concern that the building's future residents will not be up to the challenge of tending their plants; but Arca's Kyle Clark says his firm is working with landscape professionals to ensure that the distinctive plant life is sustainable.

Arca has only recently finished an artist's rendering of the project, and we're glad to show it to you first.

FirstHillSkygarden.jpg

OK, so the "leafiness” is hard to detect from that shrunken photo. Trust me, it's there.

Kitty corner from this building, at the corner of Boylston and Spring, this parking lot...


1400 Boylston B.jpg


will become....


The Boylston.jpg

The Boylston! A 43-unit luxury condo that promises to open by next summer, if you can believe that, which you shouldn't. This project remains somewhat speculative, and expect the developers to push back that completion date soon.

Phew! That was a lot of work. Sorry, but next week we'll focus on one, maybe two projects. Feel free to play armchair archtect on the projects above. And I'm still taking suggestions for next week's column. Put your suggestion in the Comments thread or email it to me at tfrancis@thestranger.com.


CommentsRSS icon

cool. but "First Hill Skygarden.jpg" is just text ....

firefox tells me the image contains errors ... but IE will load it ... nope never mind.

fix it yo, this sounds fascinating.

Fixed!

I'm curious how much a condo aimed at professionals w/ a $50,000 annual income actually costs. Are these professionals expected to spend half their income on the mortgage payment? Are they expected to have a $70K down payment lying around that they didn't happen to spend on the educations that professionalized them in the first place?

I'm not writing out of any kind of resentment here - I am an owner myself. However, I was barely able to buy something near downtown Seattle eight years ago, feel lucky I did, and wonder how anyone can now.

So I'm curious - do people earning about $50K regard the developer's stated goals as pure horseshit? Who's the real target buyer? A childless couple earning a combined $120K?

All development is good, let developers build as high as they want to. If we wanted to read people whining about developers, we can read the washed up hippies in Seattle Weakly.

Bravo Tom. I'll anxiously await round two...

Nice job...

just wondering, though - is this the "future" of Seattle architecture that Mudede thinks we should all feel so thrilled about? If so, especially considering that artists' renderings always look better, then it should be back to the drawing board for these money grubbing hacks....

I love this feature. Thanks for adding it!!

That's a real nuanced understanding of complicated land use matters you're displaying there, density.

Not.

Can anyone say "Dot-Condo"?

I'm not convinced, this looks like speculative investment at the peak of the bubble... $50,000/yr., barely, if these young-urban-go-getters are willing to bet their financial life on crazy ARM/interest-only/neg-amortization loans... rates are going up, and pretty soon no one will be able to afford these...

I'm betting half of these don't get built when prices start tumbling...

Miami, Vegas, San Diego and D.C. are already facing the Dot-condo bust, Seattle's just late to the party

I disagree, Matt. Seattle has what the cities you mentioned do not: regional job growth in excess of 50,000 annually (we're not talking McJobs either), contrained supply (physically as in water/mountains and legislatively via the GMA, stringent regulation, etc.), and surging demand. The market will continue with appreciation rates of at least 10% for at least the next few years... Bet on it.

My partner and I made a combined $60K when we bought our condo two years ago—it was a stretch, but we were able to afford a place that was $180,000, plus dues of $250 a month. So we were laying out about $1350 each month. We put next to nothing down—$5K total, including closing costs.

But interest rates have ticked up since then—so I'm guessing $50K a year would buy you a place that's about $160 or 170K? I'm guessing that'll be a tiny studio in a new development (ours is a tiny 600sf one bedroom in an old building.)

Sorry, High-Rise, but the 'limited-land' arguement fails when you look at the Japanese-Tokyo Real Estate collapse of the early-nineties, worse still is that our growth has been spurred by cheap-money via Greenspanonomics... surging demand=cheap money (but not for much longer... 30yr. at 6.67% today)

But you're right, they're not McJobs, the largest growth in new jobs to the area is construction... hmmm, 2 and 2 says that the surge is due to the condo-boom construction, sustainable? not really...

10% for the next few years? Sounds like you've been talking to a local Realtor, who really are no better than used car dealers in this town...

I used to live in First Hill, and the biggest problem with living there (or at least, living in the south part of First Hill) was that there was no grocery store. The closest one to me was Uwajimaya, which was not too much closer than the QFC at Broadway and Pike.

Something to note about the first project listed here is that it used to be the site of a grocery store. It was torn down to build condos years ago (before I lived there), but the project was stalled after they had already turned it into a big construction pit. This was at the start of the most recent recession, and they had supposedly decided to wait until the condo market came back. It was a constant complaint at the local neighborhood meetings that we didn't have any local grocery store (keep in mind hardly anyone in this neighborhood has a car). Obviously the developers now believe the condo market has come back.

Speaking as someone who no longer lives there (and who recently lost his apartment to a condo conversion), I think this will be good for the neighborhood. The only things going for it before were the very low rents and proximity to downtown. Hopefully when there are more people living there, there will be more retail that isn't just oriented towards the hospital workers.

BTW I doubt they're serious when they say they're targetting people making 50k... I make a little less than that and there are basically no new developments aimed someone like me. I can still find places affordable to me, but it's all in old buildings.

It's not that hard to make 50k a year in this town. I moved here from Milwaukee and expected a much denser downtown. It's good to see them tearing down a lot of the old crap to infill with condos. When they run out the renters (who are usually poor) and get more condo owners in there, a Whole Foods can set up shop. Look at Portland's Pearl district and the beautiful Whole Foods they have. Can't wait till Seattle is like that.

I am an owner on Capitol Hill and have noticed the recent "building boom". I wish there was something we could do to prevent classic, quality brick buildings from being knocked down for new, cheaply built and thrown together "urban living centers". I like the general idea of those places, but do not understand the logic of continuing to tear down and destroy parts of the small history this city has. Save the classic buildings! Save the Seattle style! Soon, we are going to be living in a manufactured urban hell hole if we don't preserve what is left of classic architecture in our town.

Cry baby Architects who won't tear down the old crap that's clogging up Seattle are the ones holding our city back. Density means better restaurants, better nightlife, and higher pay. Brick buildings are dangerous in earthquakes, tear them down.

If this continues unabated you will have a soulless city like Dallas or Houston that is dull and unremarkable. Please don't let that happen. Seattle has been a great place to hang out and have fun. Fight the developer's with all you have or before you know it, that culture will be replaced by glass and steel.

Love this new feature, keep up the good work!
People tend to be alarmist in Seattle -- the chances of this city becoming another Houston are nil. Choose your preservation battles wisely. Just because a building is older doesn't mean it is worth saving. But I'd still say I'd be very happy to see all these damn parking lots in Seattle built up before older buildings are torn down. Why does this city have so many parking lots?!

Sure all this fancy crap will go to rich people but what the fuck, then the slightly less fancy crapola will be availabe to everybody else. So who gives a shit build build build...If we finally get enough houseing in this burg thats the only thing that will bring prices down.Mostly this stuff looks pretty sharp actually.

Sure all this fancy crap will go to rich people but what the fuck, then the slightly less fancy crapola will be availabe to everybody else. So who gives a shit build build build...If we finally get enough houseing in this burg thats the only thing that will bring prices down.Mostly this stuff looks pretty sharp actually.

Sure all this fancy crap will go to rich people but what the fuck, then the slightly less fancy crapola will be availabe to everybody else. So who gives a shit build build build...If we finally get enough houseing in this burg thats the only thing that will bring prices down.Mostly this stuff looks pretty sharp actually.

Sure all this fancy crap will go to rich people but what the fuck, then the slightly less fancy crapola will be availabe to everybody else. So who gives a shit build build build...If we finally get enough houseing in this burg thats the only thing that will bring prices down.Mostly this stuff looks pretty sharp actually.

All the buildings proposed look like condos that now exist in the model city for this type of development "Vancouver Canada". Recently a conference was held in Vancouver so that representatives from other major cities all over the world could attend so that they could see how Vancouver had "turned itself around" and reinvented itself by building condos catering to high income earners. The problem discovered is that building mainly for high income people leaves you with a lifeless city but having low income and middle income housing mixed with expensive new development gives viability to neighborhoods. This key point is usually lost on high income home owners that usually want a "hip" environment that caters to there lifestyle only. Recently a typical slogan for a Vancouver development was "Be Bold or move to the suburbs". Hardly a welcoming slogan but that is the attitude of developers and planners wanting to make quick cash redeveloping an area for socalled "hip" buyers. First Hill seems well on it's way to becoming a "hip" neighborhood with like minded "hip" tenants not wanting anything but "hip" stores and coffee shops. Once this ball is rolling a city plagued by fast highrise condo development geared to high income earners becomes lifeless and boring. I know because even though I enjoy some of the new development in Vancouver Canada everything was build based upon how great a rendering looks but no attention was payed to the soul of the city at street level. The writing is on the wall for Seattle, most of the cool things I always loved about Seattle that let me have a great break form Vancouver are disappearing fast it is becoming like and other city with no style of it's own. All the sub cultures that the city had are being eroded and replaced by instant "hip" developments. With no sub culture you have no real development and sustainability of existing culture that gives a city it's flavor and style. Something you can not buy at a hip store or cafe.

Trader Joe's is in negotiations for the grocery space.

Wow. I have to say I don't make 50K a year and I work for a corporation that is going to be closing it's NW Call Centers down. My rent is going up and I have lived on the Hill for a couple of years. The good news is now we are going to finally have a grocery store close by, that would kick ass! However where are "the young urban career folks" supposed to go. I live alone and am single, and barely making 40K a year. Now I am feelin a lil depressed....I make too much for low income housing, but not enough, clearly, for these condos. I sure as hell don't want to live in the suburbs..oi vey.

Hi ! Your site is very interesting. Thank you.

Comments Closed

In order to combat spam, we are no longer accepting comments on this post (or any post more than 45 days old).