Slog - The Stranger's Blog

Line Out

The Music Blog

« Mommy Dearest | Shrink, Dink, Drink »

Thursday, March 2, 2006

American Bloodbath

Posted by on March 2 at 16:06 PM

This is what the glamorous French philosopher Bernard-Henri Levi had to say about the recent race riots that rocked France (the whole Stranger interview is here).


[You asked if] I found these riots American? Of course yes, and that is what I said, by the way, to my fellow citizens. I told them and I told Americans, who also failed to discover the meaning of the riots. They were full of scandalized articles about the riots in Paris slums, and so on. Remember Los Angeles, and not only Los Angeles but also remember Detroit! Americans have a short memory sometimes, and they should have known that the French behavior had one advantage over the American one: No one died, no bloodbath. You had a bloodbath in L.A. 10 years ago. You know that better than me. Thirty or forty dead. Maybe more. But in France, no one.


CommentsRSS icon

What's different between LA and the Paris banlieus is that everyone in America knows about, or thinks they know about, Watts, hardly anyone in this country, even people who've been to France a dozen times, is more than dimly aware that these places exist.

When we think of Paris we think of the Seine and the Eiffel Tower and sidewalk cafes and so on. And of course those places exist, and Paris is a real city even in its tourist center. But no one ever visits the ring suburbs. Serried ranks of crumbling concrete tower blocks stretching as far as the eye can see; they don't appear in Rick Steve's guides, even though every European city has them. They're not just full of Muslims, either; they're home to the native-born poor, including the most virulent white racist blockheads you could ever imagine.

So when they erupt into flames it's a surprise, because we didn't know they were there. It's not a short memory for problems here; we do remember those. Levi may be "glamorous", but his ability to travel through a country without actually seeing anything isn't as different from America as he supposes.

Of course it doesn't help that America is armed to the teeth. One of the most common images from the LA riots was Korean store owners with assault weapons trying to keep thousands of similarly armed rioters at bay. I'm pretty sure French households aren't mini-armories like American homes are, but if they were, their riots definately have been lethal. I think the weapons, more than French "behavior" played a bigger role in keeping these riots non-lethal. Of course, this is the French we're talking about, and as the Germans found out, they aren't too dangerous, even WITH guns.

One man was beaten to death during the riots. Considering that the riots lasted for weeks, that's still pretty amazing.

I'm pretty sure that American slums aren't included in any tourist guides.

Bernard-Henri Levi should stick to modeling white dress shirts and keep his big mouth shut. That "Who killed Daniel Pearl" was just garbage. He sure is glamourous but the guy is a lazy fake.

"I'm pretty sure that American slums aren't included in any tourist guides."

Yes they are. It's a thriving industry in New Orleans right now. America has shed more light on their slums than any other country, since the time of Jacob Riis, and people are aware of them.

mas oui --

Lived in Paris many years, always in the rings - en banlieu - no they are not horrible, just working class.

The center of Paris is like all mega Euro cities, expensive beyond belief.
Royals, corporate top level, old and new riche - no one on this blog woud lives en ville centre.

Few guns- but les Gendarmes, so very handsome are armed to the teeth with machine gus and absolute power. There is no Bill of Rights in France. The police are largely State Police, not local, and brutal if they chose, with no questions asked.

It is simple, Americans do not value life. We have never had the terror of war, over and over- plus part of our culture values the kiiller cop, killer gangster, killer robot, killer etc.

Let's not be stupid, we do not value life enough to have a fully comprhenisive national insurance plan. Europeans of all stripe cannot comprhend why the American public has allowed this sad state of affairs- no national health plan with such vast wealth.

Of course, it is not rational. Let the poor die. Very American.

The beauth of Paris as a Grande city is astonishing. So much of anything. And the Parisians love their town.

I think even the French themselves are not fully aware of the situation in their suburbs or they are choosing to ignore it. This is partly why these riots happened, because issues like unemployment and lack of educational opportunities for these people is largely being ignored by the French government. Take the responses of the French governement officials during the riots, they were not willing to look at the conditions happening in the suburbs that caused the violence, they complete wrote these people off and refused to consider the situations that caused these people to riot in the first place.

Comments Closed

In order to combat spam, we are no longer accepting comments on this post (or any post more than 45 days old).